Hotels in Fire Island

Find and book unique hotels on Airbnb

Top-rated hotels in Fire Island

Guests agree: these hotels are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Superhost
Hotel room in Islandia
4.61 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Near Long Island Aquarium | Free Hot Breakfast

Welcome to Hampton Inn Islandia – your easygoing Long Island base with fast access to NYC, the Hamptons, Montauk, and beaches. Whether you're here for quick business trips, local events, or a weekend escape, this stay gives you the essentials guests love: free hot breakfast, an indoor heated pool, a fitness center, and spacious rooms designed for comfort and convenience. Explore top attractions like Long Island Aquarium, Lakeland County Park, and historic mansions, all within a short drive.

Superhost
A spacious guest room features a king bed dressed in white linens. A light blue accent wall contrasts with natural wood furnishings. A flat-screen TV and a lamp are positioned on a wooden desk near a window, allowing natural light to fill the space.
Hotel room in Times Square
4.87 out of 5 average rating, 215 reviews

Tropical Oasis | Times Square. Heated Pool

A tropical oasis in New York City's world-famous Times Square, Margaritaville Resort Times Square invites you to set your watch to island time, this relaxing retreat is your passport to paradise. For all March Bookings, upon your arrival, you will be welcomed with 2 House Margaritas per stay! Attractions are nearby: ✔Stunning 360 views of NYC at the Empire State Building ✔Astonishing Times Square ✔Strolls through Central Park ✔Warhol/Van Gogh paintings at The Museum of Modern Art

Superhost
The exterior of the Courtyard by Marriott Shelton is showcased, featuring a modern, multi-story structure with large windows. The entrance is prominent, framed by landscaped greenery and a spacious parking area. The building is complemented by soft evening lighting.
Hotel room in Shelton
4.81 out of 5 average rating, 126 reviews

Close to Yale University + The Bistro. Pool. Gym.

Settle into comfort at Courtyard by Marriott Shelton, located near I-95 with easy access to Yale, Downtown New Haven, and area parks. Fuel up with Starbucks® drinks at The Bistro, unwind in the indoor pool, or stay productive in the 24/7 fitness center. Free parking and Wi-Fi keep things simple, while nearby hiking trails, restaurants, and local attractions make it easy to explore. Whether you're in town for work or a weekend escape, this stay makes it feel effortless.

Guest favorite
A well-appointed bedroom features a spacious bed with neatly arranged towels. Natural light fills the room, highlighting the light-colored walls and wood flooring. A modern mirror and a dresser with a warm wood finish are present, contributing to the room's inviting ambiance.
Hotel room in Kismet
5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Moonrise Motel Kismet Unit 101

The Moonrise Motel is a newly renovated vacation spot located in the heart of Kismet, just steps from the Marina. Enjoy our pet friendly, 1, 2 and 3 bedroom units that include a kitchenette, patio seating, courtyard access with BBQ, and an attached outdoor Bar and Market. Other local restaurants are steps away and the beach is just a short walk down the block! Beach chairs and towels are included with your room. We also offer bike rentals for you to ride around town!

Superhost
Hotel room in Brooklyn
4.7 out of 5 average rating, 88 reviews

POD Brooklyn - mezzanine lounge & green courtyard

Enjoy 110 square feet of thoughtfully designed comfort in our Queen Pod, perfect for couples craving a cozy retreat. Stretch out on the custom queen bed, catch your favorite shows on two flat-screen TVs with cable, and stay cool with efficient air conditioning while you work or unwind at the desk, chair, and laptop-sized safe. The glass-enclosed private bathroom features a refreshing rain shower-head and handy hairdryer. Compact footprint, full-size ease.

Superhost
Hotel room in Theater District - Times Square
4.78 out of 5 average rating, 293 reviews

Steps to Central Park | Rooftop Bar. Gym. Dining.

Wake up steps from Central Park and the buzz of Midtown NYC. Sip espresso in a chic, art-filled lobby before exploring 5th Avenue, Broadway, or Central Park’s leafy trails. Come sunset, head to the rooftop for cocktails and city views that steal the show. Whether you’re here to wander, dine, or dance the night away, our hotel puts you in the heart of it all—elevated design, local flavor, and effortless city living rolled into one unforgettable stay.

