Become a host

Vacation rentals in Anastasia Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Anastasia Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Top guest favorite
A spacious bedroom features a comfortable bed with a woven headboard, flanked by two bedside lamps. Natural light enters through a window dressed with wooden blinds. A ceiling fan circulates air, while decorative paddles add an interesting touch to the wall.
Apartment in Butler Beach

Toast Sunsets from the Wraparound Deck at a Coastal Oasis

A wonderful getaway, this property includes two airbnbs. A two story home with a detached guesthouse. These listings can be rented separately or together, if available. This listing is space is about 1,000 sq ft. You will have exclusive access to the second story apartment and wrap around porch. You will have one dedicated parking spot. There is a small backyard area with an outdoor shower that is shared with the other Airbnb. Access to the apartment is via keypad code. Were available if you need anything, but many times we only communicate with our guests through Airbnb! This Crescent Beach retreat is set back a bit from the road just 3 blocks from the ocean and 8 miles from downtown. Uber is the best way to get around without a vehicle. The Crescent Beach house is on A1A, set back a bit from the road. A1A is a moderatly busy two lane highway. However, you access the home from the backyard, which is also where you park, via a short grass road. Uber is the best way to get around if you do not have your own vehicle. This property includes two airbnbs. Each listing has one dedicated parking space in the rear of the property via a short grass backroad. The parking spaces are right next to each other.

FamilyLocationCondition

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 336 reviews
Top guest favorite
Home in St. Augustine Beach

Beachside, SUPER CLEAN, Oasis Yard, Summer Retreat

"We had an absolutely fantastic time staying at Dominick’s place. From start to finish, everything exceeded our expectations" * 100% 5-star rating ⭐ * Less than 500 steps to St Augustine Beach! ⛱️ * Super comfortable and meticulously clean. ✨️ * Huge Private Oasis Backyard, BBQ, Speakers, LOTS of seating 🌴 * towels + beach chairs + beach cart ⛱️ * 100% cotton sheets and towels ☁️ * comfy beds, pillows, extra pillows + blankets, living room * Fully stocked kitchen * On the Golden Mile

ValueLocationGetting around

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 177 reviews
Top guest favorite
Bungalow in Butler Beach

Ooo Laa Laaah Pets welcome

Private, fenced in yard and private Free standing cottage in quiet neighborhood. Private, fenced in yard! Pets are welcome. Fees apply. 2 washers and dryers, internet/wifi, 2 smart TVs. All kitchen appliances. One story. The beach is a one block stroll with no major streets to cross. Keep your car at home..walk to the beach 2 minutes stroll . Downtown, St. Aug. is a 10 minute car ride. Not a condo scene. Crescent Moon cottage is in front but completely separate. Shared laundry room.

FamilyValueTV

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 238 reviews
Top guest favorite
A panoramic view of a beach scene at sunset, featuring vibrant clouds in shades of pink, orange, and purple. The sun dips below the horizon, reflecting off the water's surface. Grassy dunes are visible in the foreground, framing the tranquil scene.
Guest suite in Butler Beach

Entire guest suite short walk to beach.

Enjoy exploring beautiful, historical St. Augustine then kick back and take it easy at this private, quiet beach retreat within a short walk to the beach. Separate keyless entry allows for self check-in. Queen size bed, fully furnished, with amenities including a Keurig coffee maker, iron, hair dryer, beach cruiser bicycles, beach chairs, towels, umbrella and gas grill for cooking out. Flat screen TVs in both the living room and bedroom with Netflix and Amazon Prime included and Free WiFi

ValueFamilyAccuracy

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 379 reviews
Top guest favorite
A well-maintained landscape showcases vibrant green grass and neatly trimmed shrubs, with palm trees lining the pathway. An expansive view of the ocean is visible in the background, framed by a boardwalk leading to the beach. Two residential buildings are seen in the scene.
Condo in Butler Beach

SeaPlace Ocean & Pool Views, 2/3 Steps to Beach

Beautiful St. Augustine Beach ocean & pool views from this 2/2.5 townhouse style condo steps to the beach. Come enjoy everything this vibrant city has to offer. Two quiet bedrooms and bathrooms upstairs. 2 private balconies. Downstairs is a full kitchen, dining area for 6, half bathroom, living area w/ newer 65" TV. 10 minutes from historic downtown. Family friendly resort community w/ pools, tennis, pickleball, basketball and bocce’ ball courts. Book now and let the island magic begin.

