Vacation rentals with a fire pit in Baileys Harbor

Very cozy with all the amenities and a beautiful view of the bay to go with. Would stay here again!

This was the cutest place for my family. It was super private and my daughter loved to play in the loft area! The games were definitely a hit! We had a little hiccup during check in when the cleaning service was running behind. But Michelle was very accommodating for the hiccup and fast to respond. Other than that, we had a great time and loved everything about the house. From the inside cozy decor, to the trails outside, we would definitely stay here again!

This was our first family vacation since having our little one and this place made it easy for us to keep their routine pretty much the same with the second bedroom. It was close to everything and we were easily able to pop back to the cabin if we forgot something or needed something! We will for sure be trying to book this place again when we come back to Door County!

Our stay at the Alma cottage was even better than we expected! The minimal yet thoughtful design boasted large windows that really let the surrounding landscape in allowing for a peaceful ambiance throughout the cabin. The beds were comfortable and we felt at home. Everything was wonderful. We will be back!

We loved the waterfront location and had been trying to get a stay here for a while. The cottage was comfortable, cheery, and had a nice kitchen setup. It was in a great location, easily walkable to downtown for the farmer’s market or to the beach. The garden and outdoor living space was spectacular as well and we spent time reading and eating on the deck, along with visits from the resident dog Sara. Alisa is a personable hostess and this is a great place to stay. We love Sturgeon Bay and the accommodations made it a great weekend getaway.

We had a great cozy stay at Jan’s. We were in Door County for a bachelorette weekend. Close to all things fun, but on the quiet side of the peninsula. Would love to visit again.

Upscale accommodations with many amenities and lovely decor. We enjoyed spending time in the beautiful sunroom. Our dog was safe and happy in her very own fenced-in yard. Our hosts were so thoughtful, and anything we might need was available. We were able to reach out with questions and recommendations as needed. It was a wonderful weekend!

Nice home in the middle of Door County. We loved being able to easily get to many locations in Door County and then come home and grill out or have a campfire and s'mores. Home was clean with lots of bathrooms just as listed. Lots of history and a beautiful farm home. Daniel and Amy were great hosts.

Had a great time at this cute studio apartment. Everything you need for a short vacation. Minutes away from great restaurants and close to scenic locations. The best part is the view from the studio and the pier/beachfront. Good recommendations from host! A must stay!

Kathleen was a terrific host who provided many touches to make our stay comfortable. Coffee, tea, movies, kitchenette all made our stay very pleasant. We especially like how close we were to our favorite Egg Harbor restaurants and shopping. Thank you for such a clean and thoughtfully appointed room for our getaway!

Really enjoyed the accommodations. The location was close to Green Bay n the price was very reasonable. Loved the quiet, peacefulness river view. Everything was neat n tidy n the antique decor was a huge hit. Cindy was very flexible n helpful. Was a great weekend.

We loved the apartment. It was very cute and well maintained. Pet friendly, and very accommodating. There isn't a pizza cutter, but we have yet to stay at an Air BNB that has one. Lol! Overall, it was lovely and will stay again when we come back.

Robert’s place was just as described! Very spacious, clean, and conveniently located. Communication was great, thank you Robert!

Logan’s place is a lovely comfortable house with all basic needs catered for a getaway to Door County & surrounding places. Everything was perfectly in order and we thoroughly enjoyed our stay. The collection of books for guests was amazing and people can read to their children as well. I give this place 5 stars

This was a great place to stay for my trip to Door County! The apartment was super clean and decorated so nicely. The apartment is located in a nice quite neighborhood and other guests on the property were quiet and lovely. I'd absolutely stay here again!!

Loved it! A beautiful place on a quiet wooded lot. Only heard the frogs. We were pleased to explore an area of Door County that I was unfamiliar with. And we hit it perfect. Yellow lady slippers galore at Ellison Bay Bluff park. House decorated very nicely. Comfy furniture. Even has a back deck to enjoy your morning coffee. Would love to return someday.

Loved staying here! Super conveniently located and close to all the fun in sister bay. Felt private enough and the house was in great condition. We didn’t have one single issue- would totally rent again!

Our stay was phenomenal, the place was very clean and the king bed was probably the most comfortable bed I’ve ever slept in. Would definitely book again!

This home was in a great location with a beautiful view. we enjoyed our stay in Oconto while we were fishing. Great place to relax

The cabin itself was clean, quiet and an amazing place for nature lovers. The trail on the farm itself is peaceful, and the nearby Algoma beachfront and Kewaunee nature trail are beautiful as well with a nice variety of wildlife, birds and plants. Highly recommended and will definitely come back again when we are in the area.

This cabin is absolutely cute and cozy. The fireplace was perfect and there was plenty of firewood on site to purchase. A nice getaway for me and my dogs!!

Great cozy springtime stay. It was nice to use the wood burning stove and hang out in the large common area.

Not only was the cabin clean with friendly hosts, the decor really enhanced the “Up North” feeling with retro vibes. Whether relaxing by the fire, listening to some vinyl we picked up at an antique store on the turntable at the cabin, walking down the street to listen to the waves or checking out great restaurants nearby, the hosts helped share their favorite places and this beautiful space. It was a memorable stay and property!

Amazing place -- the island and bay are beautiful, the cabin is cozy and has everything you need for a weekend (or more) of relaxation & fun. Hosts are friendly & responsive. We had a wonderful time, hope to return again in the future.