Lake house vacation rentals in Lake Shafer

Find and book unique lake houses on Airbnb

Top-rated lake house rentals in Lake Shafer

Guests agree: these lake houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

A stone fire pit is surrounded by circular pavers, with several blue lounge chairs positioned nearby. A grassy yard expands around the area, while the home features multiple large windows and a covered patio for outdoor relaxation.

Home in Monticello

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

The Main Lake House

Located on Main Lake Freeman with gorgeous views and updated floor plan. Enjoy lake access with Pergola Patio,Propane Grill, Fire Pit, and gradual sandy lake access with Dock. Dock Whips - Secure Watercraft up to 24’ Enjoy watching the Madam Carroll cruise by daily while cooking out. Probably the best patio for drinking morning coffee in the entire Midwest! Newly added Game Room for your enjoyment. Under 15 Minute drive to Indiana Beach and under 10 minutes to beautiful down town Monticello, IN

Superhost

The screened porch is illuminated at dusk, showcasing a spacious seating area with a lounge chair. Large windows provide views into the interior, where warm lights and a dining space are visible. The exterior features a light-colored structure with a gravel path.

Home in Monticello

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 31 reviews

Modern lake front house w/ HOT TUB for 10 people!

Visit Piper House to enjoy the lake life, beautiful views, hot tub, beach, dock swimming, private playground, fire pits and more in our NEW modern lake house. Easy getaway from Chicago (2hr)/ Indy (1.5hr). Impressive views from huge Lake Shafer lot with dock, beach, firepit & screened porch with outdoor living/dining room. No expense spared. It’s fully stocked, totally tricked out, and all about comfort. (For high-season May-Sept bookings, see https://www.airbnb.com/rooms/20663989/ instead)

Superhost

A charming cottage exterior is highlighted by a welcoming front porch with two chairs. Wooden steps lead to the porch, which is surrounded by black railing. Lush greenery is visible nearby, complementing the light-colored siding and gray roof under a partly cloudy sky.

Home in Monticello

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Indiana Beach's best retreat

Minutes from both Indiana beach amusement park and Indiana beach boat rentals. Boat dock available. Includes a fully equipped kitchen, linens, both bath and beach towels. Fully rehabbed. Most furnishing are new including kitchen-equipment/accessories. Provided is an array of sundries including, bug spray, sunscreen, shower gel, shampoo, and conditioner. Kitchen is stocked with basics such as sugar, coffee, tea, condiments, S/P and maybe a few treats and sticks to roast marshmallows or hot dogs.

A wooden staircase descends to a spacious deck by the lake, framed by leafy trees. Two kayaks are docked at the pier, and decorative bunting adds a colorful touch. The shimmering lake surface reflects clouds above and nearby trees, creating a serene lakeside scene.

Home in Monticello

4.75 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Lake Shafer Home: Boat, Swim, Kayak, BBQ, Sunsets!

Spacious 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home ON Lake Shafer facing west for amazing sunsets! Several levels of decking offer grilling, eating, water sports, and lounging area with fire table and fire pit nook right next to the water. Large lake raft, kayaks, and paddle board waiting by the pier for you with two bays close by. Living room with panoramic view of lake, cozy second floor loft with books /games. Stocked coffee bar. Washer and dryer on site. Four parking spaces right in front of the house.

An open-concept living area is showcased with a modern kitchen featuring granite counters. A black sofa and a foosball table provide spaces for relaxation and entertainment. Natural light streams in through large windows, highlighting a vintage upright piano in the corner.

Home in Monticello

4.63 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

#4 Dock swim, float, 2 min walk to Indiana beach!

This lower unit offers a scenic retreat with room for 6 guests, ideal for 2 adults and kids. Two bedrooms, including a cozy nook for the little ones. Enjoy modern amenities like granite counters and barn-style doors in the open concept kitchen. Evening entertainment with a foosball game. A large picture window provides a stunning Lake Shafer view. Share the dock with 4 other units for water fun. End the day around the bonfire pit. Your lakeside paradise awaits – book now!" (Monthly Discounts)

Guest favorite

The spacious living area features large windows that fill the room with natural light and offer views of the lake and surrounding greenery. A dining table with chairs is positioned near a cozy sitting area, which includes a sofa and armchair, enhancing the inviting ambiance.

Home in Monticello

5 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

Lakeside Bliss: Wonderful Lake Views & Access

Welcome to your lakeside retreat! Newly renovated 2bedroom, 2bath gem offers modern comfort and stunning lake views. Spacious living area flooded with natural light, fully equipped kitchen for easy meal prep, and dining area with breathtaking views. Both bedrooms boast cozy linens and plush bedding, ensuring a tranquil night's rest. Direct lake access for swimming, fishing, or basking in the sun on the private dock. Roll-away bed can fit in any bedroom and queen size air mattress available.

Guest favorite

A spacious deck overlooks a tranquil lake with a view of an amusement park in the distance. The wooden railing frames the scene, and a pair of blue chairs is visible on the deck, inviting relaxation while enjoying the surrounding nature and amusement park structures.

Home in Monticello

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Lakefront Escape | Dock, