Vacation rentals with a pool in Shelter Island

Find and book unique homes with a pool on Airbnb

Top-rated rentals with a pool in Shelter Island

Guests agree: these homes with a pool are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Guest favorite

A serene outdoor space features a sparkling pool bordered by smooth stone and surrounded by lush greenery. A rustic stone fireplace is visible in the background, adding a cozy element to the setting. Soft lighting creates a tranquil atmosphere as night falls.

Home in San Diego

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

the Belvedere

The Belvedere offers an unforgettable retreat with breathtaking sunsets. A short 10-minute drive from the ocean, this serene single-story home is designed for comfort and accessibility, featuring four bedrooms and two modern bathrooms. The outdoor shower beckons you to cool off while indulging in alfresco dining on the terrace. Watch the sun dip below the horizon while making every dinner a memorable experience. Close to restaurants and grocery stores, yet secluded enough for ultimate relaxation

LocationFamilyKitchen

Guest favorite

A welcoming living area features a leather sofa and a round coffee table, complemented by a modern electric fireplace. Natural light filters through sheer curtains, illuminating decorative vases along the floor. A cozy hanging chair and a potted plant add warmth to the space.

Home in City Heights

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Stunning 2BR/2BA| Plunge Pool, AC, Private

Modern 2 bed|2 full bath in the heart of San Diego. Featuring trendy interiors, stock tank pool, and thoughtful amenities, this space is designed for relaxation & comfort. Enjoy seamless indoor-outdoor living with cozy touches that make you feel at home. Casa Luna is perfectly located minutes from North Park, Downtown, Balboa Park, the zoo, close to beaches & a vibrant dining scene. Whether you’re here to unwind or explore, Casa Luna is your ideal home for an unforgettable San Diego experience.

LocationValueAir conditioning

Top guest favorite

A bright living space features a warm wooden ceiling and large windows. A comfortable orange sofa is paired with a wooden coffee table on a patterned area rug. The kitchen, visible in the background, includes modern appliances and white cabinetry, enhancing the cozy atmosphere.

Home in Hillcrest

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 190 reviews

1 bedroom, 1 bath /Hillcrest/San Diego Zoo/Balboa

One bedroom, one bath with a pool in the Hillcrest/San Diego Zoo/Balboa Park /Marston Hill area. Full kitchen, queen bed, queen sleeper sofa & crib. Indoor/outdoor dining, WiFi, smart TV, pool, AC/heating, BBQ& free parking. Walking to restaurants/bars/shops/stores (Trader Joe's, Ralph's & Whole Foods). Walking to the Farmers Market. Minutes' drive to all San Diego beaches. No rent for children under 3, only a $95/stay flat fee. High chair, Pack & Play Crib, crib mattress & cover are provided

FamilyValueBiking

Top guest favorite

A private outdoor area features a heated pool surrounded by lush green grass and modern loungers. An inviting fire pit is centrally located, with two stylish chairs positioned nearby. The backdrop includes well-maintained shrubbery and tall trees, enhancing the tranquil ambiance.

Home in Serra Mesa

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 295 reviews

Midcentury Lux 4BR home w Pool/Spa/Cabana/Firepit

VERY PRIVATE, COMPLETELY RENOVATED 4BR 3 Bath mid-century home with heated saltwater pool, hot tub and fire pit in totally private backyard retreat. Redone top-to-bottom, inside/out with everything new. The beds are top of the line with very high quality 100% cotton sheets and bath towels. Conveniently we are centrally located in a safe, friendly neighborhood with beautiful mountain views in the back. We never charge any fees - as we want to provide the experience we hope to get when traveling.

FamilyValueIndoor spaces

Top guest favorite

A serene outdoor space showcases a sparkling pool adjacent to a jetted hot tub, with canyon views stretching in the background. A glass fence enhances the vista, and the surrounding landscape features palm trees and gentle hills under a clear blue sky.

Home in San Diego

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

ModernCoastal I View I Pool ITub

Spectacular canyon views are the backdrop to this stunning, modern newly renovated San Diego home! The jetted hot tub with water falling in the sparkling pool, the natural light streaming through the french doors, huge screened folding door, and skylights, the beautiful Great Room with the inviting living room, gourmet kitchen, indoor/outdoor dining, comfy beds, spectacular rooms & bath, sunset vista point, outdoor BBQ & backyard loungers and daybed are all designed to get you in vacation mode!

LocationFamilyWalkability

Guest favorite

A living room features a luxury hanging chair suspended from the ceiling. Natural light filters through sheer curtains, illuminating a cozy seating area with a plush sofa and wooden coffee table. A 50” television is mounted above an elegant fireplace, enhancing the room's comfort.

Home in City Heights

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 144 reviews

Designer Luxury Rental With Pool

Welcome to Wander Haven, a luxury central rental. With it’s on trend design, custom built stock tank pool, array of amenities and thoughtful touches throughout, you won’t ever want to leave. But when do you do decide to venture out and explore all that beautiful San Diego has to offer, you will find the central location gets you to anywhere you want to be in minutes. You’re 15 minutes or less from beaches, downtown, balboa park, sea world, the zoo and hundreds of amazing bars and restaurants.

