House vacation rentals in Casey Key

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Casey Key

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Guest favorite
A spacious living area features two large sofas and a patterned accent chair arranged around a central coffee table. Tall windows allow natural light to fill the room, highlighting the neutral color palette. A staircase leads to the upper level, enhancing the open layout.
Home in Nokomis
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 209 reviews

4/2.5 Oak Bahay, Heated Pool! 5min to Beach,4Acres

Welcome to Oak Bahay Ranch, our beautiful 4+ acre ranch home with pool! Enjoy the tranquility of this 4 bedroom/2.5 bathrooms with a pool (heated during winter). Bike or drive the quick 2.5 miles to Nokomis and Casey Key Beaches! Oak Bahay Ranch is a nature lover's paradise, close to Legacy Trail, Sarasota County's premier 20+ mile biking/walking trail. Oak Bahay Ranch is an easy drive to world famous Siesta Key Beach (15 mins), downtown Sarasota (20 mins), and downtown Venice (10 mins).

Top guest favorite
Home in Nokomis
5 out of 5 average rating, 30 reviews

Comfortable Coastal Retreat. 2 Blocks From Beach

Two blocks to Nokomis Beach. Walk to waterfront dining, ice cream, and local shops without touching your car. This fully renovated 3BR/2BA home has everything your family needs for an easy beach trip. A private king suite with its own bath and entrance, two queen bedrooms, a fully stocked kitchen, and all the beach gear you could want (chairs, umbrellas, towels, wagon, even shark tooth kits for the kids). Fast WiFi, smart TVs, gas grill, outdoor shower, and washer/dryer. Just show up and relax.

Guest favorite
An outdoor seating area is presented with dark wicker furniture, blue cushions, and an orange throw draped over the arm. A table sits in the center, with manicured grass and a view of the waterfront in the background, framed by a decorative gazebo.
Home in Venice
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 171 reviews

MCM Waterfront Retreat • Dock, Kayaks & Beaches

Welcome to our Mid-Century Modern waterfront escape on Curry Creek, minutes from Nokomis Beach (2 miles) and Venice Beach (3 miles). Spend your days fishing from the private dock, paddling one of 4 kayaks, or biking the Legacy Trail with 3 bikes. Evenings are for the firepit, grilling on the charcoal BBQ, or cornhole under the stars. We’ve stocked shark tooth gear, beach essentials, toiletries, coffee, tea, olive oil, spices, and a welcome bottle of wine — so you can arrive, unpack, and relax.

Top guest favorite
An aerial view captures the tranquil surroundings of the property, showcasing nearby waterways and the serene setting of the neighborhood. The proximity to Nokomis Beach is highlighted, with lush greenery and homes present, creating a peaceful coastal atmosphere.
Home in Nokomis
5 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

Walking distance to Nokomis Beach!

Welcome to our Brisa Marina Bungalow! Nestled on a quiet street within walking distance from pristine shoreline of Casey Key, our tropical home is the perfect getaway for those seeking a cozy, relaxed atmosphere. 🔘 2 Min Drive to Nokomis Beach 🔘 3 Min Drive to Publix Groceries 🔘 10 Min Drive to Venice Pier 🔘 20 Min Drive to Siesta Beach 🔘 25 Min Drive to Myakka River State Park 🔘 30 Min Drive to Sarasota Airport Unwind in our bungalow & create lasting memories with your loved ones.

Guest favorite
Home in Nokomis
5 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Coastal Haven 3BR/2BA Beach Home

Experience the perfect beach getaway at our newly renovated 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom vacation rental. Just minutes from the sandy shores, this charming home offers the ideal blend of relaxation and convenience. Unwind in your private backyard oasis, featuring a sparkling pool—perfect for cooling off on warm days. Located just a short drive from the beach, Coastal Haven combines modern comforts with the charm of coastal living. Book your stay today and make unforgettable memories by the sea!

Guest favorite
A screened-in patio is featured with comfortable seating made of woven material. A low table sits in the center with decorative items. The backdrop includes soft purple hues from the sunset and surrounded by tropical plants, offering a serene outdoor setting.
Home in Nokomis
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 67 reviews

Summer sunset. 3 minutes away from beach!

