Lake house vacation rentals in New Buffalo

Find and book unique lake houses on Airbnb

Top-rated lake house rentals in New Buffalo

Guests agree: these lake houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Guest favorite

Home in Michigan City

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 109 reviews

Michigan City Family Friendly Beach Escape

Enjoy a relaxing stay at one of the best beaches on fresh water Lake Michigan in our century old former fisherman’s cottage updated to fit today’s lifestyle. This 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom house is perfect for large or extended families looking to relax and enjoy a few days away but still close to restaurants and other activities. Spend your days with STEP FREE access to a wide and clean sandy beach, evenings with picturesque sunsets and nights by the fire. Truly a hidden gem in Northwest Indiana.

LocationFamilyWalkability

Guest favorite

The game area features various arcade games, including a shuffleboard table and foosball. A large projector and ping pong table are present, alongside colorful murals depicting the local scenery. The inviting space emphasizes relaxation and entertainment, supported by comfortable seating arrangements.

Home in New Buffalo

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 150 reviews

Arcade/Game Room • Private Beach Access • Fire Pit

Spacious, completely remodeled home with 4 bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, 2 living areas, game room w/ mural, arcade games, ping pong, shuffleboard, foosball & pop-a-shot, outdoor living space w/ screened in patio Located in a charming neighborhood with private beach access 1/2 mile from the house. -5 minutes to downtown New Buffalo -10 minutes to downtown Michigan City -10 minutes to Lighthouse Premium Outlets -20 minutes to Indiana Dunes National Park -within 10 minutes of 2 different casinos

ValueLocationView

Top guest favorite

The living area showcases a modern design with a black sectional sofa and comfortable armchairs. A wooden coffee table is positioned at the center, and wooden beams complement the ceiling. A staircase leads to an upper level, while a large circular mirror enhances the space.

Home in Three Oaks

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 247 reviews

The Walnut House, Michigan Woods Retreat

Beautifully designed home, surrounded by trees. 5 minutes drive from the white sandy beaches of Lake Michigan, and conveniently close to historic Three Oaks downtown: Journeyman whiskey distillery, Acorn Theater, Froehlich's bakery and deli, Patellie's pizza and more. The home has beautiful large windows in every room and bedroom. It is well stocked with books, thoughtfully appointed rooms that are perfect for a quiet escape, family retreat, and home base for exploring the areas activities.

ValueLocationIndoor spaces

Top guest favorite

The exterior of the home features a charming design with a welcoming front porch and a peaked roof. Soft lighting highlights the entrance, surrounded by lush greenery and well-placed flower pots. The stone accents and wooden details contribute to a cozy cottage aesthetic.

Home in Lakeside

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 101 reviews

Hot tub! Starlight cottage in Lakeside!

Feel relaxed, refreshed, & recharged! Our home is the perfect blend of comfort & cottage charm!Home is 2450 sq. ft., 3 bdrm,3 bth (2 BR, 2 BA in main home),updated & features a full kitchen, laundry room,6 TV’s,WiFi, & 2 eating areas.Attached guest apt. has 1 bdrm,1 bth upstairs w/ full kitchen,w/d,king bed, kids cubby w/ queen size gel mattress, & 2 TV’s.Guest apt. is attached & is perfect for people in your party requiring privacy!Close to everything but “socially distanced” in Lakeside!

LocationFamilyView

Guest favorite

A stylish living area features a blue sofa with throw pillows, situated on a patterned rug. Natural light streams through a skylight, illuminating the open layout that includes a dining space and kitchen with modern appliances. Minimalist decor enhances the inviting ambiance.

Home in New Buffalo

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 236 reviews

Steps to Beach & Starbucks! Private Yard, Firepit!

Walk to Starbucks! Walk to beach, cafes, shops, ice cream, grocery! 2 queen bed 2 bath home is perfect to enjoy fenced yard, grill, fire pit, & yard games! Take a few days to explore wineries/breweries, art galleries, antique stores, kayaking, casino and more! Live bands Fridays/Saturdays till around 2am Memorial Weekend to Fall, New Year's at Casey's (behind property). Noise machines in each bdrm. Pet fee $100, 2 dogs MAX. Exterior areas have video/audio cameras w/live feeds. Wp#bcnbwmech

FamilyLocationHeating

Top guest favorite

A charming lake cottage is showcased, featuring a light-colored exterior and large windows that invite natural light. A welcoming front deck is visible, with steps leading down to a landscaped yard and the surrounding greenery, enhancing the serene outdoor environment.

Home in Benton Harbor

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 193 reviews

Panoramic Views/Beach/Hot Tub/Sauna/Cold Plunge

Welcome The Windover! • Private Beach • Panoramic Lake Michigan Views • Hot Tub, Sauna, Cold Plunge, Outdoor Shower •Expansive Yard /Outside Activities • 4 minutes to downtown St. Joseph, The Benton Harbor Arts District, and Harbor Shores • Centrally located Close to 6 Local Beaches Fine and Casual Dining World Class Golfing Wineries Breweries Nature Parks Mountain Bike Trail Park 1/4 from Property Curious Kids Museum Compass Fountain Silver Beach Carousel St. Joseph Lighthouse

FamilyValueComfort

Guest favorite

The charming two-story home features a wide front porch with ample seating and decorative lighting. White railings and a wooden design enhance its appeal. Flanking trees provide some greenery, and the entryway is welcoming with its open doors and stylish decor.