ValueFamilyAmenities

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 210 reviews
Top guest favorite
A screened lanai offers a comfortable wooden bench, with a vibrant mural piece on the wall. The space provides sweeping views of the lush greenery and palm trees beyond, as the sun rises over the horizon, creating a serene outdoor retreat.
Apartment in St. Augustine Beach

Oceanfront Bliss: Beach Views

Welcome to your oceanfront oasis in St. Augustine Beach! Featuring a spacious king suite, a comfy queen bedroom with twin trundle, and a sleeper sofa, it offers stunning sunrise views, a modern boho surfer’s vibe, and an updated chef’s kitchen. Steps to one of the best beaches in the east coast and walk to lively local restaurants and bars, it’s minutes to St. Augustine’s Nights of Lights, Amphitheater, and more! This isn’t just a vacation rental—it’s your personal seaside escape. Book now!

LocationFamilyAccess

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 115 reviews
Guest favorite
An aerial view of a beach house situated one block from the ocean is displayed. The coastline and sandy beach are visible, along with surrounding residential buildings and parked cars. The water shimmers under sunlight, suggesting a clear day.
Home in Butler Beach

Memory Maker - Vacation with Friends and Family

Modern, beautiful beach house with views of the ocean and tons of space for family fun. Home is one block from the ocean and is stocked with beach chairs, boogie boards and sand toys. Enjoy two ocean view balconies, a large open concept kitchen, living room and dining room, and board games for evenings of laughs with friends. This ultimate beach house is close to local restaurants and is an eight mile drive to historic downtown St. Augustine with shopping, tours, museums and live music.

LocationValuePets

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 142 reviews
Top guest favorite
A light-filled living area is depicted, featuring a spacious couch positioned against a vibrant artwork of a clownfish. Sliding glass doors lead to a serene outdoor space, while colorful paintings adorn the walls, adding artistic charm to the room.
Guest suite in St. Augustine

Art Studio Space – Quiet – Walk to Beach

This very private studio apartment is on Anastasia Island, with its own entrance across the street to Anastasia State Park, which includes the St. Augustine Amphitheater in a quiet, friendly beach neighborhood. This ideal location is quite literally "a walk in the park" to a beautiful undeveloped Florida beach; or a 10 minute drive across the famous Bridge of Lions to historic downtown St. Augustine – with quick access to the many local attractions and great restaurants in the area.

FamilyValueAccuracy

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 538 reviews
Top guest favorite
The exterior of Casa Coquina is presented, featuring a charming façade with rounded archways. A light blue garage door complements the neutral-colored walls. Lush greenery, including palm trees and decorative plants, enhances the inviting entryway, while a driveway leads to the garage.
Home in St. Augustine

Casa Coquina Walk to Downtown Clean Quiet Spacious

Casa Coquina offers a uniquely central location for your visit to the nation's oldest city. Located across from Salt Run Waterway & walking distance to many restaurants & entertainment, this newly renovated home offers 2 bedrooms & 2 full bathrooms, large living room, Florida room & outdoor patio. It is a 2-minute drive to Historic Downtown & 5-minute drive to our beautiful beaches. The huge tree-shaded yard is completely fenced in for child/pet safety & total privacy. Enjoy!

ValueLocationGrill

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews
Top guest favorite
Villa in St. Augustine Beach

VILLA ONE • 1 Block to the Ocean

One block from the ocean in St. Augustine Beach, this design-forward 2BR/2BA villa is made for easy beach stays. Warm tones, natural finishes and local art create a relaxed, laid-back feel. Outside, enjoy a private tropical backyard with lounge area, outdoor dining and outdoor shower. Walk to the beach, coffee and local favorites, with Historic Downtown just 10 minutes away. One of four individually styled St. Augustine Beach Villas. Not pet friendly. @staugustinebeachvillas

LocationFamilyCondition

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews
Top guest favorite
The living area features a comfortable white sofa accompanied by a woven coffee table. A ceiling fan circulates air above, while a wall-mounted TV is positioned for easy viewing. Bright wood flooring and light walls create a spacious ambiance, complemented by a dining area in the background.
Cottage in St. Augustine

1920s Coastal Cottage | Walk to Amp & Downtown

Light-filled, historic charm meets modern coastal living. Built in the 1920s, this meticulously updated 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom cottage features original heart pine floors, walls of windows, and a breezy, open feel that instantly makes you feel at home. Nestled in the quiet, historic Lighthouse Park neighborhood, you are right between the beach and historic downtown — 5 minutes to both.

