Vacation rentals with a fire pit in Sullivan County

My girlfriend and I spent a weekend here at Jerry’s beautiful home. The pictures don’t serve justice from the coziness feeling that we felt during our stay! Everything was great and Jerry was responsive to any of our questions. I recommend heading into town and exploring the area. We ate at The Grill in Port Jervis and it was super good. Definitely would stay again.

The flexibility for Ck in & Ck Out is hard to find. Lots of Clean Space in the house, Very Friendly and helpful People. Would definitely recommend and come back .👍👍

Absolutely perfect stay during a meaningful and emotional time. We came to this beautiful lakefront Airbnb to celebrate my husband’s birthday after his passing, hoping for peace and comfort—and it was everything we needed. The weather happened to be beautiful, which allowed us to take out the kayaks and fully enjoy the calm and serenity of the lake. The sunsets and sunrises were absolutely phenomenal—quiet, breathtaking moments that brought so much peace. The home itself was spotless, cozy, and incredibly well stocked with everything we could possibly need—from kitchen essentials to extra linens and thoughtful touches throughout. You can tell it’s a family-owned home, filled with warmth and very well taken care of, which made it feel even more special. It was also very family-friendly, making it a perfect fit for all of us and plenty for all to do. We truly appreciated how kind, helpful, and responsive the host was throughout our stay. We’re grateful and hope to return .

Wonderful host. Very clear and respectful-and in our case helped us out beautifully in a pinch. The house is very comfortable—a classic farmhouse with plenty of amenities. The record player/vinyl collection is an added bonus. The word burning stove and the dayroom it is in is a great room to lounge in, the kitchen is well stocked, and the surrounding area is very quiet and quite pretty-wonderful hemlock groves across the main road down the hill. Not far from Livingston manor and other small nice towns. Definitely would recommend and would be happy to return. Ideal for a small group getaway. And also, though it is close to a decent sized road, in the winter when we were there for 3 nights-maybe a half dozen cars. Extremely quiet in general and at night specifically.

Alex was incredibly helpful and responsive. The house is wonderful and in a great peaceful location with many hikes nearby, including a few waterfall ones. We had a great time going to many nature walks and going to the towns nearby, but also relaxing in the home. Absolutely a great stay and will come back in the future!

10/10. We had a great time at the barn this week. Everything that we could hope for. There was plenty of space, a very well-stocked kitchen, comfortable sleeping arrangements, and great views. Thanks for hosting

We had a great stay at Wood’s Edge! The home is beautifully decorated and so comfortable. We really loved all the games and activities. Vanessa was a fantastic host and super responsive. Perfect place to host family and friends- we can’t wait to come back!

Butternut Farm cottage charmed us with its cuteness and thoughtful amenities! We were impressed by the well-equipped kitchen (utensils, spices, Ziploc bags!) and the provided hiking sticks – Michele truly thought of everything. Our Frenchie loved exploring the farm. However, we did encounter a few wasps inside on separate occasions and ants in the small bathroom. The main bathroom's lukewarm water and leaky tub prevented relaxing baths. While the highway noise was unnoticeable thanks to provided noise machines, the first-floor bathroom setup (main bath attached to main bedroom) and limited hot water for multiple showers require planning. Despite these minor drawbacks, our family had a wonderful time. The cottage's charm and the pet-friendly farm made for a memorable getaway. We'd consider returning, hoping the small issues are addressed.

Thomas is a great host! a Very accommodating and generous man. He takes care of anything you need. I highly recommend staying here. The place is beautiful, tranquil and has 100 percent positive vibes. You won't be disappointed!

Wonderful host, warm and inviting home and great guidance/recommendations for local dining and activities. We had a great time and I strongly recommend if you’re looking in this area.

This place was absolutely beautiful and was exactly what we were looking for. Clean studio right on the lake, nothing better than waking up and looking out onto the frozen lake from bed.

Apartment is clean and, from what I can tell, the appliances, carpet and fixtures are all new. Very clean and organized.

Johns place was perfect for a little getaway. Our dog loved it as much as we did. We walked around the lake with stunning views (especially around fall season) and the fireplace is great for doing s’mores at night. Dasha was absolutely amazing, friendly and always reachable if anything.

Monica was a very welcoming host. Her apartment was as advertised; very spacious and comfortable. We felt at ease upon arrival. We would absolutely stay at Monica's unit again.

This place is so nice and peaceful...it's almost spa-like with the hot tub and sauna all to yourself! It's an awesome place to get away from the city(in just a couple of hours) and have complete relaxation! its super clean, and the host was so friendly! Will definitely try and come back!

My wife and I enjoyed Johanna’s cozy cabin very much. It was very warm and tidy and it was easy to get around to attractions nearby. We loved hanging out by the fire and watching DVDs and using the well-appointed kitchen. A great stay!

The host was accommodating with our last minute booking and let us check in a little early. Thanks for hosting us again!

Loved this home! Specifically the architecture and cabin style decor. Located near the running river and surrounded by trees this place is perfect for settling in and relaxing. Enjoyed all the amenities and also explored Callicoon and other towns nearby. Would recommend to anyone and would love to return!

Beautiful Airbnb. The hot tub was clean and perfect after a long day. There were plenty of extra towels and the bathroom was gorgeous. It felt as if a lot of thought went into setting this place up so we would have everything we could need - from wood for the fireplace to lighting around the hot tub to coffees and teas for the morning.

Stayed one night and loved it—super cute spot! The alpacas and animals were fun to be around, and waking up to a foggy spring morning with the big window was v pretty. No running water takes a little getting used to, but it was totally fine for a night and was communicated clearly in advance. Great location—feels nice and remote but still close to town.

This was our second vacation at this cabin and it was even more cozy for being familiar to us. We had a wonderful 8 days in nature and had a very hard time leaving. Smallwood forever!!!!

Julie's place was the perfect winter getaway. The fireplace, hot tub and sauna warmed us and the very well-equipped kitchen enabled us to prepare great meals. The house was beautiful, with two living rooms for different activities and energy levels, a game room downstairs, a dining room with a large table and chairs, and comfortable furniture and beds throughout. Julie texted me to make sure that our every need was met. We had a snow and ice storm, and she had the driveway and walkways plowed, shoveled and sanded twice, and kept plenty of salt on-hand. We hope to return sometime in warmer weather so we can enjoy the pond, too.