Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Sister Bay

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

The living area features warm wooden beams and a stone fireplace, creating a cozy atmosphere. Large windows provide natural light and a view of the outdoors. Comfortable seating is arranged with a sectional couch, two chairs, and a coffee table, inviting relaxation.

Cottage in Ellison Bay

Pet-Friendly, Cozy Cottage in Northern Door County

- Pet-friendly, 2 bedroom home in Northern Door County - Indoor fireplace and outdoor bonfire pit (wood provided) - Beautiful screened porch to enjoy nature - 5 minutes from famous Curvy Road, Washington Island Ferry, Newport State Park & Europe Bay Beach - Short drive to neighboring villages - Sister Bay, Ellison Bay, Baileys Harbor, etc - Walk or bike (provided) to Hedgehog Harbor - Includes all amenities to make you feel at home - Need more space? Check out our neighboring cottages next door.

A charming cottage features a distinctive turret, with a textured gray exterior and decorative trim. Soft lighting from the porch illuminates the entrance, creating a welcoming appearance. Lush greenery surrounds the home, highlighting a manicured lawn and pathways leading to the entry.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

Private 3BR Gem on 2.5 Wooded Acres- Close to All

Hinter Haven Cottage A place of solitude, beauty, and peacefulness—Hinter Haven Cottage is your perfect Door County getaway. This charming 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom retreat is tucked at the end of a private drive, surrounded by a quiet woods. You’ll feel worlds away, yet be just minutes from Door County’s most beloved villages and attractions. Thoughtfully maintained and protected with Mosquito Squad services for your comfort. Relax, recharge, and make lasting memories. Book your stay today!

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 273 reviews

A quaint cottage stands surrounded by snow-covered trees, with a light grey door and window accents visible. The structure features a simple white exterior, complemented by a winter landscape of freshly fallen snow, creating a serene and peaceful atmosphere.

Guesthouse in Fish Creek

Vintage Mod Cottage with fireplace & soaking tub!

Grandview Farm Cottage is a circa 1920s newly renovated, 420 sq. ft. private guesthouse on the grounds of a 2.5 acre Door County property built in the late 1800s. Modern, industrial and repurposed style meets vintage farmhouse charm. Central location allows for quick drive or even a bike ride to either coast of the peninsula. Enjoy nature, wildlife, your own organically grown gardens, and dark starry night skies, while being only 3 miles to nightlife and shopping and beaches and parks.

A private outdoor space is depicted featuring a pergola over a circular stone fire pit area. Surrounding greenery provides a natural backdrop, while patio seating is arranged nearby, inviting relaxation in a serene environment.

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 115 reviews

Maple Cottage, Cute & Cozy, steps to downtown.

Very cute and cozy home to enjoy Door County from. Large, private back yard with pergola and plenty of patio seating including a fire pit area. Charcoal grill on site. Home is centrally located between Washington Island and Egg Harbor. It's within .4 mile walking distance to downtown Sister Bay. Great place to get away and relax and still have the fun of the restaurants and shops nearby. This is our home away from home and we hope it will be yours too. (Maple Cottage RT-364)

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 358 reviews

A spacious wooden deck overlooks the tranquil waters of Lake Michigan, featuring a round table surrounded by black metal chairs. Long benches line the edges, offering additional seating. Lush greenery can be seen along the shoreline, enhancing the serene atmosphere.

Home in Baileys Harbor

Never Want to Leave Cottage

Three bedroom, lake home on the shores of Lake Michigan. Step into a beautiful, comfortable, clean environment on quiet North Bay in Door County, Wisconsin. As hosts, we have always taken great care to provide a safe and clean environment for our guests. To protect our guests, we are following the cleaning and sanitizing guidelines based on recommendations from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC). We look forward to hosting you! Permit Number: 32-56-1996-00

A charming cottage features a two-story design with a covered porch. Lush green landscaping, including hydrangea bushes, surrounds the entrance. The exterior showcases a mix of light-colored siding and a dark shingled roof, set against a backdrop of trees.

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Cozy Cottage in the woods

New Renovations Jan 25: Windows, New Wall Unit AC, Updated Bathroom. Welcome to Hydrangea Haven. A cozy (1200 square ft) cottage tucked away on a quiet peaceful road, but close to all the fun. Nestled 3 miles north of sister bay, between Sister Bay and Ellison Bay. Bike down the low traffic beach road to all that downtown Sister Bay has to offer. Cozy up with the indoor fireplace, Adirondack chairs around the outdoor fire pit. NOTE: we are a 10 min DRIVE to beach not walk.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

A bright living space features modern furnishings arranged for comfort. Large glass doors provide a view of the lake and outdoor deck. Natural light fills the room, highlighting the soft area rug and contemporary chairs.

Home in Ellison Bay

Mid Century Lake House with private beach

Come enjoy Door County in this beautiful lake house. Completely renovated with private beach access this is the perfect place to relax. Everything in this home is brand new! Conveniently located next to Ellison Bay & Sister Bay, enjoy all the hustle and bustle of Door County and retreat back to the serenity of the house Swim in the lake, paddle board, or take one of our bicycles and enjoy the scenery. Enjoy the winter snow shoeing, cross country skiing or snowmobiling.

