Vacation rentals in Sugar Creek

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Sugar Creek

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favorite

Home in Indianapolis

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 247 reviews

#IndyCozyCottage | Historic Cottage Near Downtown

Hello, Fellow Traveler! Welcome to our cozy historic Indy cottage in a quiet neighborhood retreat just minutes from downtown. Enjoy coffee on the porch, a fenced yard for pets, and easy access to Mass Ave, Bottleworks, and Lucas Oil Stadium. Thoughtfully updated for comfort and style while keeping its original charm! This quaint home features a king bedroom with walk-in closet, updated and stocked kitchen, secondary flex bedroom/office, and two-car garage. Perfect for your next Indy adventure!

LocationValueQuiet

Top guest favorite

A two-story building is positioned amidst a grassy yard, featuring a staircase leading to a spacious second story deck. Lush greenery surrounds the premises, while a few trees stand nearby, contributing to the tranquil rural setting.

Apartment in Fairland

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 170 reviews

The Nigh Place, Studio Apartment, King Bed, 55"TV

Welcome! Enjoy the country views from your exclusive second story deck or relax inside of your isolated, spacious, and peaceful studio apartment. Complete with a King size bed, loveseat, recliner, 55” TV, full kitchenette, walk in closet and private bathroom. Updated, clean, and secure. Arriving late? Solar and motion detector lights along with a lighted electronic key pad for ease of access. Please note there are 23 steps with rails on both sides and a landing area half way to the apartment.

ValueFamilyWifi

Top guest favorite

The exterior of the house features a combination of white brick and dark trim, with large windows that allow natural light to enter. A well-maintained front yard is visible, highlighted by green grass and lush landscaping, providing a welcoming atmosphere.

Home in Greenfield

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 143 reviews

The Rosie Roots - Cozy House & Pet Friendly

Welcome to our cozy & pet friendly 3 bedroom 1 bathroom house located in the heart of Greenfield, within 5 min to local shops & dinning and I-70. Downtown Indianapolis is a short 25-minute drive away, you'll have easy access to all the city's top attractions, including the Gainbridge Fieldhouse, Lucas Oil Stadium and many more. Our home is the perfect choice for guests who want to be close to all the action of the city while still enjoying the comfort and convenience of a charming small town.

ValueFamilyCondition

Guest favorite

A spacious guest suite is illuminated by natural light from large windows. A cozy seating area is visible beside a desk and a wall-mounted television. Attractive bedding with striped patterns adorns a sizable bed, complemented by a plush carpet and tasteful decor.

Guest suite in Greenfield

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 112 reviews

Peaceful & Luxurious Suite

Our guest suite is close to Indpls--approx. 20 min from downtown. You’ll love our place because of the quiet & serene environment that's just outside of the city. We sit on an acreage close to the I70/Mt Comfort Road Exit making for quick access to and from the interstate. Our suite is in the front corner of our home. It has a private entrance with porch. It looks out into a garden that has a pond with fountain along with seating under a pergola. It has high ceilings and is very spacious.

LocationValueKitchen

Top guest favorite

A spacious bed is adorned with a patterned duvet and two decorative pillows. The headboard is neutral gray, and a piece of wall art is showcased above. A wooden bookshelf with decorative items is visible in the background, along with a bedside lamp.

Guest suite in Greenfield

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 169 reviews

Greenfield Garden Cottage-minutes from Indy

We are excited to offer our 3rd Airbnb listing, available now! You can check out our two other listings, Greenfield German Cottage and Greenfield Country Cottage. We have several years experience hosting through Airbnb and hundreds of happy guests. Our Garden Cottage offers plenty of space for 2 people to rest and relax. We offer a king size bed, large sitting area with tv, fridge and microwave. The grounds has gardens, water fountains, gazebo and wedding chapel for you to enjoy.

LocationValueCheckout

Top guest favorite

An expansive yard is featured, bordered by mature trees and lush grass. A concrete driveway leads to the charming bungalow-style suite on the right, showcasing a well-maintained exterior with traditional features. A neighboring structure and a natural landscape complete the tranquil country setting.

Guest suite in Indianapolis

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 182 reviews

THE CUMBERLAND/Indianapolis, Indiana

"Country Living with City Convenience" 15 minutes from the town of Greenfield 15 minutes from The Academy Volleyball Club 23 minutes from Gainbridge Fieldhouse / Lucas Oil Stadium / Convention Center 25 minutes from downtown Indianapolis 28 minutes from Ruoff Music Center 29 minutes from Indianapolis Motor Speedway 30 minutes from Clowes Memorial Hall (Butler University) 31 minutes from Indianapolis International Airport 35 minutes from Grand Park Sports Campus

ValueFamilyGetting around

Superhost

A small green house stands among trees, featuring a wooden deck at the entrance. Two white chairs are situated on the patio, and the structure has multiple windows that allow natural light to fill the interior.

