House vacation rentals in Sodus Bay

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Sodus Bay

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favorite
The living room showcases a floral-patterned couch centered between two upholstered armchairs, creating a conversational area. Soft natural light is filtered through framed windows, and a decorative mirror reflects the room's inviting charm. A large area rug adds warmth to the hardwood floor.
Home in Victor
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 429 reviews

Beautiful & quiet place. A true in-law house.

It’s a true separate in-law house in a walk out basement. It’s completely furnished & includes a living room, bathroom. laundry room, kitchen, 1 bedroom with a queen bed, a full size bed off the living room, a day bed with a twin bed and a trundle twin underneath in the living room, and 2 full size air mattresses & 3 TVs. Victor is a suburb of Rochester with many hiking trails. There are wineries, lakes, casinos, & colleges. Its approx. 20 mins from Bristol Mt & we have many theatres.

Top guest favorite
A historic cobblestone building is surrounded by lush greenery. The front entrance features a welcoming door framed by large windows. A small bistro set stands on the front steps, and decorative potted plants add a touch of life to the landscape.
Home in Williamson
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 157 reviews

1845 School House in the Heart of Pultneyville

Fully renovated in the spring of 2021. According to the Pultneyville Historical Society, the first school, a small crude building, was built on this site in 1808. It burned in 1816 and was replaced by a larger schoolhouse. The cobblestone building was built in 1845 and served as a school until 1943 when the Williamson School District centralized. It is now a private residence. Notice the cobbles set at an angle. A metal bar circles the building as reinforcement — a modern addition.

Superhost
Home in Sodus
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 129 reviews

Lakefront Pine Cottage • Hot Tub & Fire Pit

Relax in our lakefront retreat featuring a hot tub, fire pit, and unbeatable views. - Direct Lakefront - Full kitchen, fast Wi-Fi, smart TV, indoor fireplace - Free Parking - Located in a State Park! - Superhost hospitality—responses within an hour Three comfy bedrooms sleep your group in peace. Enjoy morning coffee on the deck, s’mores at the fire pit and sunsets over the water. Ready for lake life? Click “Reserve” to secure your dates today!

Top guest favorite
A spacious lakefront porch features several white Adirondack chairs positioned for lake views. The calm waters of Lake Ontario stretch out, framed by greenery and trees in the background, inviting relaxation in a serene outdoor setting.
Home in Sodus Point
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 175 reviews

Lakefront Cottage - Best of Both

Welcome to "Best Of Both"! This homey get-away overlooks beautiful Lake Ontario for amazing sunset views! Our updated 100-year old charmer features a big yard in a quiet neighborhood setting but we're within easy walking distance to the public beach, playground and skate park, historic lighthouse, free summer concerts, and all the village restaurants and bars. Bring your camera- you'll find lots of stunning settings to serve as backdrops for a wonderful vacation!

Top guest favorite
A cozy living area features warm wood flooring and a television on a modern console. A comfortable chair with a colorful throw pillow is positioned near a fireplace. Art pieces with muted tones are displayed on the wall, complementing the inviting atmosphere.
Home in Skaneateles
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 148 reviews

Newly updated, pet-friendly home in Skaneateles!

Relax at this peaceful place to stay right in Skaneateles! This cheerful, private, newly updated 2-bedroom residential home is close to town in a quiet neighborhood. Enjoy fun summer dinners on the large patio with gas grill. Walk or bike the short mile into town to enjoy Skaneateles Lake and all that our beautiful village has to offer! Shopping, dining, boating, hiking, wineries and breweries are all close by, ready to enjoy, no matter the season!

Guest favorite
The exterior of the property features a well-maintained wooden staircase leading to a front door. Large windows provide natural light, and a satellite dish is mounted on the side. A green lawn offers space for outdoor activities, surrounded by a tidy walkway.
Home in Oswego
4.79 out of 5 average rating, 107 reviews

Home Sweet Home

Bring the whole family to this great place with lots of room for fun. No hidden fees. 3 large bedrooms and 2 full baths with washer and dryer. It does list 6 but you are able to sleep more especially with kids. This is pet friendly. what your pet leaves please pick up. Close to the speedway. Quiet neighborhood. BBQ Grill and utensils provided. Fire pit and setting area in the back with wood to purchase. Stay for a few nights or a few months.