5 out of 5 average rating, 220 reviews

The cottage showcases a distinctive A-frame design surrounded by lush greenery. A spacious wooden deck with yellow Adirondack chairs invites relaxation, while large front-facing windows allow for natural light and views of the serene wooded lot.

Cottage in Sister Bay

Sister Bay A-Frame | Coffee Bar + Fireplace

Trade the hustle and bustle for peace and quiet at our cozy retreat, just 5 minutes from the heart of Sister Bay. Tucked away on 1.6 acres of serene woods filled with beautiful beech trees, the cottage is your perfect getaway spot. Kick back on the spacious front deck, unwind on the screened-in porch, and soak in the natural beauty all around. Inside, mid-century modern vibes meet cozy comforts, with everything you need for a relaxing, stress-free stay.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 157 reviews

A cozy cottage is nestled among tall trees, showcasing a white exterior with a stone chimney. The spacious porch features blue chairs, inviting relaxation. Lush green grass surrounds the home, complementing the peaceful rural setting.

Cottage in Sister Bay

Lofted Pines Cottage

Settle in at Lofted Pines Cottage for your Door County stay! Located off the beaten path, but only a few minutes from downtown Sister Bay or Lake Michigan, Lofted Pines is elegantly situated among mature cedar and fir trees, yet open and airy. Whether you're relaxing on the wrap around porch, cozied up in front of the fireplace or enjoying the wood burning fire pit, Lofted Pines is the perfect spot to unwind after exploring the Door County Peninsula.

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

The image shows a well-lit open-concept living area and kitchen. A sink and dishwasher are visible in the kitchen, with a microwave on the counter. A cozy seating area features a light gray armchair and a side table, with large windows allowing natural light.

Condo in Ephraim

In the Heart of Ephraim ~ Cozy Condo

First floor, accessible 1-bedroom condo. Spacious bathroom with newly tiled shower, two flat screen smart TVs with cable. Full kitchen has new appliances (fridge, stove, oven and dishwasher), quartz countertops, microwave, drip coffee maker + toaster. Private patio connects to spacious shared yard with gazebo, patio table + chairs, grills and lovely water fountain (only runs in late spring and summer). Centrally located to everything in Door County!

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 264 reviews

A bright kitchen features a central island with a wood countertop and a gas stove. Shelves hold dishware, and modern appliances are visible. Natural light enters through the sliding door, which opens to a view of the yard, complemented by wood accents in the cabinetry.

Home in Baileys Harbor

Baileys Harbor Yellow Home with a View

Situated in the heart of down town Baileys Harbor, Wisconsin. You can sit in the kitchen and see Lake Michigan as you drink your morning coffee. No need to drive if you do not want to, you have restaurants, bars and shops all within walking distance. You have the whole house to yourself, but we own a coffee shop one building over, in case you need anything. The house is a late 1920's house, but newly upgraded, with a new kitchen and bathroom.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 176 reviews

The entrance is framed with natural wood siding and features a double glass door adorned with a festive wreath. Two wooden benches are placed on either side of a gravel pathway, complemented by greenery and decorative lighting fixtures.

Home in Baileys Harbor

Winding Down - A Retreat on the "Quiet Side"

Let it snow, let it snow, let it snow! Bring your snowshoes and cross country skies! Get ready to relax and recharge with family & friends. Winding Down is the perfect place to enjoy the quiet side of DC. We are walking distance from the Nature Preserve & the shores of North Bay. Located in a beautiful cedar forest that provides a needed respite. Plenty of privacy but also a short drive to Ephraim & Sister Bay.

Popular amenities for Sister Bay fireplace rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

House rentals with a fireplace

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 190 reviews

Home in Ellison Bay

Northern Lights Farmhouse with Hot Tub

A game area features a foosball table and a classic arcade machine, surrounded by large windows allowing natural light and forest views. A comfortable sofa provides seating for relaxation, contributing to a casual and inviting atmosphere for guests to enjoy games and socializing.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 37 reviews

Wooded Fall Getaway • Hot Tub • Games • Best Spot

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews

The exterior of a freshly remodeled home is displayed, featuring a dark blue facade with white trim. A large screened-in porch wraps around the front, complemented by plentiful windows. The surrounding area is wooded, offering a natural, serene environment.

Home in Fish Creek

Maple Grove Landing (Brand New Rental)

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 173 reviews

A spacious living area features a stone fireplace as the focal point, accompanied by comfortable seating on a sectional sofa. Natural light filters in through large windows, providing a view of the surrounding landscape. A coffee table sits at the center, adding a practical touch to the design.

Home in Fish Creek

Foxlea Guest House in Fish Creek

An open-concept living area is showcased, featuring a cozy arrangement of beige and tan seating around a modern coffee table. The elegant decor includes a stylish fireplace and a view of the kitchen, enhanced by natural light flowing through large windows.

5 out of 5 average rating, 20 reviews

The Porch House-Designer Sister Bay Retreat

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

The living room features a spacious couch arranged around a central area rug, with two armchairs positioned nearby. A stone fireplace is complemented by a wooden mantel adorned with decor. Tall windows allow natural light to fill the space, enhancing the feeling of comfort.

