Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Sodus Bay

Anything you need, was at the house. It was like walking into your own home. Beautiful older home with all the modern updates you'd want, without losing the charm. Perfect place for our family to meet up. Lot's of space for everyone. We made Easter dinner and all the necessities were there. Hoping The Blue House is available next time we visit. Dennis was the best host, super responsive and very nice. Thanks for a weekend of great family memories!

Thanks so much, Merry for letting us stay at this place. The house is amazing, it's clean and peaceful and has everything you would need to make the stay wonderful. We had our 10 month old baby with us, and Merry made sure there's a high chair and a pack n play for the baby. The house could use a refill on some coffee and some bath essentials, but overall I would 100% recommend this place to anyone looking for an accessible and beautiful place to stay near the finger lakes! Would definitely stay here again if I am visiting finger lakes, thanks again for hosting us!

We booked last minute and everything was still seamless. The house was bright and airy and felt very much like home away from home. The location was perfect for us. It felt private but was really close to stores/restaurants. Cheryl was responsive and friendly. No surprises, which we appreciate.

5/5 – A Perfect Family Getaway We had an incredible stay and truly didn’t want to leave. The home was ideal for a family vacation—comfortable, well-equipped, and full of thoughtful touches. My children were devastated to go! We had planned a few small adventures in the surrounding area, but they were so happy in the pool that we barely left the property. We came during spring break from upstate New York, where it was still snowing, so the warm weather and sunshine were a much-needed reprieve. The house had everything we needed: Netflix, Alexa, a garage full of pool noodles and floaties, and a lovely selection of children’s books that my toddlers adored. One of the most heartwarming moments was when Neil kindly gifted my daughter a stuffed cat she had fallen in love with—it meant so much to her and to us. This was the kind of stay that creates lasting memories. We can’t wait to come back.

We were in town to spend the holidays with family and the house was everything that we had hoped for! It was warm and welcoming and a great space for us all to spend time together. Everything was clean and the house had everything that you might need for a wonderful stay. Owner was easy to reach and answered questions quickly. We loved it and are already talking about a repeat visit next year!

After a stressful cross-country move, we needed a place to stay while we looked for a house. Joanne's place was exactly what we needed. It was so quiet and peaceful, but still close to many things. It is a great location, within walking distance of the beach and walking trails. Even though it was freezing most of our stay, I still enjoyed taking walks in the woods at the end of the street. The house itself is very cute and cozy. We felt right at home. Everything was clean and stocked for a long stay. Joanne was very responsive and accommodating. I would highly recommend staying here.

It was just what was advertised. Nice area and would definitely rent again.

Our stay was fantastic! Rebecca was an awesome host, and so easy to communicate with. Highly, highly recommend if you’re looking for a beautiful getaway.

We had a a wonderful stay at The Regent. The property is exactly as described and is located a few short blocks off park Ave! The kitchen is well equipped for cooking and the beds are super comfortable! There was parking for two vehicles which was excellent as our college aged kid was able to come and visit without worrying about street parking! I would definitely stay here again on our next trip to Rochester!

I'm familiar with Rochester and knew exactly where this place was...a 5-minute walk for my morning cappuccino and croissant and a convenient drive past Rochester's only Frank Lloyd Wright house to friends and family,. The apartment is lovely and tranquil - a new, modern kitchen, small but nice bath, lovely dining room and comfortable livingroom/bedroom with good lighting and a very comfortable reading chair, an amenity that is seldom provided. The furnishings are lovely and the closet has lots and lots of hangers. A 10-minute walk to Park Ave. restaurants and shops; a short drive to Wegmans. Culver Road traffic noise can be irritating, but it quiets at night; expressway noise is negligible. James was very responsive when I had questions. I will return.

This was my sister and my second time staying at Roger's AirBNB. We purposely returned for the wonderful hosting, convenience, access to great parks, museums, and family nearby. This time we stayed on the first floor which was beautiful and homey. The surrounding neighbors were friendly and I loved walking my dogs and chatting with them everyday. Roger is a fantastic host - always responsive, a gentleman, and professional. He was flexible with our wish to return this year for which we are grateful. We will definitely consider returning again.

Tonia is very pleasant to deal with, very responsive and her place is beautifully kept, clean and in a great location. I highly recommend checking it out if you are in the area.

Absolutely lovely place! We enjoyed the weekend in this cozy and beautiful apartment in the Finger Lakes, very close to downtown Geneva and has everything you could possibly need. Everything was extremely easy!

Shelly's place was so wonderful! It was just as she listed it, but really the pictures do not do it any justice. It's warm and inviting and everything you would need is there and easy to find in the space. We had never been to Geneva before and Shelly gave us some awesome recommendations for local restaurants and bars to check out. Everything that we wanted to do in Geneva was walkable from the front steps which was really great. We will definitely be back and will absolutely stay with Shelly again!

Great communication and the place was very clean, nice and comfortable!!! Host was easy to work with. I would definitely come back.

Beth’s place was spotless, tidy, well organized and very comfortable. It took about 20 minutes to walk to the little downtown area. Her instructions were clear and we had no issues at all. A very enjoyable stay!