Beach house vacation rentals in Garden City

We loved staying here! Stayed in October but had stunning weather, quick walk to town, walked the Sunken Forrest, which was easy to get too. Quick walk to the ocean for morning sunrises and enjoyed some wildlife friends, loved the deer. Hosts were accommodating, can’t beat three master bedrooms, would absolutely stay again, my family had a wonderful time!

This was one of the most memorable and meaningful events and Ashley's gorgeous home was the perfect centerpiece and the warmest most wonderful place that we could've ever found. We are so greatful! The decor, the furniture, the rooms, the beds, everything available for us to use, I can go on and on and on. The pictures don't do it justice. Wow if you are on the fence of where to go, THIS IS IT! We hope to come back again!

So glad we stayed at John's beachfront home. We wanted a way to escape the noise and chaos of a large city and this was the perfect fit. Granted the commute is longer, but we couldn't get enough of the amazing ferry ride from Rockaway to Manhattan/Wall Street. Such a great way to explore NYC.

Rob was very responsive to all emails and texts and all the instructions for checking in/checking out were very clear. House was exactly as advertised. Easy to get to beach and town. We had a really nice stay.

The neighborhood is peaceful and quiet, and the beach is right next to the house. The home itself is nicely set up, clean, and comfortable. Jenn was incredibly responsive and kind throughout our stay. We’ll definitely miss the time we spent there!

Overall a great space, right next to the ocean and silver sands State Park. Easy to find and available parking. Clean and tidy, space as pictured. Shared back yard. Quick and easy communication with owner.

Catherine was a fantastic host! She left us local restaurant menus and activities to do in the area on the table when we arrived! She was also super helpful with any questions we had and quick responses! The house was gorgeous and had a great view of the water! Would 100% book again!!

It was cozy yet spacious. It caused an all out homemade hot chocolate w marshmallow, movie night with the whole family. We'd grab a different great breakfast sandwich 3 min away daily. Everything is just an exit or a block away. I would love to stay here again.

Great little place to stay right by the bay.

We had such a great time staying at this Milford house! It was even better in person than the pictures show, more spacious than expected. The balconies overlooking the water were great to wake up to, and the small touches that the host added (towels set up and stacked in each bedroom, full coffee bar) made everything that much better! Allana was incredibly kind and responsive, being proactive about check in and check out and making sure we had everything we needed. We will definitely be repeat stayers at this house!

We were all very happy with the check-in/check-out. Instructions were clear and host left helpful information. Beds were quite comfortable. More than enough space for all. Laundry room was a plus. Easy to access town & beach. Lovely place - quiet - clean. Would definitely book again.

Place was clean and reasonably priced for the area. Conveniently furnished with many kitchen appliances. Moderately noisy from the traffic (as you can expect close to the road) and typical noise from the rest of the house. Johnna was very easy to communicate with. Got greeted by a very cute cat as we parked outside :)

I cannot describe accurately how lovely and comfortable Jonathons house is It was more than perfect for us in every way! The fenced in yard was perfect for our little dog and we all enjoyed turkeys and deer hanging out. Walking the neighborhood and to the beach with leaves changing It couldn’t have been any better.

A lovely stay for my brother in-law. Very comfortable with easy check-in and fast communication. Exactly what we needed!

This is a beautiful old house. Charming and spacious, well kept and appointed. The beds were very comfortable with nice linens. The host was very responsive - both for initial inquiries and a few questions along the way. Walking distance to the village. We enjoyed our stay very much.

Great stay and location with lots to do close by. thanks for a great stay!

this is the 2nd time I've stayed here both times I've enjoyed my stays and how friendly Geet is me and my friends love with spot and will continue to stay here 😂

Excellent location. An easy inexpensive ride into Penn Station via LLRR. A suggestion: I recommend those luggage racks one finds in hotels for your suitcase in each bedroom. That, or foot of bed benches. There is no closet for the small bedroom, so a place for your suitcase would be great. A chair in the small bedroom would also help.

Victoria's place was wonderful! It was spacious and comfortable and gave our family plenty of room to spread out and enjoy our visit. Victoria was a very responsive host and made check in and check out stress free and easy! There was ample parking for our cars and the house was private - it was the "house behind the house" so we weren't subject to busy traffic noise on the street. (Got a little confusing for DoorDash drivers but we worked it out :D). I will book this same place next time I am up for an extended weekend with the family. Highly recommend!

We needed a family friendly place for Easter weekend close to where my nephew is located and Jennifer's place was perfect! The kitchen, dining and living rooms were not only spacious enough for the 8 guests we were also able to include my nephew and his family for a holiday meal. The home's layout provided ample privacy for 3 generations to enjoy without feeling on top of each other, the furnishings were comfortable both indoor and out, with great selection of games for a variety of ages and was spotless to boot!

The host was extremely accommodating and communicative. This home is absolutely beautiful, the perfect place to stay! We stayed for our daughters wedding and we had all the girls getting hair & make-up done the day of the wedding, it was the perfect peaceful setting. The sound of the waves with the beach back drop is simply gorgeous! If your traveling to Milford, this is the perfect place to stay!! Thank you Victor for a wonderful weekend.

Our stay was short but sweet. The accommodations were as described and comfortable. It was extremely close to the beach.

Our family of 9 was super comfortable. This place it great. My family loved being here especially because it was so close to the beach. The yard is very small and also the entry door to the yard is completely missing, there is a lot of garbage under the deck which I found it to be a bit disturbing. Overall it was a fantastic stay… just make sure that make sure to lock the door with the lock..

Had a truly amazing stay! House was exactly as pictured and was perfect for sleeping 8 people comfortably. Perfect location in between the beach and the town. Host was incredibly accommodating and very responsive. Outdoor roof space was perfect for relaxing after a day at the beach. Highly recommend!!