Monthly Rentals in Simm's Settlement

It was the first time my family and I visited Long Island. We met Docky and Jill and they made us feel at home from the very beginning. Starting from the simplest details of providing, coffee, tea, bug spray, baby oil for mosquitoes to the more complex like taking time out to direct us everywhere on the entire island. The home is equipped with all of the basics even some cooking seasonings. The yard is big and has a beautiful huge tamarind trees. a nice gazebo, grill and the house hilltop view was spectacular. We had true privacy and the neighbors were quiet and kept to themselves. We never saw them..You definitely will need a car to get around especially to restaurants and grocery shopping. It’s located to the very northern tip of the island. The busiest settlement is 45 minutes to the south. We will be back again and will be delighted to book with Bonafide fishing house again. We didn’t do any fishing with Docky because of the rain. We came as visitors and left feeling like locals.

I had a few issues with the TV, but outside of that, everything was great. The apartment was as described. I’ll be back.

We wanted a quiet, peaceful place on the water. That's exactly what we got. Beautiful sunsets every evening, no neighbors except our hosts who are wonderful - generous, peaceful, interesting. This was the best AirBnB we have experienced. Highly recommended.

We had an absolutely amazing time at Tiny’s and would highly, highly recommend it to anyone visiting Long Island. The location is breathtaking and the cottage itself is beautiful. Michelle was a phenomenal host - her communication was quick and helpful, and all of her local recommendations made our stay even more special. From secluded beaches to great spots to eat, everything she suggested was spot on. We genuinely didn’t want to leave and would come back in a heartbeat. Thank you for such a memorable stay! We hope to be back soon!