Vacation rentals in Casey Key, Florida

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Casey Key, Florida

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

A curved swimming pool is set against a backdrop of lush tropical foliage and palm trees, with water views extending to a nearby dock. Brightly colored pots with plants are placed around the pool area, enhancing the serene outdoor setting.

Home in Sarasota

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 71 reviews

True Island Living House/beach/water views

Charming Bayfront Home in heart of Siesta Key. 3 bdrm/3.5 bath, full water views, spectacular sun rises, private, gas heated pool, boat dock/ lift, outdoor sitting area /lush tropical landscape. Open floor plan, contemporary decor, gas fireplace, hardwood floors throughout, updated kitchen, stainless steel appliances, granite counters and a full walk-in pantry. 2 Master Suites upstairs and one guest bdrm on main floor. Washer and dryer inside, 3 TV’s. Outdoor shower. Fishing. Parking for 2 cars.

Top guest favorite

The exterior of the property features palm trees and well-maintained landscaping, creating a welcoming atmosphere. A light-colored house is shown with a spacious driveway and a covered porch area, indicating a tropical setting. A clear blue sky is visible above, enhancing the bright scene.

Bungalow in Nokomis

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 70 reviews

Beach Cottage. 2 Blocks to Nokomis Beach. 2BD/1BA

Prepare to be amazed by Poco Tortuga, the ultimate destination for relaxation and exploration! Nestled just a short stroll away from the stunning Nokomis beach, this hidden gem offers you the perfect getaway to unwind and indulge in a truly fulfilling vacation experience. Immerse yourself in the lifestyle of Florida living. Whether you're seeking solace by lounging beach side, embarking on thrilling adventures, or simply basking in the beauty of nature, this remarkable escape has got you covered

Guest favorite

An outdoor seating area is presented with dark wicker furniture, blue cushions, and an orange throw draped over the arm. A table sits in the center, with manicured grass and a view of the waterfront in the background, framed by a decorative gazebo.

Home in Venice

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 148 reviews

MCM Waterfront Retreat • Dock, Kayaks & Beaches

Welcome to our Mid-Century Modern waterfront escape on Curry Creek, minutes from Nokomis Beach (2 miles) and Venice Beach (3 miles). Spend your days fishing from the private dock, paddling one of 4 kayaks, or biking the Legacy Trail with 6 bikes. Evenings are for the firepit, grilling on the charcoal BBQ, or cornhole under the stars. We’ve stocked shark tooth gear, beach essentials, toiletries, coffee, tea, olive oil, spices, and a welcome bottle of wine — so you can arrive, unpack, and relax.

Guest favorite

Lounge chairs with decorative blue cushions are arranged on a patio, overlooking a serene body of water. A lush green lawn extends in front of the water, and the sky is tinted with soft hues of orange and pink from the setting sun.

Home in Sarasota

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 31 reviews

Right on the bay! Heated pool! King bed

Conveniently located near plenty of Sarasota's shopping and dining areas, your new home away from home is nice and isolated, surrounded by gorgeous views and just a quick walk from the waters of Sarasota Bay. You will have whole house except two rooms which will be locked and no one will be there. One bedroom with a king size bed and sleeping sofa in the family room (if more than two guests coming). Full size kitchen, two family rooms, pool and gorgeous view on the salty bay for nature lovers.

Top guest favorite

A serene view showcases a manicured lawn leading to a calm lake, bordered by palms and grasses. The bright blue sky reflects softly on the water's surface, creating a peaceful outdoor ambiance.

Home in Nokomis

5 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

Lake View, 6 Miles From Beach

-Located inToscana Isles (gated community with heated infinity pool, gym, tennis/pickleball/bocce ball courts, playground, dog park, billiard room, and monthly events) -Backs up to 1 of 3 lakes (kayaking and fishing allowed, 2 kayaks, 2 fishing poles and tackle box included) -6 Miles from Nokomis Beach, 6.8 miles to Venice and dog beach, the only pet friendly beach in the area (4 beach chairs, umbrella, cooler, wagon and beach bags included) -Close to Legacy Trail and Oscar Scherer State Park

Guest favorite

A spacious waterfront home is surrounded by green landscaping, palm trees, and open blue skies. A large heated pool is visible in the backyard, adjacent to a well-maintained deck. Comfortable seating is positioned on the sandy area by the water, providing a relaxing atmosphere.

Villa in Osprey

5 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Paradise with a pool, pier and private beach area

Intercoastal, Blackburn Bay waterfront home with boating facilities near Casey Key and Siesta Key. On a point facing the setting sun. This is simply paradise. The pier is long, and the water deep enough to handle most boat docking needs. The large, heated pool is a few steps from the screened lanai and the deck beckons "come watch the sunset". And while it won't replace one of the large beaches on the key, you can lay or play on our beach hidden by mangroves, and easily launch kayaks, etc.

