Vacation rentals with lake access in New Buffalo

Me and my pup stayed here for a quick peaceful weekend getaway and it was the best experience we could ever ask for! The place was super clean and just like described and the sunset at the private beach was so beautiful. Alyese was super friendly and helpful and was quick to respond if I ever had questions! I would 100% visit this cute place again with Bruno! 🥹

This place was amazing! For 8 guys staying, it could not have been better. EVERYTHING you want to do is also right near by. Travis and Regan are great hosts who communicate quickly and are incredibly friendly. I highly recommend this to anyone looking for a weekend getaway. WITHOUT A DOUBT COMING BACK!

We had a wonderful stay at Heather & Lydia’s home! Their customer service is top-notch! The space was peaceful, beautifully and thoughtfully designed, and surrounded by nature—perfect for a relaxing getaway. The location is ideal, just minutes from biking and hiking trails, and close to New Buffalo, MI—one of our family’s favorite spots for great restaurants. It was Mother’s Day weekend, and I truly appreciated the welcome gift—a heartfelt and personal touch. Their clear, concise instructions made check-in and check-out easy and stress-free. Every detail made our stay feel special. We loved every minute and can’t wait to return. Wishing them many more happy guests!

We had a wonderful stay at this Airbnb! My parents thoroughly enjoyed the home and repeatedly mentioned how it truly felt like home. The place is peaceful, cozy, and perfect for a relaxing family outing. Everything we needed for a comfortable stay was thoughtfully provided. Highly recommended for anyone looking for a quiet and homely getaway!

We needed a quiet weekend and Pati’s place delivered: Great, cozy spot. Close to restaurants and activities.

Would highly recommend this charming beach house for your getaway. Walkable beach access to Lake Michigan. Indiana Sand Dunes just a few miles away, along with delightful cafes and restaurants. The comfortable beds, linens and space created an inviting space to wind down after a day of outdooring! And the jacuzzi tub to soak those sore bones. We were visited by several deer while enjoying the outdoor lounging areas.

Absolutely perfect! Great spot to retreat from it all. Beautiful home and location. Super nice hosts!

Why I loved this house…First of all location. You are in the center of Michiana Beach Life here and a short walk to the Lake. I grew up in this area and have spent a lot of time in MC and New Buffalo and Candice’s house offers the best of a Lake Michigan vacation w/out the crowded noisy tourist vibe of some areas along Lakeshore. The house is super cute, super clean, the decor is awesome and legit Midcentury pieces to match the era of the home, the yard is exceptional (great for families & dogs), the neighbors are nice, the neighborhood is really peaceful and quiet: you primarily only hear birds. We had everything we needed for a great stay including all the beach gear you would need from chairs, to a cooler w/ wheels and a large beach wagon and they even have bikes. Having 4 bikes available for use is wonderful and this area is prime for biking. The beds are comfy, appliances all new and top notch, plenty of towels etc… I highly recommend Candice’s home. A+

Carlos place was everything we expected and more. We loved that it had a hot tub. It was very clean. The loft was so clean and so beautiful. Perfect for our one night stay!

Really nice, remodeled home! We loved our stay, the beds were comfy, and we loved relaxing in the living room after our jobs were done. We ate at the bar that was next to the home. AMAZING FOODIES‼️🫶 HIGHLY recommend this place, and look forward to staying again in the future.

My two girlfriends and I stayed here for two nights and it has the most beautiful view of Lake Michigan! We arrived later in the evening and were so thankful that our host left us with restaurant menus and recommendations, we loved the pizza. Place was clean and very well stocked with linens and even coffee and some water in the fridge. The beach is a steep staircase away (it was a bit rough, and my legs hurt, but it’s worth the trek). Also thank you sooo much for letting us use your beach chairs! We stayed on the beach from sunrise to sunset. It was magical and the views are to die for! Our only complaint would be the lack of communication that the host would be staying on site during the same weekend as us. The listing brags about a private beach and yet at one point the hosts wife appeared 15-20 feet sitting directly behind us reading a book. We felt like teenagers being watched by our mother. We decided to take a walk, and when we came back she was gone, but it was weird.

My husband and I stayed at Irene’s place for a weekend get away. The apartment was easy to access and on a very private street. Irena is friendly and responds quickly. As stated in her post, it really was a 3 minute walk to the beach. We were provided with extra towels, shampoo, conditioner and body wash. There is a private patio and beach towels provided, but you need to grab your own firewood. We had a concert in Chicago and it was only a 30-40min drive to Solider Field, Navy Pier and Shedd Aquarium. This place was a gem and a romantic destination, we will definitely book again!

The location is excellent! Very walkable to town and Lake Michigan. The bed is on the firm side if you like that and bedroom is small. Netflix available was a plus.

Thank you very much for your hospitality. It was a great place to stay.

Erica's listing was great. I would stay there again for sure. amazing communication and since the place was not booked before or after she gave us early check in/late check out if we wanted to utilize it.

Loved our stay! It was right next to the beach and great restaurants. The guide provided was fantastic as well!

Really beautiful place in a great location. The pictures don’t really do it justice. Very relaxing and peaceful. Short walk to the beach. Great restaurants close by. It was perfect for a weekend getaway. Highly recommend.

Fantastic location, close to downtown but the loudest noise besides a little thunder were the waves hitting the beach. Definitely booking again.

The house is quiet, clean, cozy, and beautifully decorated. It had everything I needed for a comfortable stay. The kitchen was fully stocked with cooking tools, making it easy to prepare meals, and the bathroom had all the necessary supplies including towels, shampoo, and body wash. The location is perfect—just a short walk to the beach and only a few minutes' drive to the Indiana Dunes National Park, which made exploring the area super convenient. Stephen was a responsive and responsible host. I highly recommend this place to anyone visiting the area.

Third stay in two weeks. Everything about the cottage and grounds is perfect and I am already looking forward to coming back. Highly recommend!

Lovely home, many well thought out perks like fans in upstairs rooms and beach toys for kids! Info said it was an easy short walk to beach so I spent a whole lot more than I usually would. With children it would not be pleasant and is really not a short walk (and is on a semi busy road) & beach is down a whole lot of steps. BUT there are parking spaces so it was fine. Within the house, the steps are fairly steep at parts & there are 2?big ones going into house &!these were hard for my 70 year old mom w knee issues. So if person reading reviews is one of those people, this might not be THE place. That being said, it is very short walk to community pool & host is very responsive & house is beautiful! My mom mostly stayed within first floor including an awesome bed/bath on ground floor. There are games (although I didn’t love the Ouija board 🫣😂) . This would be a great place for multiple family / friends to split cost ;) Its very beautiful & community pool & hot tub are great!

Where to begin - this place was a gem!! I spent my 30th birthday with friends at Kim's place and it was nothing short of amazing. The neighborhood and lake are serene and peaceful and Kim's unobstructed view is incredible. The sunroom is charming, bright and so cute; I could've spent my entire trip in that room looking out the lake, lol. The hot tub and pontoon were the cherries on top and I cannot wait to visit again. All my guests were buzzing about the house and how they want to book here for their own future trips. Thank you so much for everything, Kim!! Your house made my 30th so memorable & I will absolutely be back :) :)

We really loved our stay in Coloma! There was plenty to do around town and the surrounding towns. We enjoyed wineries, sitting down by Little Paw Paw Lake, some great meals and a stunning sunset over Lake Michigan. Liz was so helpful and responsive. We definitely hope to return!

Great place to stay. Christine is a really good host. The house was clean, and the back yard is great. The only thing is that the access to the beach is a bit challenging than described. But, overall, we had a great expereince at Christine's place.