Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Theater District, Manhattan

Highly recommend staying here if you’re wanting to stay outside of New York. Couple minute walk to train, an actual driveway to park in, and a nice neighborhood. We would stay here again!

Staying at Mark’s historical cabin was a true privilege. The charm and character of the place made it a unique experience, and the fact that it’s just 20 minutes from Manhattan made it even more special. Everything was exactly as shown in the pictures — cozy, clean, and full of character. We absolutely loved our stay and would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a peaceful retreat close to the city!

Heba was a great host with a beautiful home. Very clean, welcoming, and spacious. Bonus- All the tile selections were gorgeous! Our families fit comfortably in the home during our stay and we enjoyed our time.

Really beautiful house and neighborhood. Perfect for our visit to family in Millburn. We are already talking about coming back! Thank you Emily for your hospitality!

The place is great! Everything is new and fancy. Highly recommended to everyone.

This home is beautiful. The only set back is parking is only available on one side of the street so there is limited parking for this home.

Nalini is a wonderful host and the home is just as described. Very clean and well stocked. Great value and I enjoyed my time there. Thank you very much!

This place was amazing and everything I wanted! I stayed here with my groomsmen before my wedding in New York. Very nice neighborhood and great home type feeling inside. Me and my groomsmen with their significant others were thoroughly blessed to be able to stay here. Joanne was a fantastic host with all the recommendations and quick responses to any questions I had!

Once again I love it it is so comfortable I feel like I'm at home when I'm there I finally learned how to you the fireplace 😂😭

If I could give 11/10 I would! Sal was simply the best host you could ask for! Incredibly responsive, full of great advice and very hospitable. We couldn’t have asked for a better experience. Thanks so much Sal. If we are ever blessed enough to return, we will be back!

Wonderful apartment in a warm neighbourhood and very convenient location, easy walk to the Path or Ferry to NYC. A couple great playgrounds nearby. Apartment thoughtfully appointed and was nice to have some outdoor space. Emily was a great host and appreciate her prompt replies and flexibility (where it was possible).

Maggy was very proactive and responsive. The house was very clean and spacious. I would absolutely visit again if I was in the area.

We had a peaceful garden apartment stay at Margo and Vipin’s. 2 very comfortable bedrooms and a beautiful outdoor garden area. Private, secure, and spotless! Felt like home with lots of blankets and towels. Walkable to transportation, restaurants, and shopping, while situated on a quiet, family-friendly street. Kindly, they were flexible with the checkin and checkout we needed. Sparkling bathroom!

This place came with a lot of charm! Everything was as advertised, and Greg was gracious enough to allow us to check-in early. There was plenty of space for our group of 3 that we didn't feel like we were on top of each other during our stay. Last but not least, the value of this place was pretty great!

Nice and clean.. would recommend

Very nice accommodation. It takes a good half hour by bus to get to Port Authority terminal. Very clean, clear instructions for check-in even late. Several buses take you to Manhattan, a 7-minute walk away. Cecia explains how to take them. Bonus: a basketball court right next door for kids to let off steam in the evening when they get home if they have any energy left!

A beautiful home with a gracious host. Linyan was available at short notice, and provided us with a very hospitable experience

Thank you for another wonderful stay!

We're so happy to stay at Ying's place. It's way more beautiful and cozier than what the pictures show. Everything is new/remodeled and clean. It takes just a couple minutes to walk to the bus stop near the traffic light to NYC. Parking can be tricky but Ying's clear instructions make us at ease. Overall I'd highly recommend this place for family trip.

Alice did a great job making us feel comfortable. The home has a wonderful view of the NY skyline and the accommodations were impeccable.