Welcome to your Summer Sunset Beach Retreat! It's a new property, just listed! Just a 3-minute drive to Nokomis Public, and very close to Shark Tooth Beach where to gather some shark tooths. Waterfront restaurants are just minutes away and Casey Key Gulf Club is too. The house offers the perfect blend of modern comfort. Fully equipped kitchen, Comfortable couches and beds. The clean, light, and airy atmosphere inside and beautiful surroundings outside make this stay perfect!

Guest favorite
A heated pool is surrounded by lush tropical plants and palm trees, offering a relaxing atmosphere. Adjacent to the pool, a tiki bar provides seating for several guests, complemented by a flat surface for refreshments. The area is enhanced by a well-maintained garden visible beyond the pool.
Home in Nokomis
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

Tiki Oasis 3bed on .6 acre paradise 5 min to Beach

Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay. Enjoy 2 master suites with 3 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms. A 5 min drive to Nokomis beach or downtown Venice, and walking distance to legacy trail, tennis courts, and playground in Nokomis park. Fast 500GB up/down internet speed around the property, Tiki bar nestled next to a heated pool and spa ( adtnl charge for spa). Fully stocked kitchen, beach-ready with cooler chairs umbrella wagon, and toys. 4 smart tvs

Top guest favorite
Home in Nokomis
5 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

Nokomis Waterfront Unit Walk to the Beach & Dining

Relax in this freshly renovated 2-bedroom, 2-bath canal-front retreat just a 10-minute walk to Nokomis Beach! Enjoy peaceful mornings on the deck, paddle out with the included kayaks, or stroll to local favorites like waterfront restaurants and ice cream shops. With modern comforts, a fully stocked kitchen, plush king + queen beds, and thoughtful amenities throughout, this is your perfect home base for a family getaway, snowbird stay, or beachside couple’s escape.

Top guest favorite
Home in Nokomis
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 117 reviews

Charming vacation home, short walk to the beach

Welcome to our charming vacation home! Just a 10-min walk to beautiful Nokomis Beach and a short drive to Siesta Key, Downtown Venice, and all the area’s attractions. Inside, the home is bright, spotless, and fully stocked with essentials. Two spacious bedrooms, each with a walk-in closet and private bath for your comfort and privacy. Enjoy the patio, grill, and peaceful neighborhood. We are looking forward to hosting you!

Top guest favorite
A private heated pool is surrounded by lush palm trees and a well-maintained lawn. An outdoor dining area with a large umbrella is visible, along with two lounge chairs positioned near the pool. The area is brightened by clear blue skies and sunlight.
Home in Siesta Key
5 out of 5 average rating, 158 reviews

Beach, Village, Dock & Private Pool! One-of-a-kind

Rad’s Cozy Cottage – Siesta Key Private Home. Enjoy a heated saltwater pool, canal-front dock, and putting green at this one-of-a-kind tropical getaway. Steps from Siesta Village (shops, restaurants, nightlife) and the powdery-white sands of Siesta Key Beach. Fully updated 2BR/1.5BA cottage with modern kitchen, AC, Wi-Fi, and washer/dryer. Sleeps 6 (king + 2 twins + sofa). Book your island paradise!

Top guest favorite
Home in Sarasota
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 106 reviews

Your DreamOasisAwaits: SiestaKeyEscape with Pool!

Welcome to your dream oasis near the world-famous Siesta Key! ✨ This immaculate 2BD/2BA home is a true coastal gem, offering a serene retreat with stylish design and luxurious amenities. Just 1 mile from the sugar-white sands of Siesta Key Beach, this home provides the perfect blend of comfort and convenience—an ideal spot to embrace relaxed Florida living at its finest. 🌴

Top guest favorite
A single-story house is presented with a light-colored exterior and a gently sloping roof. Lush greenery surrounds the property, including palm trees and ornamental shrubbery. A paved driveway leads to a two-car garage, while a clear blue sky completes the inviting exterior view.
Home in Nokomis
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 109 reviews

Peaceful Getaway just minutes from the beach

Beautiful, bright, freshly decorated 3 bedroom house just 2 miles from Gulf Coast beaches. When not at the beach, relax out at the lanai with a saltwater pool (heated November-March) and hot tub in our private backyard.

Popular amenities for Casey Key house rentals

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Florida
  4. Sarasota County
  5. Casey Key
  6. House rentals