Vacation rentals in Shumway

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Shumway

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

A welcoming living area features a comfortable sofa and armchair, paired with a decorative area rug. A flat-screen TV is mounted near a stone fireplace, surrounded by natural light from the windows. Indoor plants add a touch of greenery to the space.

Cottage in Effingham

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 517 reviews

Centrally located, Peaceful Cabin by the Beach

TomRating, 5 starstoday

We have stayed at Kristen's place multiple times now with our pets and it is our go to in the area. Waterfront cottage with an up north feel, close to shopping, restaurants and easy access to the highway. We will definitely be back again and recommend it to anyone looking for a nice getaway or even a quick overnight stay when passing through the area.

Guest favorite

A wooden deck extends over a serene pond, framed by greenery. Two black Adirondack chairs are positioned for relaxation, overlooking the water. The surrounding area is graced with a mix of trees and open space, under a bright blue sky dotted with clouds.

Home in Sullivan

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Lake Shelbyville-Lakeside Villas

MycaRating, 5 stars1 day ago

We had a relaxing time staying at this wonderful place for two nights. The house has plenty of space, was well-stocked and was quite peaceful. We particularly enjoyed having coffee and breakfast on the back deck, where it seems you’re the only people in the world. The basketball court, swings and lovely sitting area by the pond were also a huge bonus in this space. There were multiple MASSIVE catfish and cute little fishies to feed and watch, which made it that much more special. Thanks for a great wonderful getaway!

Top guest favorite

An outdoor patio area features a square fire table surrounded by four wooden chairs. Lush green grass stretches out beyond the patio, with trees and open fields visible in the background, creating a serene setting for relaxation.

Cottage in Sullivan

5 out of 5 average rating, 213 reviews

Lakewood Cottage #1 @ Lake Shelbyville

MeganRating, 5 stars2 days ago

My husband and I spent two nights in this cottage with two of our close friends. The location is fantastic, quiet, and very private … it is located only a couple minutes drive to the quaint town of Sullivan, but you would never know with how private as it feels ! Marissa was very helpful. Anytime I reached out, (which was several) her responses were quick and helpful every time. At one point we had a glitch with the dryer knob and she and her husband showed up promptly and took care of the problem. Everything went smoothly for the rest of the time we were there. The house is immaculate, and all of the thoughtful touches are spot on. We have stayed at several Airbnb‘s and I believe this is one of my favorites! The kitchen is very well stocked with high-quality items and we never needed anything that wasn’t available. We prepared three meals each day and had all th supplies we wouldhave used at home. It looks exactly like the pictures and everything was modern and in great condition.

Top guest favorite

Cabin in Mattoon

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 157 reviews

Cottage on Lake Paradise,

KatieRating, 5 stars2 weeks ago

An amazing retreat. The lake was so peaceful and beautiful. The home was extremely well stocked and very well cared for/clean. The hosted provided great pre-check in instructions and check out was a breeze. The location was secluded but less than a 30 minute drive from wineries and restaurants. Would absolutely stay again!!

Top guest favorite

A modern kitchen features a farmhouse-style sink with a sleek stainless steel finish, surrounded by white cabinetry and granite countertops. A compact turquoise toaster sits on the counter, and a large window provides natural light and a view of the outdoor space.

Home in Vandalia

5 out of 5 average rating, 140 reviews

Modern family friendly home in Historic Vandalia

AmberRating, 5 stars4 weeks ago

We had a wonderful stay at Mary’s place. Her home was exactly as described and pictured. She thoughtfully stocked it and made it feel like a pampered resort. My family couldn’t have been more comfortable or at home. Mary was awesome and her home beautiful. If we’re ever traveling through again - we’d stop and stay just for the enjoyment. Highly recommend!

Top guest favorite

Home in Shelbyville

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

The Hub- 4 min to lake ramp/boat parking/Hot Tub

JakeRating, 5 stars7 months ago

Great house with plenty of room for the whole group. Bathrooms and kitchen were very nice and there is plenty of room to hang out as a group both inside and out on the patio. Lots of parking. Renee was easy to get ahold of and check in/out was simple.

Guest favorite

A wooden cabinet houses a selection of spice containers. Visible are jars of ground cinnamon, organic poultry seasoning, garlic powder, paprika, and crushed red pepper. A small glass jar of white sugar completes the arrangement, providing essential cooking ingredients in an organized display.

Home in Arthur

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 255 reviews

Sojourners' Abode

EstherRating, 5 stars2 weeks ago

This place met our needs for a family get together in Arthur. The location was perfect for us and the host was responsive and easy to reach. The house is in a quiet neighborhood on a dead end street and we felt perfectly safe. The place is comfortable and the kitchen is well stocked with all the essentials. We wouldn’t hesitate to stay here again.

