Cottage vacation rentals in New Buffalo Township

My family had a great time. Home was as described. Outside area was great.

Such a fun weekend! Location to beach and other fun activities was fantastic! Very cute cottage with all the amenities we needed. Thanks, Jennifer!!

Amy was a fantastic host! Any questions we had were answered immediately. Cabin was great super clean and comfy. We will be back!

As soon as we started packing we already miss it we loved it the hot was nice I love how at night time the sitting area light up up the inside was lovely I love how it’s small but it have a lot of space the was our first time getting an Airbnb and we loved it 10/10 would definitely come here again food spot little far out but we didn’t mind it the drive is nice and peaceful I love how we get to cows and horses on the way only 2 things I’ll say about the Airbnb I wouldn’t complain about or make it a big deal you will see ants ofc and the bed was uncomfortable but we really didn’t mind it we had to much fun to even worry about other than that we loved it❤️

We had a quick two night stay while visiting the area. The house was as listed and we had a great time. We loved the hot tub and the indoor space. Comfortable seating in the living area while we waited out the rain. There is a train that travels close by but otherwise had a great stay!

Very peaceful to stay put here--bring what you need and stay in these beautiful surroundings among birds and gardens and an art-filled home. Or spend time on nearby beaches and trails, wander the nearby small-town shops and nice variety of restaurants and look forward to a hot tub soak and campfire. Donna's home is welcoming and inspiring!

We had an absolutely amazing stay at this beautifully decorated and incredibly comfortable home. From the moment we arrived, we felt right at home — every detail was thoughtfully designed, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The space was spotless, stylish, and perfectly equipped for a relaxing getaway. One of the highlights of our experience was the exceptional management team. They were extremely kind, friendly, and responsive, making everything seamless from check-in to check-out. It’s rare to find such genuine hospitality!

We stayed at Kimberly’s place for a girls trip and it was everything I had hoped it would be! We relaxed, boated, kayaked & went to town for the farmers market. The boat is a great amenity (really need a better anchor though 😅) The 1908 lake house was beautifully decorated & very homey! Perfect for our group of 5 ladies.

We loved our winter stay here with our dog. Fran thought of everything from extra blankets to dog waste bags! We wanted for nothing & loved the short walk to the main strip of town. Beds were comfortable, everything was exceptionally clean, the fenced yard was great for the dog, and communication with host was very responsive. We highly recommend this charming cottage for any time of the year. We will definitely stay here again!

Third time staying here - we love this place. Brendon and Bryndal do an amazing job communicating and their place is always clean and in great shape. We like the walking areas near the house for our pup and the disc golf in Michigan City. Always a pleasure to visit - thanks

Great place to stay located right in the coast and close to fun towns. Lee is an amazing host!

The Place was clean and quiet. Beautiful trees surround the area. I am familiar with the New Buffalo and Union pier area. It was right in the middle of all the Restaurants. Sunroom was a great hang out. Yard was a large and private space to hang out and get a fire going. Of course, the koi fish was an extra bit of enjoyment, watching them. Would highly recommend this rental.

Very cozy and cute place! I loved the short walk into town. It was the perfect place to spend the weekend. My family & fur-baby adored this place and I definitely plan to come back. I loved the backyard! It’s so big! It was fun to hang back there and exercise. I have so many good things to say.

What a beautiful location! Loved all the trees, beautiful yard to play games, super big fire pit, deck and grill was spotless! The inside was nice and spacious for the size. Great kitchen and bathrooms. The basement was large! We had an incredible time. Would come back for a longer vacation!

Review..... Host Annette was very accommodating and fast response. The home is a very quaint cottage with every amenity we needed. There are many water toys (peddle boat, kayak, paddle board) and life jackets. My grandchildren enjoyed fishing and swimming. But, the best part is the amazing view. Even saw a deer in the lake! This place is on the top of my list when I come back. Jill St Petersburg, FL

Good location! Cute stay :) Great food and dunes nearby! Perfect for stargazing! FYI the weather was pretty chilly in May!

Loved this cute little cottage! Very well decorated and the accommodations were great. Great location as well. Alannah and Nick were extremely accommodating and responsive. I would definitely visit again!

Great place to stay, right on the beach, comfortable.

I wish I could convey how incredible our stay was. Herb is a FANTASTIC host, and their home is so beautiful and cozy. This made for the most wonderful and memorable weekend. We walked in the door and immediately decided that we will be returning. THANK YOU!!!!

Highly recommend. 10/5 stars. Great location, communication, extremely cozy and peaceful and the beach access is top notch. We will be returning for sure.

We choose Trevah’s place for our family weekend getaway. It was fun. My granddaughter enjoyed the spacious home. She answered our questions in a timely manner and was helpful getting us connected with the Marina to rent a pontoon for the day. Our family had a blast. The one thing that we all had to get used to was the lack of window shades, specially for the sunrise. Don’t get us wrong. We loved all the windows. But it was something to get used to. Definitely would will consider coming back. Thank you Trevah for sharing your home with us. Otherwise lovely home.

We had a great stay! Great location and our kids had a blast just playing in the yard. The kitchen had everything we could have needed and more. Wayne was responsive whenever we had a question. Would definitely stay here again!

This is our second time staying here this summer. We enjoyed it so much the first time we booked again. Great location with tons of good local eats. Christen is very easy to work with and so communicative. The house feels like home- so much that our kids asked when we were moving here. The walk to the beach is short and the privacy of the beach is so nice.

Just as described. Had everything we needed And nice and quiet. There are railroad tracks directly behind the property, but only a small passenger Amtrak runs every few hours and you rarely even notice it. Place was clean and Jonie Was responsive on the rare occasion that we needed to contact her.