Cottage vacation rentals in Sister Bay

Absolutely loved our stay at this beautiful Airbnb in Sturgeon Bay! The place was impeccably clean, easy to find, and offered gorgeous facilities that made our stay feel special. The space felt incredibly welcoming and comfortable, with friendly touches throughout that made us feel right at home. The highlight, however, was the unbelievable sunrises—truly breathtaking and worth waking up early for. Highly recommend this gem for anyone visiting Door County

This was such a beautiful cottage to stay in while visiting Door County. I would recommend this stay to anyone! It was so cozy, beautifully decorated and in a very convenient location.

Beautiful location and great place to stay! We will be back!!

The cottage was exactly as described and was super comfortable. We had everything we needed to make meals and also having 2 showers was wonderful. Plenty of hot water for all 5 of us to shower after getting home from adventuring. Would recommend this place for a quiet and peaceful stay.

Beautiful! Really enjoyed our girls weekend at the waterfront cottage. The view of the bay is absolutely stunning. The kitchen is beautiful and great to work in. The hot tub was the highlight. To be able to look at the bay and enjoy the environment was our favorite. Furniture was really comfortable. The beds are dreamy. Showers are great! Kayla gave great instructions on how to use everything. They’re even videos just to make sure you are parking in the right spot and using the hot tub properly. Definitely would recommend this beautiful hideaway.

nice place! staff was friendly and the room was cozy. we tried to use the Jacuzzi tub and it was a little dirty but other than that it was a great place to stay.

We had a great time staying at Erin's place in Egg Harbor! The cottage was walkable to downtown Egg Harbor and a great homebase to explore all of Door County!

My husband, toddler, dog, and I loved our stay here. The sunsets here were so beautiful! The cottage felt like home & all the antique decor added so much charm. Check in was easy & Alexandra provided a lot of information on what to do in Door County.

We enjoyed a lovely autumn weekend at Sophie's place! It is a cute and comfortable cabin in a beautiful (and more peaceful/less touristy) part of Door County, close to the water and within a half-mile walking distance of a few shops including a coffee shop. Welcoming touches like a cherry tart and fragrant bath soaps, in addition to the host's proactive communication and recommendations for things to do locally, made us feel right at home.

The perfect cottage for a weekend in Fish Creek. One mile drive away from Downtown. The kitchen was stocked with everything you would need. Ceiling fans and extra fans kept the cottage nice and cool. Comfortable beds, cozy space overall. And the privacy of being in the woods was wonderful. We would love to come back again!

Lovely home with everything we needed to have a relaxing girls weekend. There three of us so we each got out own room. We had a last putting together puzzles, playing games and remembering how to play Super Mario Brothers. The house was very clean and had everything we needed for our stay. Thank you for a lovely weekend.

kelly’s place was absolutely perfect! cozy, clean, and so relaxing. we will be back!!

Peaceful, cozy cottage with a great view of the lake and gorgeous sunsets. Outdoor space to relax and connect while enjoying a fire and the view. Warm and welcoming indoor spaces. Cottage was clean and well equipped with everything we needed for our stay. Easy to walk to shops and restaurants and convenient by car to great hiking as well as to all the Door County sights! Andrea was very helpful as we prepared for our trip and stayed in touch throughout to make sure we had what we needed and knew how to find local hot spots. Overall fantastic place to stay and we will be back!

Patty’s place is exactly as described. Right in the heart of Fish Creek, but down a secluded drive that is very private. Patty’s communication was great. We had four adults and our Bernedoodle and could not have been more comfortable. Shops and restaurants were within easy walking distance. Most restaurants accommodate dogs on the patio, so our dog could go almost everywhere with us. Everything else is just a short drive away. We had a great time and would definitely stay at Patty’s place again.

Thank you for allowing us to stay here again. We love the accommodations, however the wifi wasn't working to terribly great. But we still had a wonderful time. I'm sure we will be back again next year. Thank you, Greg.

This is a nice, reasonably priced home very close to Potawatomie State Park. It would be good for a family with kids, three bedrooms but only one bathroom. Some of the furniture could use replacing, but overall it is a comfortable stay. This was a repeat stay for us, so obviously we wouldn't have rented it again if we didn't think it was comfortable enough and a good value. We especially like the mowed trails through the property which allows us to exercise our dog off lease in a safe area--the home is set back from the road and there is only one neighbor directly across from the long driveway. The property is surrounded by farmland.

if you get excited sitting around the fire and looking up to the starry nightsky, or watching the deer family grasing in the garden in the morning, then this is the place for you! John's forrest house sits in between old trees and provides you with a porch (not roofed), a table in the garden, a bbq and a firepit, and a big grassy area for the kids to run around. the kitchen +house are very well equipped, you only need to bring cloth+food. we enjoyed our time with nana and our 16m old daughter. the house has a lot of kidsstuff like a highchair, plates, cups and toys. however be careful of the edges in and the stones around the house. a coastalplace to view the sunset is 5min by foot. the little town egg harbor is 5min by car with a marketshop, bakeries, restaurants and a sandy public beach. the state parks are only -30min away and offer beautiful hiking trails also suitable for little kids. we can definitely recommend coming here and enjoyed it very much!!

We had a great weekend get away in this hidden cottage. We were actually upgraded to the main house for a very reasonable rate. The house was clean, spacious and very comfortable. We will definitely be looking at this property for our next trip to Door County.

I was calling it our little turquoise cottage by the sea😃. It had everything we needed and the neighbors were very quiet. You won’t be disappointed by the amazing sunsets and Lake views!

April’s place was exactly as described! So peaceful and tranquil. Very clean and extremely comfortable bed! It was nice to “disconnect” while there. Would definitely recommend!!! 5⭐️’s

We rented Denise’s place as a destination to get our family together to celebrate the 4th of July. Eight of us never felt on top of each other as there was more space than expected. The ground by the dock was shallow and sandy which was perfect. We really enjoyed our stay.

Of 6 years of staying at many Airbnbs, Jake has been the best host by far. He is always responsive, flexible, and accommodating. He frequently goes above and beyond to ensure an enjoyable stay. This is my 3rd stay ( we are planing our fall trip now.) Thank you for sharing your beautiful home, on an incredible bay, on Washington Island!