Home in Michigan City

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 203 reviews

5 Bedroom Luxury Home In Heart of Beachwalk Resort

Beautiful home in the heart of Beachwalk, across the street from Lake Kai, pools, basketball & tennis courts and 2 blocks to Lake Michigan. This home is bursting with charm. Front porch runs the width of the house. Dining area opens up to family room with a lovely fireplace. Stunning master bedroom w/walk-in closet and beautiful new bathroom with all the finishes. 3 more bedrooms upstairs, one with full bathroom attached and the other 2 sharing bathroom. 5th bedroom on the lower level.

FamilyValueBeach

Top guest favorite

A spacious living area is presented with large windows allowing natural light to fill the room. A dark sectional sofa, accented with red pillows, faces a wooden coffee table. A light-colored armchair and a small ottoman complement the cozy setting, while a framed rug adds warmth to the wooden floor.

Home in Grand Beach

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 139 reviews

Superhost, hot tub, golf cart, fire pit, large!

Newly renovated 5 bed, 2 bath home in the quaint village of Grand Beach. Golf cart included with rental (in season - May thru mid-Nov). Home is situated on a large lot, high on a sand dune that overlooks the 6th fairway and park area. Enjoy two large decks and year-round eight person hot tub. The property is very private, on secluded street and fully stocked for a great stay. It's a great place to enjoy some down time in an idyllic village in the heart of Michigan's "Harbor Country."

LocationValueBeach

Top guest favorite

Home in La Porte

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 254 reviews

Aunt Betty's Lakeside Abode, Hot Tub Steam Shower

Aunt Betty’s Lakeside Abode offers 3 king bedrooms, 2.5 baths, 2 twin cots, west-facing beautiful Stone Lake views, screened porch with gas fire, lakeside terrace, and year-round hot tub. Enjoy multiple gathering areas, a steam shower, ping-pong. Perfect for families, couples, or groups exploring LaPorte County, Indiana Dunes or wineries, breweries, trails surrounding Lake Michigan. Sleeps 8, or book with Uncle Larry’s Lake Place next door for larger groups and shared lakefront fun!

ValueLocationHiking

Guest favorite

An inviting pool area is surrounded by a wooden deck, featuring comfortable seating arrangements and a large red umbrella providing shade. Lush greenery stands tall in the background, complementing the serene atmosphere of the private fenced space.

Home in Lakeside

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 102 reviews

Lakeside with heated pool & pvt beach access!

LAKESIDE COTTAGE - POOL, HOT TUB & RARE semi-private Lake Michigan access to gorgeous beach shared by just 10 homes, so it’s never crowded! Beach access is a 7-min walk away (no parking). The pool will close Sept 16th, 2027 this year! Charming, sun-filled cottage sleeps 8 (3BR + pull-out). Heated 85 degree pool (May 22–Sept 15), new hot tub, fire pit, gas fireplace, spacious deck, bluestone patio & grill. 10 mins to New Buffalo, Whistle Stop, coffee - just steps away!

FamilyLocationLayout

Top guest favorite

A private backyard features a patio space with a table surrounded by four chairs. The area is paved with stones and includes a raised wooden deck, a grill on the deck, and flower beds adding a touch of greenery. The house is painted in a warm peach color.

Home in Michigan City

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 188 reviews

Midcentury marvel steps from beach! Pups

Year-round beach fun an hour from Chicago!Welcome to Barefoot Bungalow, a mid-century marvel with modern amenities. Your group will love the game room with pool table, ping pong. Private dog-friendly fenced backyard with grill, patio & firepit. Short stroll to Stop 7 to beach (Beachwalk boardwalk, wagon provided). Quiet relaxation far from the madding crowds. So many excellent restaurants, shopping, brew pubs, wineries, hiking, biking. Off-street parking, Wave bus

ValueLocationSleep quality

Guest favorite

The exterior of the cottage is framed by lush greenery, featuring a covered patio with wooden beams. Seating is arranged under the structure, inviting relaxation. The space is surrounded by decorative landscaping and opens to a tranquil forest backdrop.

Home in Union Pier

4.87 out of 5 average rating, 206 reviews

Barn & Beach Guest house New Buffalo/Union Pier

MODERN cottage located at ground zero in Union Pier ! Location is just the BEST !! 2200sq ft , 4 bed , 2 bath , hot tub . 6 blocks to Townline beach , Timothy’s, Red Arrow Road house , Whistle stop , 1 block to Seeds Brewery ,Union Pier Social , Black Currant Bakery , 2 grocery & beach store . Bike path directly across street , plenty of bikes to use ! (Main home in front also available for large groups , there’s room for up to 25 people with both homes ).

LocationFamilyHospitality