Top guest favorite
The exterior of the Reid-Tanner House is showcased in the evening light, featuring a classic colonial revival design. The front porch is marked by decorative railings and two symmetrical entries, surrounded by blooming yellow flowers and stately trees, with a soft sunset illuminating the background.
Home in Oswego
5 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

The Reid-Tanner House

The Reid-Tanner House exemplifies the timeless beauty of Oswego's golden age. Located in the historic Washington Square District, the double lot and buildings were owned by the Reid family, founders of Reid & Company hardware established in the late 1800s. The Reid family owned the property for fifty years before transferring to the Tanner family who also lived in the house for decades.

Top guest favorite
The exterior of a renovated 1800s schoolhouse is showcased, featuring a striking red facade and white trim. A bell tower is positioned above the entrance. The surrounding landscape is blanketed in light snowfall, complementing the serene rural setting.
Home in Canandaigua
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 104 reviews

Renovated 1800s Schoolhouse with 2 bedrooms

Make history a part of your vacation in this renovated 1800s schoolhouse. This historic house is located in the heart of the Finger Lakes. Built in 1886 and in service as a one room school until 1952, this home is truly a special place. Whether you are visiting from afar or looking to unwind on a peaceful staycation, this private two-acre space is your cozy home away from home.

Top guest favorite
A two-story yellow home features a welcoming front porch with steps leading to the entrance. Decorative planters with flowers are placed beside the pathway, while a screen porch is visible on one side. Mature trees frame the property, adding greenery to the surroundings.
Home in Seneca Falls
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 183 reviews

Quiet Accommodations Seneca Falls

Unplug in this 2 story home in the birthplace of the women's suffrage movement and the heart of fingerlakes wine country. Within walking distance of restaurants and historic sites. Seneca Falls attractions include the Women's Rights National Park, wineries, and lakes. Large yard, grill, fire pit, and enclosed screen porch.

Guest favorite
The exterior of a two-story home is presented, featuring a gray facade with white trim. A brick chimney adds character, while a small porch area invites relaxation. Lush greenery surrounds the house, enhancing the welcoming outdoor space.
Home in Seneca Falls
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 289 reviews

Cute & Cozy Blue House

Cozy 2BR home just 2.5 blocks from downtown Seneca Falls! Walk to shops, cafes, and dining, or explore nearby wine trails with 100+ wineries, breweries, and small towns. Features a full kitchen, Wi-Fi, private deck, two bedrooms, and a first-floor bathroom—your perfect Finger Lakes retreat!

Superhost
A single-story house is set in a spacious green yard, surrounded by trees. A wooden deck is visible at the entrance, providing easy access. The exterior features light gray siding and a well-maintained driveway with ample parking visible in the background.
Home in Waterloo
4.77 out of 5 average rating, 435 reviews

Top of the Fingerlakes, relaxing retreat.

Perfectly efficient setup, in a nice neighborhood, that’s in the middle of everything, right at the North end of Seneca lake. 3 minutes from the lake, 5 minutes from downtown Geneva, or 5 minutes from downtown Waterloo. If you're interested, ask about our bicycle and outdoor game rentals.

Top guest favorite
The interior features an open layout with wooden beams and a wooden staircase leading to an upper loft area. A kitchen area with appliances is visible alongside a small dining space with two bar stools. A bookshelf with various books is situated in the corner.
Home in Red Creek
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 299 reviews

Little Guest House for Two

Cozy Little guest house in an out-of-the-way hamlet outside of Red Creek NY makes a comfortable haven with nearby access to many central NY destinations. Private, usually quiet, full kitchen.

Popular amenities for Sodus Bay house rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Wayne County
  5. Sodus Bay
  6. House rentals