Vacation rentals in Tappan Lake

Had a great stay for the week. House was very clean and comfortable. Plenty of cooking pots ,pans and etc. We enjoyed the cookies waiting for us. Freida was very responsive about booking and how to get in upon arrival. Will definitely book again.

Beautiful home in a peaceful area. Kitchen had tons of kitchen gadgets and tools to use. Our family kept on mentioning how this maybe the nicest Airbnb that we have every stayed in. (And we have been in 10+) Lindsay was responsive and helpful. We had a great time and felt right at home :)

Marissa's cabin was exactly as promised! This was are 4th year of coming to Leesville Lake to fish. The fishing this year was not the best and I'm pretty sure the drought is over, can't control the weather. Staying at the cabin was a total pleasure, the enclosed porch area is very comfortable and a great place to spend a rainy day! We were able to enjoy a outside fire on our first night, and totally enjoy the night time calming sounds of the lake, the owl every evening was a plus. When we were unable to spend our evening outside around the fire ring the fireplace in the living room was a great replacement, there is nothing like a fire and watching a movie to relax. It was very nice not having TV and all the political commercials. If you are looking for a beautiful place to get away and relax this is the place.

Fantastic place to stay! Cristina’s clear instructions and warm, friendly messages made the space feel incredibly welcoming and homey. The living room was much more spacious than I had expected, adding to the overall comfort. I absolutely loved my stay and will definitely be returning!

We had a lovely overnight stay! Everything was exactly as pictured. We had everything we needed to cook a delicious meal using the pots/pans/utensils provided in the kitchen. The extra snacks were a nice touch (we couldn’t resist trying the popcorn) and the stock of coffee/creamer was a huge plus since we forgot to bring our own for the morning. We greatly enjoyed the peaceful surroundings from the back patio and hot tub. Thank you for sharing your beautiful space!

We had an amazing time at the lighthouse! So much to do just on site alone. We wouldn’t even have had to leave to have an incredible time, but we did try out some of the host recommendations for dining and shopping.

We had the best time at the cozy cabin! It’s super cute, almost like a hidden gem! And they also had firewood setting and waiting for us which was a perfect touch! Thanks for letting us stay!!!!

Everything was well accommodating, and we loved the house!!

Jennifer was an amazing host! She put us in touch with her friend and we went to the friend's restaurant and had such a great time. (All the food in that area is incredible, but be sure to bring your own insulin drip). The apartment was so cozy and cute, we found ourselves repeatedly glued to the sofa. Jennifer left us a welcome basket of goodies and detailed instructions on how to find things and where to go. We also met her cleaner/assistant, also named Jennifer, who educated us on the Amish and the area. Everyone we met was so nice. The apartment was really perfect and I kept telling my traveling companions, I need a place like this to move into when I sell my house! Only it needs to be in NJ . . . Highly recommend. Jennifer if you find yourself in NJ please call me!!