Become a host

Cottage vacation rentals in Fire Island

Find and book unique cottages on Airbnb

Quick stats about cottage rentals in Fire Island

  • Total vacation rentals

    Explore 20 vacation rentals in Fire Island

  • Nightly prices starting at

    Fire Island vacation rentals start at ﺩ.ﺇ 551 per night before taxes and fees

  • Verified guest reviews

    Over 970 verified reviews to help you choose

  • Family-friendly vacation rentals

    20 properties offer extra space & kid-friendly amenities

  • Pet-friendly vacation rentals

    Find 10 rentals that welcome pets

  • Wi-Fi availability

    20 of Fire Island vacation rentals include wi-fi access

  • Popular amenities for guests

    Guests love Kitchen, Wifi, and Pool across Fire Island rentals

  • 4.9 Average rating

    Fire Island stays are highly rated by guests—averaging 4.9 out of 5!

  • Nearby attractions

    Fire Island's top spots, include Fire Island National Seashore, Islip Cinemas, and Loughlin Vineyard

Top-rated cottage rentals in Fire Island

Guests agree: these cottages are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Guest favorite
A charming cottage with a red exterior is surrounded by a lush garden filled with various plants and flowers. A spacious covered porch extends across the front, offering a welcoming entryway. The well-manicured lawn is complemented by vibrant greenery and colorful blooms, creating a pleasant outdoor space.
Cottage in Mount Sinai

The Red Cottage Circa 1936

This cottage is a gem to be found! From the primary room to the charming loft, this cottage can sleep 6! There is a full working kitchen. For those who wish to do exploring, you will be centrally located on LI giving you great ease in using LI rail road (.5 mile) from cottage and Port Jeff Ferry (1mile)from cottage. There is a large fenced in yard with BBQ and outdoor seating if you wish to dine in. Dogs are allowed w/prior notice and a $65 pet fee per dog. You won’t beat this value reserve now.

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 557 reviews
Guest favorite
A spacious pool area is framed by well-maintained greenery and flowering plants. Two large umbrellas provide shade over lounge chairs beside a sparkling pool, with expansive coastal views and a serene landscape of grasses and trees beyond.
Cottage in Guilford

Luxury cottage by the sea with hot tub and pool

We built this guest cottage to provide an ultimate luxury experience for people wanting to escape from hectic life!With incredible coastal views, this home is a haven of tranquility. It sits on a special stretch of the Connecticut coast, with spectacular bird and wild life-watching year-round. Enjoy great shopping in Guilford's boutiques around the historic town green. Watch the sun set over the water and relax in the hottub for some night time star gazing year round (pool open June-beg/mid Oct)

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 212 reviews
Guest favorite
A spacious deck offers a panoramic view of the beach and water, with sunlight reflecting off the surface. Colorful chairs are positioned for relaxation, while shadows created by the railing add depth to the scene. The sandy shore can be seen in the distance.
Cottage in Milford

Cheerful 3 Bedroom Cottage with Fire Place

We are happy to still offer some dates for September. Come enjoy the solitude of the beach as the tide ebbs & flows. Reconnect with loved ones in this family-friendly place. Enjoy strolls on the beach located just out the back door or a sunset meal on the back porch. This wonderful cottage offers everything you will need during your stay. Including, comfortable beds, beach strolls and a bright upgraded kitchen with many amenities. The 3 bedrooms will fit up to 8 people comfortably.

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 109 reviews
Top guest favorite
Cottage in Branford

Water Views & July 4 Fireworks – June 27, 2026

Quaint and romantic beachside retreat along the Connecticut shoreline, featuring spectacular waterfront views, breathtaking sunrises and July 4 Fireworks. Just 100 steps from the beach, with a cozy fire pit in the yard for relaxing evenings by the water. Enjoy swimming, kayaking, and other seaside activities, along with many exceptional local restaurants nearby. Conveniently located just 5 minutes from the Shore Line East train station and only a 10-minute drive or train ride to New Haven.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 181 reviews
Guest favorite
A two-story beach cottage is presented with a light exterior and a spacious balcony. Large sliding glass doors are visible at the lower level, providing easy access to the outdoor space. Nearby, a driveway is seen leading towards the garage.
Cottage in Westbrook

