Hotel vacation rentals in Long Island

Clean and close to everything. The townhouse was especially roomy

Amazing stay, this hotel is great! The pool was like a bathtub and the owners kept it open late so I could swim after 8PM! Will be coming back again and again.

Second time staying here, and would stay again. The rooms are small, but clean and comfortable. Hosts helpful and responsive. We were able to get a last minute early check-in, which was great. The water pressure in the shower was excellent. We like that it is budget friendly (for the area) and clean, and family owned!

Perfect spot for 4 friends on a weekend trip to NYC

Amazing amazing amazing! I loved everything about the hotel. The rooms were big, spacious, clean, comfortable, the balcony was a plus and the restaurant near the main lobby had a great bartender; that made our drinks extra good! Also, parking was fairly easy to find and the hotel location was perfectly located close to Manhattan! I would recommend just double checking and confirming the room type you are booking, since there are many different options and room styles! I would stay here over & over again 🌸!

A truly wonderful & amazing host! Very friendly & provides most of what you’ll need :).

Great studio apartment!! Very clean and comfortable and tastefully decorated. Joe was extremely communicative. Right on the water and we enjoyed sitting on the outside furniture. It is a very short ride to the lighthouse and downtown Montauk. A beautiful place! We would love to return someday.

I almost wish i hadn't seen the photos - the Flophouse is unique, quirky and beautiful. René was very thorough and responsive and his friend who looked after the place in his absence was lovely. This was a wonderful place to come home to because it felt like home, not a sterile hotel room. Thank you René and Felipe

My boyfriend and I had tickets to a play and decided in the city overnight. We started our search on Airbnb and I’m so glad we did. . We found Margaritaville and couldn’t be happier with everything about our stay. Check in was easy (and in fact we arrived early and were able to get into our room early), hotel staff couldn’t have been nicer, the room was small but absolutely adorable and very clean, and we had a great view. Great experience and I can’t wait to come back.

Definitely one of the best hotels in the area. Check in is very easy and rooms are always clean.

This is a great place to stay at if you are traveling to Long Island. Quiet, clean, and personnel at the front desk are really friendly. The LIRR is close making it easy to travel to NYC. 100% recommend.

Prime location, the balcony over looking the drag shows is a must. We used Ethan’s services twice because it was that good. Very communicative, very easy, we just had a blast. Will definitely come again next year!

Exceeded our expectations! Amazing place to stay! It gave us that away from home getaway feeling. Gerry was very helpful and responsive. Will definitely be back!

Absolutely awesome stay. More amenities than I originally thought. It was really awesome to see an oven there! Definitely will be back again.

We booked here for a little 'staycation' for our first wedding anniversary! The weather wasn't great, but it worked to our advantage and we got an upgrade :) The ladies at the front were very kind and welcoming. The location is perfect right off the ferry and in the main village, walking distance to everything. We would definitely stay here again!!

Chef Step was a great host! He was incredibly accommodating and super kind. I ended up getting food poisoning and he made me tea and got me some medicine which was very much appreciated. The first morning that we were there, he even cooked for us - chicken and waffles 10/10. I would 1000% stay with Chef Step next time I am in NYC.

Awesome spot! Better than in the pictures!

Sascha is an absolutely wonderful host -- always ready to offer help, and to make sure you feel at home. Her place is impeccably clean, and has both the privacy and the community that you might need, especially in a long stay. Highly recommend.

I can honestly say it was way better than expected. Host reached out to me before I even realized I might miss the check in window and took care of me and my family. Thank you so much.

My reservation at Wavecrest Resort was one of the most beautiful stays I’ve ever had! The pictures provided in the listing do not do the property justice! Also, the staff was very friendly and helpful, and the studio came with everything we need! All cooking utensils, plates, bowls and cups, a burner plate, hair dryer and the most gorgeous views! The tv also comes with all your favorite apps loaded and ready to play! Overall, I would 1000% recommend booking the Wavecrest Resort for your next stay! :)

Wonderful place, very modern, clean , designed and furnished with a lot of love. Also the garden was extraordinary, and we loved the fire pit! Nery was very friendly, proactive and professional.

excellent host

We had a wonderful stay at Maria’s place — it had everything we needed, and it was easy enough to get to other areas of Brooklyn, by train or citibike. She was very responsive and we appreciated the flexibility with check-in and check-out due to our travel schedule. The bedroom faces the street so keep that in mind if you’re a light sleeper, but we were fine for the most part. And, of course, Sana the cat was so friendly and certainly added to the stay!