Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Sullivan County

Loved Ellie's place. Martina was an amazing host and made it very easy for us to enjoy this beautiful property. Highly recommended if your looking to relax and get back to nature. Looking forward to returning.

Ashley’s place was perfect! We were looking for a peaceful mountain getaway and it exceeded our expectations. The house is clean and beautiful, and it has everything you would need. Ashley was very responsive and left a great list of recommendations. I would definitely stay here again!!

The flexibility for Ck in & Ck Out is hard to find. Lots of Clean Space in the house, Very Friendly and helpful People. Would definitely recommend and come back .👍👍

Absolutely perfect stay during a meaningful and emotional time. We came to this beautiful lakefront Airbnb to celebrate my husband’s birthday after his passing, hoping for peace and comfort—and it was everything we needed. The weather happened to be beautiful, which allowed us to take out the kayaks and fully enjoy the calm and serenity of the lake. The sunsets and sunrises were absolutely phenomenal—quiet, breathtaking moments that brought so much peace. The home itself was spotless, cozy, and incredibly well stocked with everything we could possibly need—from kitchen essentials to extra linens and thoughtful touches throughout. You can tell it’s a family-owned home, filled with warmth and very well taken care of, which made it feel even more special. It was also very family-friendly, making it a perfect fit for all of us and plenty for all to do. We truly appreciated how kind, helpful, and responsive the host was throughout our stay. We’re grateful and hope to return .

Narrowsburg is such a quaint, cute, and friendly town—perfect for a relaxing getaway! Plamena was a fantastic host, always quick to respond and incredibly helpful with anything we needed. The home itself is cozy and well-appointed, especially the kitchen, which had everything we needed for cooking. The fireplace was such a treat—be sure to grab firewood from Pete’s! The location is ideal; we loved being able to walk to Main Street and explore the charming shops and restaurants. The beds were very comfortable, and the linens were top quality, making for a restful night’s sleep. A special highlight was watching the deer wander through the backyard—it was such a peaceful and beautiful sight. Highly recommend this stay! Would absolutely return.

This was such a beautiful stay! We loved the hot tub after a long hike and the warm fireplace when the temperatures were freezing. The kitchen was well stocked so we could cook meals. The record player with records and cds was such a fun touch! We did find the beds hard to sleep in with two people because they were a little sunken in the middle, but I would still stay here again!

Little gem. House was described perfectly. House and amenities were exactly what we needed. Host was friendly. Would definitely recommend.

Butternut Farm cottage charmed us with its cuteness and thoughtful amenities! We were impressed by the well-equipped kitchen (utensils, spices, Ziploc bags!) and the provided hiking sticks – Michele truly thought of everything. Our Frenchie loved exploring the farm. However, we did encounter a few wasps inside on separate occasions and ants in the small bathroom. The main bathroom's lukewarm water and leaky tub prevented relaxing baths. While the highway noise was unnoticeable thanks to provided noise machines, the first-floor bathroom setup (main bath attached to main bedroom) and limited hot water for multiple showers require planning. Despite these minor drawbacks, our family had a wonderful time. The cottage's charm and the pet-friendly farm made for a memorable getaway. We'd consider returning, hoping the small issues are addressed.

We had a great stay! The apartment was very clean and comfortable. Jennifer left toiletries in the bathroom that came very useful. There was even an adorable arrangement of flowers left on the mantle being that it was my birthday weekend. She was very responsive!

We stayed at 81 North for a quick weekend getaway to the Catskills from NYC. The room was spacious, comfortable, and had nice little touches like bottles of water and microwaveable popcorn. Richard and Sherryl were very kind and welcoming.

This place was awesome. It was comfy and private, beautiful. Jarrett was very proactive even checking in on us after check in. The lake was gorgeous and If your looking for great food visit the Spotted Cow awesome food and great service. Thank you so much Jarrett. If your looking for a private exclusive getaway with amazing views, this is the place.

Excellent stay. Richard greeted us and gave us local recommendations for restaurants, activities, etc. Room was clean and the linens were spotless. My GF and I had a great stay and would highly recommend to anyone looking to stay in the area. Location is close to many hiking trails.

Johns place was perfect for a little getaway. Our dog loved it as much as we did. We walked around the lake with stunning views (especially around fall season) and the fireplace is great for doing s’mores at night. Dasha was absolutely amazing, friendly and always reachable if anything.

If I could put 6 stars I would! They made me feel right at home. I will try to stay here every time I’m in NY

The place is breathtaking. Located in an incredible land with awesome trails is a marvelous house nicely decorated and amazing rooms. We had an incredible time with my family that we will remember forever. Many thanks to Paula. Always there and really helpful with everything.

Yvette's home was absolutely wonderful! The place was spotless, beautifully decorated, and had all the amenities needed for a comfortable stay. The beds were cozy, the kitchen was well-equipped, and every little detail was thoughtfully arranged. Yvette was an exceptional host—super friendly, responsive, and always communicative. She made sure we had everything we needed and provided great local recommendations. I would definitely stay here again and highly recommend it to anyone looking for a relaxing and enjoyable stay.

Our family weekend at Casa Julia was awesome. All 3 generations loved the layout of the house and the beautiful lake across the street. The house was nicely decorated, matched the pictures, and had everything we needed. It was a great home base for relaxation and exploring the Catskills!

We had an amazing time! The house was awesome—clean, comfortable, and in a great location. It had everything we needed, and overall, it was a really great experience. The only downside was getting charged for a late check-out, which was a bit of a bummer, but other than that, everything was smooth and enjoyable. Would definitely recommend!

We had a fantastic time, the highlight of our stay was definitely the amazing pool. It was clean, well-maintained, and it also had heating facilities making it perfect for a refreshing swim. The stay was comfortable and beautifully decorated. The kitchen was fully equipped, making it easy for us to cook meals when we wanted to. The bedrooms were cozy, and the bathrooms were spotless. Our host, Israel, was incredibly welcoming and responsive. He provided us with all the information we needed and were quick to address any questions or concerns we had during our stay. Overall, we had a wonderful experience. We would definitely recommend it to anyone looking for a relaxing getaway for a large group of people with a great pool. We hope to visit again soon!