Condo vacation rentals in Sister Bay

This beautiful condo was the perfect spot for our mini vacay. It was cozy with updated amenities and very spacious. The location was perfect for exploring local attractions. Yet it still felt private. Everything inside was upscale and pristine. My only regret is that we were not able to stay longer. We will definitely be returning.

A wonderful location in the heart of Sister Bay! Highly recommend.

We loved staying at Gary's place. The location was awesome for walking to all the restaurants and shops in Sister Bay and viewing the sunsets by the water. The condo was surprisingly quite considering how close to major restaurants and shopping it is located. Also, the kitchen was well stocked. We didn't' feel like he skimped on the extras, like soap, laundry detergent, etc. We would stay at Gary's place again when wanting to be able to walk in Sister Bay.

We loved our stay at the condo! Everything is just as pictured and is truly such a beautiful space. We really enjoyed using the fireplace and being able to see Al Johnson’s right out the window! It is extremely walkable to everything in Sister Bay and it was so nice to have two parking spots. This was our third year in a row coming to Sister Bay and we would definitely stay in the condo again!

Beautiful space. Contemporary decor. Excellent climate control options in rooms. Beautiful balcony view. Blue Horse Cafe immediately next door. Easy parking. Thoughtfully equipped kitchen; nearby (walkable) grocery. Would certainly stay here again.

This location was ideal for our family (4 adults plus a baby). The bedrooms were spacious and the condo had everything we needed. We appreciated that both bedrooms had an ensuite and the bedrooms were across from each other rather the next to each other, so my baby's cries at night didn't disturb my parents. The location was great - quiet and a bit removed from the hustle and bustle, perfect for appreciating the fall leaves and not far from the waterfront.

Great condo and location. We enjoyed the access to Horseshoe Bay Golf Club privileges. Played golf and visited their outdoor bar/restaurant every day.

We loved the place and will come back! Lundquist was very responsive and helpful when I called after we arrived - which I was super thankful for. Please know the following if you plan to stay here: 1. Does not come with sheets or towels. You can rent sheets and towels for $100 fee. 3. There is a gorgeous jacuzzi tub in the master bath however there is not enough hot water to fill it above the nozzles. 4. Make sure you know what unit number you are staying in before you arrive. The address they send you when you make the reservation does not include the unit # next to the address. It is listed in a separate paragraph of the instructions.

Stunning location right on the water with two parking spots. Plenty of space for our extended family to stay for the Door County 5k/half marathon weekend. Fireplace was a nice touch for the colder days and we love the availability to bring a furry friend!

Very nice and new space. Clean and thoughtfully decorated. No issues with check in or check out. We had a lovely time!

This place was in the most convenient location right off the highway and by a Kwik Trip and Walgreens in case you forgot things. It was super easy to get on 42 or 57 to get around the peninsula and since Door County is so small we found it the perfect home base for going up either side. The space itself was spacious and was nicely furnished, super comfy bed. It also had a nice little yard for our dog to do her business in. Other reviews mentioned how it can be loud but we brought a sound machine and had no problem at all! I could definitely see some of the traffic being loud though if you don't sleep with a fan or noise machine. Our pup did have issues going up the stairs and we had to carry her up and down, but if your dog is better with wood floors it may not be an issue.

Great stay and great views from this condo. We were on a two-family vacation and there was plenty of room to spread out. Good kitchen and roomy main area. Close to everything you’d want in fish creek. Responsive owner. Likely to return!

We stayed at Bonita’s for a long weekend over Memorial Day weekend. It was a perfect location for beautiful sunsets over the water. Easy drive to the parks and nearby towns. Bonitas place was spacious and well stocked. Plenty room for big groups. Enjoyed our stay.

We had an amazing stay at Leah's place! The communication was top-notch, Leah was quick to respond to all of our inquiries and provided helpful local tips that made our trip even more enjoyable. We appreciated the accommodation for the early arrival of our party of 7, coming from different locations. Leah's place was very relaxing. We definitely will be back.

Great area and close to local Breweries! Definitely a most use again!

Wonderful Hosts! The condo was beautiful with modern updates and very comfy furniture. Loved the fact that it has two living spaces! Our kids could go play their video games in the upper living area while the adults hung out in the downstairs living room. This condo is a real gem in Door County and we can't wait to stay there again.

This was the perfect size for our family-we had 2 couples and a 1 yr old. It was very quiet and the patio was private. While there wasn’t sidewalk to walk to downtown Fish Creek it was such a short drive to so many things it was great. The beds were comfy and we had everything we needed in the bathrooms and the kitchen. We had a few questions and Angela was very quick to respond. We had a great time and truly enjoyed our stay. Thank you so much for having us!

Wonderful place to stay! Very cozy and all the amenities you want. Recommend highly!

Beautiful place. Peaceful. Close to the water in Egg Harbor. Many restaurants, and local happenings right near the unit. The unit was clean and comfortable and exactly as described. We will hope to be back!

Great location in Door County (and Fish Creek). Comfy beds. Liked the layout with the bedrooms upstairs and living space downstairs. The bedrooms were a good size. We had plenty of room in the main bedroom for our daughter's pack n play. The shower had great water pressure, and the towels were soft. There was an excellent assortment of dishes, bowls, pots & pans, and utensils. (For example, there were mixing bowls; some other places we've been have had sparser kitchen items available.) There was a cute outdoor area/patio and upstairs there was a little balcony off the main bedroom.

We really enjoyed our time at Mario's rental. The townhome is well appointed and in a great location. We enjoyed use of the clubhouse. Mario was very responsive to our needs and a friendly host. Highly recommend!