Tiny home in Indianapolis

4.84 out of 5 average rating, 182 reviews

Cozy Tiny House Nestled in the Trees

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. In a charming tiny house surrounded by trees and birdsong, you can unplug and relax without going too far off the beaten path. Only a 15 minute drive from downtown, we’re conveniently located between Fountain Square, Irvington, Beech Grove, and Wanamaker. Curl up with a cup of tea and a good book, sit on the patio and watch for deer, or take a walk around our fledgling 9-acre permaculture farm.

FamilyValueLayout

Top guest favorite

An open-concept living space features a large, grey sectional sofa with a vibrant orange throw pillow. A rustic coffee table sits in front, and the kitchen area includes modern appliances. A dining table, barstools, and two desks provide ample space for activities, complemented by natural lighting from multiple windows.

Guest suite in Indianapolis

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 792 reviews

La Cochera Indy East - No Cleaning Fee!

Contemporary, clean carriage house on a large East Indianapolis property. Private keypad entrance with easy self check-in and on-site parking for up to two cars. Comfortably sleeps the whole family with a king bed and a stylish queen-size sofa bed. Important details: • No parties or events • Local guests require prior approval • Early check-in available for $35 (when possible) • $20–$40 linen fee for use of sofa bed

FamilyLocationCheck-in

Top guest favorite

A modern living area is highlighted by a comfortable sectional sofa adorned with decorative pillows. A pair of armchairs and a wooden coffee table create a cozy seating arrangement. Natural light filters in through the window, complemented by a stylish lamp and wall art.

Home in Indianapolis

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 213 reviews

Private, one car garage, hot coffee

Welcome to Robin's Nest, my cozy, modern, open-concept home in Indy! This inviting space includes 2 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and 2 queen beds. Enjoy amenities such as a coffee bar, fire pit, and workstation. Let your fur babies run free in my fully fenced-in yard. You’re in close proximity to Lucas Oil, the Convention Center, and Gainbridge Fieldhouse, Murat, and many major hospitals are in a 10 mile radius.

ValueLocationAir conditioning

Top guest favorite

A cozy living area features patterned chairs and a wooden coffee table, surrounded by wall art and greenery. A smart TV is mounted on one wall, and a small desk provides a workspace. Natural light enhances the warmth of the space.

Home in Indianapolis

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 355 reviews

Cobb Cabin

Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. Quiet and relaxing 1 bedroom studio home with king bed. Only 18 minutes from downtown. Couch pulls out for added comfort, leg room and sleeping area. There is a fold out single cot and a fold out queen mattress available. Full kitchen, smart tv, washer/dryer, private security system and all the basics are all with this secluded home.

FamilyValueAir conditioning

Top guest favorite

A comfortable living area features two gray sofas adorned with decorative pillows, situated on a textured area rug. Natural light enters through two windows, illuminating a wooden coffee table at the center. A ceiling fan adds a rustic touch to the space.

Farm stay in Indianapolis

5 out of 5 average rating, 173 reviews

Historic Meadowdale Farm

Relax at this peaceful historic farm stay! Located in our pole barn built in 2023, this private unit sleeps 4 (1 bed/1 bath) just 15–20 mins from city life and shopping. Step into your dog-friendly, 1/4-acre fenced yard featuring a covered outdoor dining area, porch swing, and a cozy firepit for evenings under the stars. The perfect rural retreat with plenty of room to unwind!

LocationFamilySleep quality

Top guest favorite

A vibrant landing area features floral wallpaper and a cozy seating arrangement. A unique table with sculpted legs sits against the wall, framed by decorative art. Natural light enters through a doorway leading to a bedroom, while designer lighting adds character to the space.

Home in Irvington

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 112 reviews

The Prescott- Historic Glamour. Bold Luxury

Welcome to the Prescott. A bold, exciting & fierce luxury rental in the heart of beautiful historic downtown Irvington. 5 miles from downtown Indianapolis. Enjoy this historic home built in 1908; reimagined & curated in 2024. Experience an upscale stay with modern comfort & historic elements where BOLD is always at the forefront.

ValueLocationParking