Superhost
Hotel room in Koreatown
4.83 out of 5 average rating, 150 reviews

Midtown retreat, with a nod to old world elegance

Step into our luxurious retreat inspired by Parisian elegance. This expansive suite offers 9-foot ceilings with large windows, perfect to take in the New York City skyline. Relax and indulge in the comfort of your pillow-top queen sized bed outfitted in plush bedding and linens. Unwind and rejuvenate in your large walk-in shower, adorned with marble countertops, stocked with decadent Italian-made Acca Kappa bath products.

Superhost
A historic building with an ornate facade features intricate brick patterns and ornate architectural details. Illuminated at dusk, the structure contrasts with the surrounding modern skyscrapers, highlighting its timeless elegance amidst the dynamic cityscape.
Hotel room in Times Square
4.86 out of 5 average rating, 231 reviews

Luxe Times | Bryant Park. Fitness Center

Iconic luxury at the heart of NYC's bustling Times Square, The Knickerbocker Hotel offers timeless elegance and unparalleled comfort. Attractions are nearby: ✔Promenades along Central Park ✔Breathtaking views from the Empire State ✔Unforgettable spectacles at Broadway Theatre ✔Astounding Times Square ✔Paintings by Warhol or Van Gogh on display at The Museum of Modern Art.

Superhost
Hotel room in Brooklyn
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

POD Brooklyn - Bunk room in vibrant neighborhood

Stay in our 110 sq. ft. Bunk Pod room with two comfy twin beds, each with its own flat-screen TV. Enjoy modern amenities like air conditioning, a work desk, rainfall shower, and free local calls. All Pods are fully private with en suite bathrooms and entertainment-ready features. Designed for efficiency and fun, nightly rates cover the entire room for up to two guests.

Superhost
Hotel room in Downtown Brooklyn
4.81 out of 5 average rating, 86 reviews

Ace Brooklyn Room – Let Us Surprise You

Discover the unexpected in Brooklyn with our Run of House room at Ace Hotel. When you book this flexible option, you’ll receive one of our thoughtfully designed guest rooms at check-in — chosen based on availability. Whether it’s a cozy King or a more spacious double, each room blends industrial-modern style with warm, local character.

Guest favorite
Hotel room in Midtown East
4.83 out of 5 average rating, 190 reviews

Queen bed and NYC’s fastest WiFi

Our Classic Rooms are ideal for individuals or couples looking for a budget-friendly option to drop their luggage and explore the streets of New York City. A service fee of 100 deposit for incidentals will be required on a credit card, which will be released at checkout, assuming no damages or additional charges to the room.

Guest favorite
A compact guest room features a twin-sized bed with a white quilt and a green accent pillow. A desk with a vintage-style blue drawer and a television is positioned against the wall. Warm lighting is integrated into the wooden features, providing a modern aesthetic.
Hotel room in Manhattan
5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Private Studio with Twin Bed & Bath in Midtown

Experience a cozy retreat in our Twin Size Room! Located near Grand Central Metro Station, allowing you to explore Times Square, Central Park, and the Metropolitan Museum of Art. Surround yourself with cool bars, restaurants, and coffee places, in one of the safest neighborhoods in NYC, near the United Nations.

Popular amenities for Fire Island hotels

Quick stats about hotels in Fire Island

  • Total vacation rentals

    Explore 20 vacation rentals in Fire Island

  • Nightly prices starting at

    Fire Island vacation rentals start at ﺩ.ﺇ881 per night before taxes and fees

  • Verified guest reviews

    Over 280 verified reviews to help you choose

  • Pet-friendly vacation rentals

    Find 10 rentals that welcome pets

  • Wi-Fi availability

    20 of Fire Island vacation rentals include wi-fi access

  • Popular amenities for guests

    Guests love Kitchen, Wifi, and Pool across Fire Island rentals

  • 4.9 Average rating

    Fire Island stays are highly rated by guests—averaging 4.9 out of 5!

  • Nearby attractions

    Fire Island's top spots, include Fire Island National Seashore, Islip Cinemas, and Plaza Cinema & Media Arts Center

Destinations to explore

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Suffolk County
  5. Fire Island
  6. Hotel rooms