Vacation rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Hotels

Stylish accommodations and amenities

Unique stays

Spaces that are more than just a place to sleep

Homes

Comfortable places with all the essentials

Popular amenities for Shumway vacation rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Other great vacation rentals in Shumway

Top guest favorite

The cottage is surrounded by lush greenery, with a large tree providing shade. A well-maintained lawn features flower beds and a gravel path leading to the porch, enhancing the inviting outdoor space.

Home in Keyesport

5 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Vintage Lakeside Cottage in Keyesport

DaveRating, 5 stars1 week ago

The place was perfect for a long weekend visit with our granddaughter. The house was comfortable, well stocked with games and entertainment options. It had easy access to the local park and a short drive to numerous state and federal parks with miles of trails and lots of waterfront activities. Plenty of shopping and restaurant options just a short drive away.

Guest favorite

A historic brick building features classic architectural details, including large front windows and a decorative entrance. A wide concrete walkway with gradual steps leads to the door, while nearby trees provide shade. Streetlamps enhance the welcoming exterior along the sidewalk.

Loft in Moweaqua

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews

Hidden Gem

NicoleRating, 5 stars3 days ago

My stay here was great and it was just what I needed during my work contract. It’s in a quiet neighborhood which gave me an extra level of comfort. I felt right at home and the apartment looks just like the photos. The hosts were very responsive and made sure I was comfortable. Highly recommend!

Top guest favorite

The spacious living area features high, wooden ceilings and large windows that invite natural light. A cozy seating arrangement with a sectional sofa faces a decorative fireplace. An open kitchen layout is highlighted by a central island with bar stools, providing a welcoming space for gatherings.

Cabin in Casey

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

Cabin by the Creek‼️🏡🎣🦌

KeelyRating, 5 stars1 month ago

We had a lovely time at Brittany's place. The place was clean, comfortable, and supplied with thoughtful amenities. We really appreciated the attention to detail. We were committed to plans during the day but when we got back in the evenings, we enjoyed sitting on the porch looking out at the water and listening to the frogs. Private and quiet- love that you can't see neighbors and the nature trail out back is lovely for meandering around. Would definitely stay here again. Thanks Brittany!

Guest favorite

The cabin is set alongside a tranquil pond, surrounded by trees that reflect in the water. The exterior features a porch and is nestled within the forest, offering a serene view of the natural landscape.

Cabin in Strasburg

5 out of 5 average rating, 32 reviews

Rocky Springs Cabin: A Secluded Cabin On 40 Acres

AnnieRating, 5 stars1 month ago

We had a great stay! The place was clean and the surroundings were very peaceful. We enjoyed exploring the trails around the property. There was also easy access to trails on the adjacent park which were very private.

Top guest favorite

A modern kitchen is featured with white cabinetry and dark countertops. A refrigerator stands against one wall, while a stove is positioned nearby. Light gray walls are paired with laminate flooring. Large windows allow natural light to fill the space, enhancing its welcoming feel.

Home in Flora

5 out of 5 average rating, 28 reviews

Grandma’s House! Cute small home/quiet street.

MasonRating, 5 stars1 month ago

Thank you so much for everything! Amazing as always! Such a lovely home! Clean and comfortable. They really do think of everything to make your stay as easy as possible! Definitely will be back again!

Guest favorite

A stylish room features exposed brick walls, three full-length mirrors with black frames, and two elegant seating areas. A light-colored rug creates a soft contrast with the dark flooring. A kitchenette can be seen in the background, complemented by modern cabinetry.

Apartment in Greenup

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Village Vacation

RodneyRating, 5 stars2 weeks ago

We needed it just overnight traveling through. Nice and spacious. Our needs were taken care of! A quaint little place being a former store. But it was well fixed up and furnished.

Top guest favorite

A modern kitchen corner features a stainless steel refrigerator and a double sink beneath a window. White cabinets are displayed above and below the countertop, offering ample storage. Natural light fills the space, enhancing the clean and organized layout.

Apartment in Taylorville

5 out of 5 average rating, 47 reviews

Hideaway blocks from downtown.

JoanneRating, 5 stars2 months ago

Clean, quiet, comfy. Perfect location, easy safe parking. Wonderful stay while in town

Top guest favorite

A tranquil pond is showcased in front of a single-story inn, surrounded by mature trees. The calm water reflects the building and greenery, while a screened pavilion is visible nearby, providing a scenic outdoor space. Closer to the shore, a light gravel path lines the pond.

Vacation home in Lakewood

5 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Lake Shelbyville Pond Pavilion Inn - Sleeps 6

JordanRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago

Stayed here for a fishing trip and it was perfect-clean, comfortable, and in a great spot. The host was responsive and check-in was super easy. Would definitely stay again for another trip.

Show all

Vacation rentals in Shumway

Top-rated vacation rentals in Shumway

Vacation rentals for every style

Popular amenities for Shumway vacation rentals

Other great vacation rentals in Shumway

Destinations to explore