Sag Harbor vacation rentals

We had a wonderful stay at Peter's home. It was beautifully decorated, very comfortable and a quick drive to Springs. Access to the private clearwater beach was a plus! Thank you for sharing your beautiful home with us.

We absolutely loved our quick getaway from the city at Kate’s lovely home. It is hard to articulate in words just how beautiful of a home and location this was. It was truly magical. We were very comfortable as a family traveling with young children. Despite the weather being a bit chilly, we had a wonderful time soaking the views and discovering “treasures” by the water. We cannot wait to come back again soon.

My family had a wonderful time at Robert’s home. The house was clean and cozy and the view of the water was peaceful. He was super communicative and friendly and check in/out was a breeze. The house is in a great area and super close to East Hampton, Amagansett, and Montauk. Highly recommend!

“A Wonderful Stay!” I had such a pleasant experience at this Airbnb! The space was clean, cozy, and exactly as described. The host was incredibly welcoming and attentive, making sure I had everything I needed for a comfortable stay. The location was perfect—quiet and peaceful, yet close to everything I needed. I especially appreciated the thoughtful touches throughout the space, which made it feel like home. I wouldn’t hesitate to book again—highly recommend! Feel free to customize it with any specific details about your stay!

My group of 4 loved this house in EH Springs. We were out east for a long weekend for a wedding, 4 adults. The pool is huge, the backyard had plenty of room to spread out, and there were plenty of supplies for outside (cushions, towels, etc). The bedrooms were comfortable and spotless, as were the bathrooms and kitchen. Dariusz and Patricia left us a really nice welcome gift (wine, snacks, a cake!) and a handwritten card. We felt very welcome - every detail was thought of - the house was fully stocked with coffee, condiments, lots to get us started when we arrived. We agree with other reviewers - while the pictures here are accurate, they don't do the house justice!! I really hope to come back :)

Lisa's apartment is exactly as depicted in the AirBnb listing. It is spacious, clean, comfortable, close to the village of Sag Harbor and down the block from a beautiful private beach. Given the cost of hotels in this area this apartment is an excellent value. While we did not speak or meet during our stay Lisa provided clear directions with regard to finding the home, parking and how to enter and left us her cell phone number in case we needed anything.

Nothing like waking up to a sunrise in bed. Perfect place for someone who loves the ocean. I couldn’t ask for much more for the price. Perfect for a romantic weekend getaway or just some quiet time.

This home is beautiful and so spacious! Proximity to East Hampton and Springs, yet very private and peaceful. Couldn’t recommend enough!

We were unfortunately unable to actually stay at Linda’s place due to our flights to the area being cancelled due to a hurricane. However, Linda was in constant communication with us as we were trying to get flights up there and held the rental for us in the off chance we were able to make it out for part of the stay. In the end the hurricane had different plans for us but we are thankful for Linda’s constant and timely communication with us.

This cottage is the perfect getaway for rest, relaxation and a little adventure. We were so comfortable there and felt right at home. The location is fantastic- away from hustle and bustle, but close enough to explore surrounding areas and villages. The cottage is full of extra special touches that make the stay even more great. Lisa is a great host, and her communication from the moment you book to checkout is unmatched. Highly recommend.

Vincent’s place was great for my husband, myself, our baby and my parents to stay when visiting Jamesport for a wedding. Beautiful cottage, close to everything, and Vincent was very easy to communicate with. Would stay here again

The beach house was great. Instead of being on a road, it was on a green commons area that gave it a really relaxed neighborly feel. It was a very easy and pleasant 1 minute stroll to the beach, where was a great pastry and shop, and restaurant, and some simply amazing views. Deb's communications were also great and check in went amazingly smoothly. Also the town of New Suffolk itself is quite charming, and is a perfect base for exploring vineyards, beaches, hiking trails and whatnot.

We had a wonderful stay at Mischa’s home. The house was truly stunning - beautifully decorated and clean. Mischa has clearly thought about all of the little details that make a stay memorable - the kitchen was well stocked and the place was so cozy.

I stayed here with my mom and siblings over Thanksgiving weekend and it was absolutely perfect. The entrance was a little hard to find at night, but Allison's directions made it easier. The house was notably spotless. We joked that we must have been the first guests based on how clean it was. All of the beds were comfortable, the house was nice and quiet, and we genuinely had no complaints! So happy we found this place. Allison is a great host. She was very responsive and friendly. I would recommend this stay to anyone and hope to stay here again!

We had the most wonderful and peaceful fall weekend at Brooke’s cozy cottage to celebrate our anniversary, and it was truly unforgettable! The cottage itself is beautifully decorated and felt like a warm home away from home. Brooke went above and beyond to make our stay special, leaving us complimentary champagne and wine to kick off our celebration. The location was perfect for enjoying the crisp fall air and stunning foliage, providing the peaceful retreat we were hoping for. We can’t recommend this place enough and will definitely be back for another stay!

Cottage 3 at Lenhart’s Cottages. Stayed here with my husband and dog during a quick getaway. Love that it’s dog friendly! The location is amazing. Literally a 1-2 min walk from a very nice beach. Also close to town. The only negative thing was I encountered and killed a few ants and a big millepede or centipede thingy with a lot of legs in the bathroom. Overall a pleasant stay and would recommend.

Incredible location! Walking distance to the town. The neighborhood is very quiet and we felt very comfortable all weekend long. Carole and Rich are wondering hosts, and the apartment had everything we needed. We would recommend!!

Our 3 time staying at Amanda’s home. Beautiful and spacious within walking distance to village. Looking forward to coming back next year!

Great spot! Very walkable. It's also a great layout if traveling with small children - there is a separate meditation room upstairs that was perfect for setting up our travel cribs. Would stay again!

Michael is such a courteous, considerate and generous host. We have stayed many, many times and it feels like a second home. I highly recommend this cozy, clean apartment. Micheal goes out of his way to make sure you are taken care of. Best host! Truly!

Great location very close to down town, I didn't realize the home was a split level but it didn't interfere once. Danielle was easy to communicate with, the home was clean and had everything we needed for a long weekend. Can definitely recommend the restaurant The Halyard! Was amazing.

I had the best stay, it’s about 15 min. Or a little more if you’re not in a hurry to down town Sag Harbor and all the super cute shops and wonderful restaurants… and of course all the Galleries… Such a cute place and the bed was overly comfy… The host was so accommodating and helpful, I definitely recommend this place!!!

Lovely, clean, comfortable, well-designed space. Hosts are friendly, responsive, and respectful of guests’ privacy. Would stay again!

It really is steps from the bay!! Stayed with my partner for 3 nights during the off season, the place was so cozy and clean, a perfect place to relax and warm up between chilly walks on the beach. We had a wonderful stay and really appreciated all of the hosts’ local recommendations for food and shopping. Hoping to return again in warmer weather !! Thank you so much to Patti and Lily once again ♥️