A Beach House Gem

Beautiful beach cottage with a private beach. Sleeps up to 6 comfortably with two full beds and 1 queen in the master. with a beautiful balcony Full bath upstairs,1/2 off the kitchen entrance outside key on the key chain The main living area has a TV, air conditioning, and sliding doors to a deck. The updated kitchen has a dishwasher, microwave, cooktop, oven, and coffee maker. There are 2 parking spots in front of the garage The house is not winterized there are no bookings from Nov1

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews
Top guest favorite
Cottage in Milford

3BR Cottage Walk to Beach and Tyde Wedding Venue

Walking distance from Walnut Beach and Tyde Wedding Venue! Stay at this cozy 3-bedroom (King, Queen + Twin), 1-bath beach cottage in the heart of Walnut Beach. Perfect for family vacations, wedding guests, or Yale visitors, the cottage features a full kitchen, private backyard, fire pit, and peaceful coastal vibes. Walk to the sand, celebrate at Tyde, enjoy coffee on the porch, and relax by the fire pit. Firewood is not provided. Comfort, style, and location — all in one unforgettable stay!

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 181 reviews
Top guest favorite
Cottage in South Salem

Oscaleta Guest House: Lakefront Cabin

Escapology-A spectacular lakeside destination, designed as a luxury suite with its own dock. Close to NYC and ideal for a quick trip, remote work or an extended retreat. Glamping-A cabin in the woods on a lake surrounded by nature, but tech-enabled with all the modern perks. Artfully Designed Space-Modern retrofit thoughtfully curated with custom artwork throughout this historic 1920's cottage. Purpose built for your outdoor routine- from grill to canoe…. We recommend 3+nights if you can.

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 141 reviews
Top guest favorite
A light-filled living space is highlighted by a wall of glass, providing expansive views of the water and a natural landscape. The space includes a round coffee table on a light floor, with comfortable seating arranged to enjoy the serene outdoor scenery.
Cottage in Riverhead

Savor Ocean Sunsets at a Soothing Beachfront Haven

Newly renovated and featured as a top Airbnb by New York Magazine, The Beach Cottage has been designed and decorated in a modern organic style, with a palette of whites and neutrals to create a serene and peaceful escape. Relax in the airy, light and open living room, which features a wall of glass for indoor/outdoor living with expansive, uninterrupted water views. Stay on the property for swimming, beach walks, sunsets and BBQs - or venture out to enjoy all the North Fork has to offer.

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 184 reviews
Superhost
Cottage in Branford

Cozy 2 Story Cottage in Short Beach Community

A cozy home in a beach community that has a central location with easy access to outdoor activities & local restaurants. The home is also 5 minutes from the Branford Train Station, Stony Creek Brewery, & Branford's town center. We are also a 10 minute drive from New Haven, home to Yale University, Yale Hospital and other colleges/universities. Our guests also gain access to Johnsons' Beach, a private residents only beach, located just around the corner from the home (3 minute walk)

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 271 reviews
Top guest favorite
A modern, two-story structure showcases large windows framed by climbing greenery. A stone pathway leads to a glass-paneled door, with potted flowers positioned along the entrance. The surrounding area is filled with trees, creating a serene atmosphere.
Cottage in Weston

The River Loft

Escape to The River Loft, a private riverfront retreat in Weston, CT. Built in 2015 by a visionary local architect, The River Loft open-air design seamlessly integrates the outdoors with the interior space. As you step inside this 750 sf small home, you'll be instantly captivated by the layout that makes it feel spacious. Sitting on over 2 acres of forested land with private river access. Book now for an unforgettable experience. For more images & videos visit insta @the.riverloft

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 247 reviews
Top guest favorite
A welcoming living area features a comfortable couch and a textured ottoman, complemented by natural wood accents on the ceiling. Light fills the space from multiple windows, highlighting the hardwood floors and decorative stone wall that adds character to the room.
Cottage in Milford