Home in Egg Harbor

Classy Harbor House-sleeps 14-walk to beach, shops

The remodeled farmhouse is showcased with a welcoming front porch and manicured landscaping. A large tree provides shade in the front yard, while a flag flutters gently. A rustic barn is visible in the background, surrounded by lush greenery and blooming orchards.

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Swedish Orchard Farm

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 125 reviews

The inviting living area features a rustic stone fireplace and comfortable leather seating. A wooden staircase leads to the loft, while large windows allow natural light to fill the space, creating a cozy ambiance. Decorative plants and accents add a touch of nature.

Home in Sturgeon Bay

Walden too

Apartment rentals with a fireplace

The resort features a spacious building with large windows and a distinct red-roofed clock tower. It overlooks a serene body of water, surrounded by well-maintained green lawns and trees in the background, creating a peaceful setting.

Apartment in Fish Creek

1BDSuite Little Sweden-FishCreek, WI Resort

A patio area overlooks Sturgeon Bay, featuring a round table with four chairs and a fire ring nearby. The view includes the water and distant docks, with a clear sky adorned by scattered clouds, providing a serene outdoor setting.

4.81 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Bayview Studio | On the water

The exterior of a two-story brick building is presented, featuring large windows with decorative trim. Lush, rounded shrubs are neatly arranged along the pathway leading to the entrance, which is framed by a small porch. A well-maintained lawn enhances the inviting appearance.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews

Lovely Victorian Suite

5 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

A bright living area features large windows that allow natural light to fill the space. A comfortable armchair and small lamp are positioned beside the window, while a patterned sofa adds a touch of color. A large TV is mounted above an elegant fireplace.

Apartment in Sister Bay

Alpaca Grand Vacation Rental

4.68 out of 5 average rating, 222 reviews

A welcoming entryway features a stone fireplace and glossy wooden flooring. A door with clear glass panels offers natural light and views of the outdoors. Simple furnishings, including a small side table, complement the space, while an exit sign indicates the way out.

Apartment in Sister Bay

The Yoga Pad - Open & Eclectic

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 119 reviews

A spacious living room is featured, designed with a comfortable sectional sofa and accent chairs around a circular coffee table. Natural light floods through large windows, complemented by a stylish fireplace and wall-mounted artwork showcasing sunset views.

Apartment in Egg Harbor

The Loft – Pet-Friendly Egg Harbor Rental

A spacious living area features comfortable seating arranged around a central coffee table. A gas fireplace is located below a wall-mounted television. Light enters through large windows, which lead to the outdoor deck, enhancing the inviting atmosphere.

5 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

Bay View Loft

A spacious bathroom area is visible, featuring a jacuzzi tub and a modern vanity with a mirror. Natural light enters through two windows, illuminating the light wood paneling and white cabinetry. The sleeping area is adorned with a decorative quilt and a hint of texture from the woven rug.

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 56 reviews

Deluxe Apt with Whirlpool in Sturgeon Bay

Other vacation rentals with a fireplace

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 65 reviews

An open-concept living space features a large wooden dining table surrounded by black chairs, with natural light flooding in through wide windows. A well-equipped kitchen is visible in the background, showcasing modern appliances and a cozy seating area with plush couches.

Cabin in Sister Bay

Starkhaus: Modern Cabin, Walkable to DT Sister Bay

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 57 reviews

An outdoor fire pit area is surrounded by Adirondack chairs, where guests gather around a crackling fire. The charming cottage is partially visible in the background, adorned with string lights and accessed by a wooden deck, providing a cozy setting for night-time gatherings.

Cottage in Sister Bay

Cottage & Bay: Home with Game Room Near DT SB

The exterior of a charming farmhouse features a covered porch with two green folding chairs beside a welcoming front door. Lush greenery and flower beds enhance the home's inviting atmosphere, accompanied by a view of a small storage shed.

5 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Door County Sister Bay Home: 3 Ensuites & Game Rm

4.75 out of 5 average rating, 60 reviews

The cozy interior of the cabin features a quilt-covered queen bed adjacent to a futon. Rustic log walls and a stone fireplace add character. A television is mounted on a wall, while an air conditioning unit is positioned near a window, ensuring comfort.

Cabin in Sister Bay

Rustic Log Cabin! Romantic, Cozy, Quiet!

5 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews

Cabin in Ellison Bay

Lakeside Cottage on the Bluff

5 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

A modern living room features large windows with views of the water. Comfortable seating includes a blue sofa, two neutral-colored armchairs, and an elegant coffee table with decor. A handcrafted gas fireplace is located beneath the wall-mounted TV, adding a cozy touch to the space.

Condo in Sister Bay

Luxury Property, Prime Location With Water View

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 46 reviews

An aerial view captures the layout of downtown Sister Bay, with vibrant green roofs visible on nearby buildings. The scenic water view stretches towards the horizon, while the coastline features a pathway leading to the beach. Various structures and parking areas can be seen below.

Condo in Sister Bay

Sister Bay Gem-steps to the beach and downtown!