ValueFamilyQuiet

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 277 reviews
Top guest favorite
A private balcony is presented, offering panoramic ocean views. The space includes a textured table and four chairs, with one set featuring floral upholstery. Green grass and sandy shorelines blend into the sea under a clear blue sky, enhancing the sense of tranquility.
Condo in Butler Beach

Wade n Sea Ocean Front Condo

Bring the whole family to this ocean front condo with lots of room for fun. Wake up to spectacular sunrises every morning! Kick back and relax in the heated pool or spend lazy days on the beach. Head to Historic St Augustine which is only a few minutes away and enjoy the town.

LocationFamilySleep quality

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 112 reviews

Popular amenities for Anastasia Island vacation rentals

GymBBQ grillLaptop-friendly workspaceWifiAir conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Anastasia Island

Top guest favorite
A welcoming entrance displays a white front door framed by large glass panels. Two black wire chairs are positioned on either side, enhancing the space. A doormat is placed at the threshold, and a small flowerbed with bright blooms adds a touch of color to the entrance.
Villa in St. Augustine

Tranquila Villa

FamilyValueAmenities

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 217 reviews
Guest favorite
The kitchen area features wooden cabinetry, a stove, and a refrigerator. A ceiling fan is present above a bar counter with seating, while a dining table is positioned nearby. Natural light streams in through a window, creating a welcoming environment.
Home in St. Augustine

Anastasia Island Tropical Treehouse

LocationFamilyParking

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 395 reviews
Guest favorite
An expansive view of the ocean stretches across the horizon, reflecting sunlight. The scene includes rooftops of nearby houses, with lush greenery framing the foreground. The beach is visible in the distance, emphasizing the beachfront location.
Home in St. Augustine Beach

Direct Ocean & Beach View Home

ValueFamilyHospitality

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 361 reviews
Guest favorite
The entrance features a solid brown door with modern glass accents, welcoming guests into the cottage. A small decorative mat lies on the porch, and bright blue siding complements the entryway. Light fills the interior through visible open spaces beyond the entrance.
Cottage in Butler Beach

Tones of Blue

FamilyValueQuiet

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews
Top guest favorite
A charming home is framed by lush greenery and distinctive palm trees. The gravel driveway leads to a welcoming porch with comfortable seating. The light blue exterior is complemented by large windows, allowing natural light to brighten the inviting entryway.
Home in Butler Beach

Family/Dog Friendly | Walk to Beach | Fenced Yard

FamilyLocationAccuracy

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 128 reviews
Top guest favorite
Condo in St. Augustine Beach

Spectacular Oceanfront Third Floor Paradise

ValueLocationDecor

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews
Guest favorite
Home in Butler Beach

Beach Walk · Pool · Pickleball · Arcade · Golf

FamilyValueCondition

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 57 reviews
Top guest favorite
A serene pool area is highlighted by clear blue water and surrounded by neatly arranged lounge chairs. Lush palm trees and tropical foliage provide a natural backdrop, while a well-maintained lawn complements the inviting outdoor space. The building's charming architecture can be seen in the background.
Condo in Butler Beach

Salt & Serenity~ Beachside Retreat

LocationFamilyLayout

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 89 reviews

Frequently Asked Questions

  • Where is Anastasia Island located?

    Anastasia Island is just off the northeast coast of Florida, near the city of St. Augustine. It is known for its beaches, natural preserves, and relaxed coastal atmosphere.

  • When is the best time to visit Anastasia Island?

    Late spring and early fall are often suggested for comfortable weather, with temperatures ranging from about 65 to 84°F (18 to 29°C) and manageable rainfall. Cooler winters appeal to those wanting fewer crowds, while summer brings warmer days and higher humidity.

  • What are some things to do near Anastasia Island?

    Explore wide sandy beaches, visit Anastasia State Park for walking trails and native wildlife, or discover the historic St. Augustine Lighthouse and Maritime Museum. The area also has local seafood restaurants, nature preserves, and opportunities for water activities.

  • How is the weather near Anastasia Island?

    Anastasia Island experiences mild winters around 45–68°F (7–20°C), with warmer, humid summers near 90°F (32°C) and peak rainfall during late summer. Spring and fall are frequently noted for moderate temperatures and less humidity, making outdoor activities inviting.

Destinations to explore