Summer Sale! CozyCottage/Pet-friendly/ WalktoBeach

Inspired by my Dad's wanderlust and love of sea & sand. Relax and unwind in this completely remodeled, stylish Cottage a block and a half from Long Island Sound and .9 mile to Walnut Beach - walk to coffee, pizza, lobster shack! We offer a modern kitchen, breakfast nook, dining area, natural stone wall, parking and W/D. Located in a charming coastal town - enjoy quiet neighborhood walks, coastal trails, boardwalk, breweries and restaurants. 15 min to Yale/New Haven, 65 mi to NYC.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 421 reviews
Guest favorite
The exterior of a private cottage is presented, showcasing a gray wood-paneled facade with a light-colored front door. Well-maintained landscaping includes shrubs and grass, leading to a concrete pathway. A wooden fence and trees provide a natural backdrop.
Cottage in Kings Park

Cozy Riverside Cottage

This is a private cottage on its own lot with its own driveway and yard located in a quiet residential neighborhood. Several grocery stores and restaurants for delivery/pick up in the area. 400 MBPS Internet connection for those who need a reliable internet connection for work/movie streaming! Please note guest maximum is 4. There are no additional guests or visitors allowed.

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 201 reviews

Popular amenities for Fire Island cottage rentals

KitchenWifiPoolFree parking on premisesAir conditioning

Cottage rentals with a hot tub

Guest favorite
An open-concept living space features a modern dining area with a wooden table set for six, complemented by sleek metallic chairs. A comfortable sectional sofa is positioned across from a wall-mounted television, with a fireplace and green outdoor views visible through large windows.
Cottage in Bridgehampton

Calf Creek Cottage (Water Mill/Bridgehampton)

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews
Guest favorite
Cottage in Hampton Bays

Swim into Fall & Hot Tub through Winter!

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews
Top guest favorite
Cottage in Bridgehampton

Cozy Bridgehampton Cottage w/Hot Tub & Fire Pit

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews
Superhost
An expansive wooden deck is depicted, surrounded by greenery. Low wooden planters are positioned along the railing, providing a natural element. The clear blue sky and subtle hints of the bay can be seen in the distance, creating a serene outdoor space.
Cottage in Amagansett

4 Br Beach House; Short Walk to Beach!

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews
Guest favorite
A large gunite pool is surrounded by a well-maintained grassy yard, featuring comfortable lounge chairs on a sunbathing area. Lush trees provide shade, while a charming cottage stands in the background, contributing to a serene outdoor setting.
Cottage in Bellport

Renovated Historic Cottage w/ Pool Bellport Vllage

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviewsAn open living space is shown with a spiral staircase leading to an upper level. A comfortable seating area is arranged with a soft couch and armchair. A dining table with wooden chairs is positioned near a large window, while a television is mounted on the wall.
Cottage in Old Lyme

Private Beach Cottage in Point O'Woods

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 274 reviewsA charming red cottage is framed by lush greenery, set back from a driveway leading to the entrance. A small white bench is visible on the left side of the well-maintained lawn, with flowering plants adding a touch of color in front of the house.
Cottage in North Fork

Lovely 2 BR Beach House No. Shore

4.69 out of 5 average rating, 213 reviewsThe living area features a comfortable sofa adorned with a striped throw, a coffee table, and a television. Nearby, a dining space is set for meals, with natural light illuminating the room through large windows framed by light curtains.
Cottage in Bellport

Bellport Inn, Charming Cottage in the Village!

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Pet-friendly cottage rentals

Top guest favorite
The sunroom features a light pink wall and a high ceiling with exposed beams. A comfortable wicker sofa with decorative throw pillows accompanies two matching chairs. A patterned area rug covers the floor, while a small table sits in the center. Soft light filters through sheer curtains.
Cottage in Guilford

Charm + location. Walk to beach, town, & harbor.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 310 reviews
Guest favorite
The image captures a serene beach scene at sunset, with soft colors reflecting on the calm water. Silhouetted figures are seen on the shore, engaged in various activities as the sun sets on the horizon, creating a peaceful atmosphere.
Cottage in Rocky Point

Adorable cottage

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 193 reviews
Guest favorite
A riverfront deck is furnished with two lounge chairs and a glass table, surrounded by lush greenery and trees. The view overlooks a calm stretch of the Patchogue River, creating a serene environment for relaxation and enjoyment of nature.
Cottage in Westbrook