Guest favorite

A bright dining area features a round table surrounded by three colorful chairs in pink and blue. A decorative chandelier hangs above, and soft natural light enters through the large sliding door, showcasing views of the tropical surroundings and bay.

Condo in Nokomis

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 73 reviews

Casey Key cottage-steps from private beach.

PRIVATE BEACH AND STAND ALONE COTTAGE. Remodeled, spacious, detached bay front one bedroom private extra clean, well maintained cottage located on Casey Key just steps from our private beach. King sized bed & TV in bedroom. Full kitchen & dining area. Large walk-in shower. Queen sized pull out sofa sleeper for additional sleeping space. Enjoy the tropical backyard overlooking the bay & boat docks or enjoy tropical breezes on your attached private porch. Ask for beach chairs/grill

Superhost

Home in Nokomis

5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Waterfront Home, Walk to the Beach & Dining

Relax in this freshly renovated 2-bedroom, 2-bath canal-front retreat just a 10-minute walk to Nokomis Beach! Enjoy peaceful mornings on the deck, paddle out with the included kayaks, or stroll to local favorites like waterfront restaurants and ice cream shops. With modern comforts, a fully stocked kitchen, plush king + queen beds, and thoughtful amenities throughout, this is your perfect home base for a family getaway, snowbird stay, or beachside couple’s escape.

Top guest favorite

The lanai features a comfortable seating area with woven chairs surrounding a central table. Natural light fills the space, highlighting the outdoor view through large screens. A patterned rug adds texture, while a dining set is visible in the background against a white fence.

Home in Nokomis

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 46 reviews

Coastal Charm Retreat. 3 min away from the beach!

Welcome to your Sunset Beach Retreat, just a 3-minute drive from the Nokomis Public, don't forget to visit Shark Tooth Beach to collect some tooths, and water-front resteraunts. The Casey Key Gulf Club is not too far too. Lots of paths for exercising too. This idyllic seaside escape offers the perfect blend of modern comfort and beachfront bliss, ensuring an unforgettable getaway. This home is new in the market. It is designed for any vacation.

Guest favorite

A beachfront property is depicted, featuring a two-story structure with a spacious porch. Surrounding landscape includes sand and lush greenery, leading to the waves of the Gulf of Mexico. Sunbathers are seen in the distance, enjoying the beach atmosphere.

Condo in Englewood

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 198 reviews

Manasota Key

Direct Ocean Front Unit. Imagine having a glass of wine at sunset overlooking world class views of the Gulf of Mexico. Steps to the beach and unsurpassed views. Excellent restaurants and Tiki Bars within walking distance. This unit is a 1 bedroom 1 bath spacious unit that can comfortably sleep 4. It includes a King bed & Full size sleeper sofa. It also has a beautiful kitchen with granite countertops and tile floors throughout. No Pets.

Top guest favorite

A row of brightly colored Adirondack chairs is positioned on the sandy beach, facing the tranquil ocean. The hues include yellow, orange, green, blue, pink, and purple. A clear blue sky with soft clouds complements the serene shoreline.

Cottage in Nokomis

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 162 reviews

Staycation Sanctuary

Our property is clean and welcoming. You can enjoy a relaxing, warm and peaceful getaway from the rest of the world just steps to the beach. This is the perfect "Old Florida-style" location to experience the comfort and hospitality you so deserve! Grab your bathing suit/flip flops and enjoy tranquillity of beach life, sunsets and lazy days of fishing and bird/dolphin/manatee watching and gathering sea shells-- all only 2 blocks away!

Guest favorite

A stunning pool area is surrounded by lush greenery and tropical plants. A prominent rock feature with multiple waterfalls is visible, providing a serene focal point in the outdoor space. The vibrant blue water complements the natural elements, creating a tranquil retreat.

Island in Sarasota

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 332 reviews

NEW 4/NTS AUG OPEN! Sarasota #1 Lux BEACH Villa

BOOK 2025 NOW, and stay in Style magazines exclusive beachfront gem! This property OWNS THE BEACH!! UNIQUE PRIVATE POOL & BEACH combo is HEAVEN! Private ELEVATOR! 32,000/gl FREEFORM POOL, with 4 WATERFALLS, HOT GROTTO with HOT falls! NEW BBQ PIT AREA, BIKES, KAYAKS, and PADDLEBOARDS! WRAPAROUND BALCONY, CHEF kitchen. Hosted CELEBS! SHOPPING, FINE DINING, watch our VIDEOS!