FamilyLocationNearby

Guest favorite

Home in San Diego

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 108 reviews

windows of the world. views, pool/spa and fun yard

Welcome to HIGHER ELEVATION, a 7500 square-foot lot, newly remodeled new pool, spa and backyard full of games! 5-bedroom 4-bathroom (+ a/c & heat) hillside home designed in a modern-concept overlooking San Diego and Mission Bay (FIREWORKS) with breath taking views of sea world and from La Jolla to downtown! We're centrally located, near many attractions (eg beaches, Sea World, Zoo, downtown (read the neighborhood section for details). We are neighbors to USSD and a 15 min walk to the Trolley.

FamilyLocationAmenities

Top guest favorite

A spacious outdoor patio showcases a private pool and hot tub, surrounded by comfortable seating and a fire pit. An activity area features games such as foosball and cornhole, with lounge chairs positioned for relaxation. Lush green landscaping complements the inviting space.

Home in Bay Park

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 124 reviews

Modern Central SD Home w/ Pool & Spa Near Beach

Experience luxury at Bay Breeze Retreat, an exclusive oasis in the heart of Mission Bay, San Diego. This stunning residence features a private salt pool, outdoor jacuzzi spa, elegant fire pit, whole house water filter system and a state-of-the-art grill and kitchen. Inside, revel in contemporary upgrades which makes the place perfect for family gatherings of up to 8 guests. Walk to Luce Bar & Kitchen and Bird Rock Coffee. Minutes from downtown and top attractions, your perfect escape awaits.

FamilyValueKitchen

Top guest favorite

The poolside area features a well-maintained saltwater pool reflecting the colors of the sunset. Comfortable seating arrangements, including lounge chairs and a cozy fire pit, are visible. Large umbrellas provide shade, and lush greenery adds to the serene ambiance.

Guesthouse in La Mesa

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 173 reviews

Vacation Paradise-Heated Pool+Hot Tub+FirePit+EV

Welcome to your personal resort! This is your private Guest House with a salt & heated pool + hot tub. Located in a very quiet & safe neighborhood in beautiful San Diego. Drive 15 minutes to the beach, downtown, La Jolla, Zoo, stadiums, Sea World, Convention Center + more. Hike next door at Cowell Mountain or Lake Murray. Smart TV, wifi, two zone AC, full kitchen, W/D combo, top quality finishes & furniture. Everything you need for memorable vacation! No smoking or vaping on the property.

FamilyLocationGrill

Top guest favorite

A colorful living area features a vibrant blue couch adorned with decorative pillows. A round white coffee table sits prominently on a multi-colored rug, while a television is mounted above a red cabinet. Artwork and framed prints decorate the pink walls, enhancing the playful ambiance.

Home in University Heights

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

Casa De Colores

Need some color in you life? Come stay in our one of a kind home- groovy wall mural, bright decor, rainbow speckled floors. Tucked back in the peaceful neighborhood of University Heights, this home includes a lusciously landscaped yard with a: - Pool -Hottub - BBQ -Outdoor patio furniture Our property also offers the ultimate in convenience: - Acclaimed restaurants and cafes are just minutes away - Close to the Airport, Zoo, Balboa Park, and Downtown - Close to many world-class beaches

LocationFamilyKitchen

Guest favorite

A private entryway is framed by lush greenery and colorful plants. A rustic wooden gate provides access, set against a clean, beige wall. Blue pots filled with vibrant foliage are positioned at either side of the path leading to the entrance.

Cottage in Pacific Beach

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 256 reviews

Crown Point Gem with Salt Water Pool

This Cottage home is a beautiful Oasis in San Diego's Crown Point neighborhood. Our home is 2 blocks from Mission Bay with access to bike paths, water sports, and playgrounds for the kids. Easily walk to great restaurants, coffee shops, night life and shopping. With our cool saltwater pool, hot tub, grill and relaxing patio space you wont even need to leave the house to get that vacation feeling. Please let us know if you would like the pool heated, we charge $75/night for this service.

FamilyLocationComfort

Guest favorite

A vibrant heated pool is surrounded by minimalistic landscaping, featuring tall cacti and a clean white fence. Soft lounge chairs are positioned nearby for relaxation. The clear water reflects the blue sky, creating a refreshing setting for leisure and enjoyment.

Home in Mission Hills

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 291 reviews

Lionhead - Private Boutique Home

Unwind in your private backyard resort, featuring a heated pool, complimentary Jacuzzi, cabana, and BBQ—perfect for watching planes soar over the city skyline. Amenities: High-speed Wi-Fi, Smart TVs, and a vintage record player. Location: Minutes from Downtown, the Convention Center, and easy highway access. 🏊🏼‍♀️🛟Optional pool heat is available for $50/day (stays under 5 days). To ensure the best experience, heating is applied to the full duration of your stay only.

LocationValueCheck-in