Peaceful Riverfront Cottage w/Dock, Walk to Beach

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 234 reviews
Top guest favorite
The living area features a vaulted ceiling with bright natural light streaming through large windows. A cozy seating arrangement includes a light grey couch and a comfortable chair. A stylized coffee table sits in the center, with a dining table set for two nearby.
Cottage in East Lyme

Your Nest Near The Beach

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 330 reviews
Guest favorite
A quaint cottage is nestled among vibrant trees, showcasing rich foliage in shades of green and burgundy. A well-kept lawn surrounds the cottage, with a white door framed by flower beds. The serene setting invites relaxation in a natural environment.
Cottage in South Salem

Private cottage in horse country &1 hour from NYC!

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 283 reviews
Guest favorite
The living room features a bright and airy arrangement with a large white sectional sofa and a coffee table at the center. Natural light streams through the wide windows, creating a welcoming environment. A front door and a lamp add to the cozy feel of the space.
Cottage in Hampton Bays

Hamptons Cottage 3-minute walk to breezy bay beach

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 151 reviews
Top guest favorite
A spacious loft area features high ceilings with exposed beams and warm wooden accents. Two comfortable leather sofas face a central ottoman, surrounded by artwork and decor. Natural light floods in through large windows, highlighting the rich wooden floors and a decorative rug.
Cottage in Black Rock

Spacious Cottage Loft

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews
Top guest favorite
A living room features natural light streaming through windows, enhancing the warm wood floors. A brown sofa is paired with a woven lounge chair, and a blue coffee table is centered on a light-patterned rug. Wall-mounted shelves display framed art and decorative items.
Cottage in Old Saybrook

1920’s charming dollhouse near South Cove

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 113 reviews

Private cottage rentals

Top guest favorite
A bright living area features a comfortable sofa set against a white wall, paired with a wooden coffee table. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, while a patterned area rug adds warmth beneath. A modern chair and a small storage unit are also visible.
Cottage in Valhalla

Charming private 1BR apt. Easy access to NYC

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 340 reviews
Top guest favorite
A tranquil lakeside scene at sunset features vibrant pink and orange hues reflected on the calm water. Silhouetted trees line the shore, and rolling mountains rise in the distance, creating a serene backdrop.
Cottage in South Salem

Serene lake front cottage 1 hour from NYC

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews
Top guest favorite
A traditional New England-style house features a front porch supported by white columns. Two white chairs and a small table are arranged on the porch, complemented by a dark front door. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, surrounded by green landscaped areas.
Cottage in Shelter Island

3 Bedroom Cottage Gem

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 131 reviews
Top guest favorite
A welcoming view of Belle Vue Cottage features a well-kept lawn with a sign indicating its name. The cottage is framed by trees, with a driveway leading to it. A garage is visible in the background, contributing to the serene atmosphere of the neighborhood.
Cottage in Old Saybrook

Belle Vue Cottage

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 169 reviews
Guest favorite
A private deck overlooks a tranquil marsh, framed by vibrant flowers in terracotta pots. A shaded seating area includes a couch with cushions and a small table, inviting relaxation while enjoying the serene view of the water and surrounding natural greenery.
Cottage in Branford

Enchanted Cottage on the Marsh, walk to beach

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 139 reviews
Guest favorite
A single-story house is set against a backdrop of green grass and towering trees. Natural light illuminates the exterior, which features light-colored siding and a welcoming front porch. The spacious yard provides ample outdoor space for relaxation.
Cottage in North Fork

Riverhead Farmhouse

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 118 reviews
Top guest favorite
The living area features two comfortable sofas, a wooden coffee table, and a dining table set for four. A window allows natural light to fill the space, while decor accents create a relaxed environment. Air conditioning unit is visible on the wall.
Cottage in East Hampton

Carriage House - Cottage in East Hampton Village

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 387 reviews
Top guest favorite
A charming entrance is framed by an archway adorned with decorative ironwork. The door, painted in a soft turquoise, is complemented by a welcoming wreath. Lush green foliage surrounds the entryway, creating a serene outdoor environment.
Cottage in Old Saybrook

The Cottage

4.75 out of 5 average rating, 261 reviews

Destinations to explore