Cottage vacation rentals in Rushford Lake

Loved the stay. Conesus Lake is beautiful. The house was very nice. Jeff was an awesome host and answered the phone right away for anything we needed. We brought a boat and jetski so being right on the water with dock access and lifts for the vehicles was super convenient. Will absolutely book again hopefully in the near future.

Had a wonderful time at Jan and Mark's Cozy Lake Front Cottage in Faun Lake! The cottage comes with a full working kitchen, and many places to sit for enjoying a card game or a campfire. The front porch is a big bonus, also. All in all, everything was great! For shopping: Warsaw about 20 minutes away has ample shopping with a Walmart, Tops grocery and boutiques. Arcade, also about 20 minutes, has a decent amount of shops and groceries. The lakes were beautiful and really do offer Adirondack like views. The trails circle both larger lakes and have seating spots, gazebos and docks. If you have a canoe or kayak, bring it to enjoy the paddling. We rate this as 5 star and would recommend this to anyone who's looking for a great deal with an awesome experience!

Beautiful views, nice space, friendly and helpful host. Would stay again

This is my families second time staying at Kathryn’s place. Hassle, free check-in , great space for large numbers of guests , clean , adequately supplied . she gives super fast response time with questions . Very accommodating . Kathryn’s place has amazing view’s and is very peaceful . We would not hesitate to stay here again in the future.

This was the perfect place for a girls weekend! The cottage was immaculately, clean, just as it was described & beautifully decorated. There was plenty of places to sit outside, to sit inside to just enjoy the lake. The kitchen was well stocked with everything we needed. I would highly recommend this cottage!!!

House was as advertised. Had use of the owners Kayak for a small fee (which the owner kindly waived). Views from the house are outstanding. Very good fishing in the lake - caught dozens of fish off the dock. Reasonably close to Niagara Falls, East Aurora, Keuka Lake for day trips. Very close to a Letchworth and a local Cidery in Castile - which were both fantastic. Very reasonably priced for a lakefront property in the Finger Lake Region. Our family had a wonderful stay - would definitely recommend.

Host is very responsive and in tune with guests needs. Very flexible. We felt right at home. It's our 3rd time staying and will go back soon. Plenty of space to lounge, read or watch TV. Even in winter, it's a cozy place to stay at with very relaxing views. Kitchen is well stocked and ready to use. We all had a great time! Thanks so much Anthony!

The cottage was so cozy and just perfect for what we needed for our weekend. It was exactly as described and the views at sunset were *chefs kiss*. My kids had an absolute blast on the swim mat and the dock and our very senior chocolate lab had no troubles wading into the lake to cool off and napping in the shade. I did cook the days we were there and I do wish the kitchen was a little more well stocked. It was missing the basics like a colander and measuring cups. I looked everywhere, and if they were there, I couldn’t find em. And we did have a little trouble with the lock getting in. Gena’s cottage is absolutely wonderful and we would 100% recommend. It’s so perfect for all ages. We had my 1 1/2 year old to my 68 year old father. What are you waiting for!? Book it!!!

Clean and everything was nice. Great dock and swimming area.

Erica’s place was great to stay at. The home was very cozy and beautiful surroundings. Highly recommend for future people!

We came to town to visit the Zippo Museum and the history of this BnB property was just a bonus! Jessica’s spouse met us while arriving and gave us extra history info and restaurant recs. We tried both and were very pleased (Corner Bar & Kabob’s at the Option House.) If ur passing thru or wanting a wknd trip would highly recommend this perfectly equipped little cottage. It has tons of little extras u may have forgotten, or forgot that u even needed.

The Mafia House is exactly what you’d expect and want for the weekend. The location is perfect, walk out the door and there is the stadium (new and old). Plenty of tailgating fun around the house, everyone was super nice and welcoming. Shane was a great host, answered texts quickly and made sure we had what we needed. Highly recommend this place if the opportunity comes about, it just adds a little extra to a great Bills weekend. GO Bills!

The property was beautiful, inside and out. The inside was absolutely charming and perfect for us, and two bathrooms for two bedrooms was amazing. Stepping outside and hearing the babble of water and chirping of birds made for such a relaxing weekend.

Great place to stay for the weekend, close to Geneseo and many great restaurants! Only 30 minutes away from Rochester as well. Small place but can fit a family if needed

Nice cozy cabin. Dogs enjoyed the yard. Thank you!

well worth the money for this place. would recommend to everyone. hot tub ,pound absolutely beautiful. pets friendly which is a plus .even had dog bowls. literally can't wait to go back . the host and co host communicate fast and will bend over backwards for you. 10 out of 10

We had a great time here! very cute and cozy cabin, private area. A lovely place to stay. 20 min drive from Letchworth.

Great place! Very peaceful! Thanks again!!

Jennifer was a wonderful host - very helpful and responsive. Beautiful location, well kept, comfortable cottage. A great place to stay while moving my daughter out of college. We will definitely keep it in mind for future visits!

My family and I had the absolute most wonderful weekend here!! Victoria was super responsive and made sure we had everything we needed. We ice fished and cooked on the grill and relaxed in the hot tub. ❤️ it was absolutely wonderful!

As soon as we got settled in Dorothy’s beautiful cabin, we knew we’d be coming back in the future. The space itself is cozy, private but not isolated, and filled with genuine decor to make you feel right at home immediately. Dorothy herself is responsive and kind, we especially appreciated all the notecard descriptions of some of the family history behind items in the home. So beautiful. Could not recommend this host and this space enough. It truly tied together a perfect weekend for my girlfriends birthday celebration.

Susan's wonderful, cozy, and clean cottage was absolutely PERFECT in every way and we can't wait to return! It was absolutely spotless, contained everything we needed (and then some) for our stay, and she even left us some yummy goodies for a welcome gift! The bed was super comfortable, the shower water pressure was perfect, and the cozy living room area and kitchen made us feel right at home. It was rainy, cold and windy during our stay (we even experienced some April snow!), but the little fireplace and heated flooring kept us nice and warm. We loved the decor too- so inviting and calming. The single car garage was a HUGE plus too as we didn't have to have to go out into the rainy weather to be able to get into and out of our car. Susan was such a gracious host and it was a joy and blessing to be able to meet her in person! Susan's beautiful Hinsdale Cottage has moved right to the top of our list of our favorite AirBnb rentals and we can't wait to return!

Very clean, organized and super well kept place with everything my family and I could have needed. The description and photos don't do justice. Great location. Felt like a home away from home. Very responsive host. Would def come back again!

Very comfortable stay. Host was responsive and attentive to details. Would recommend.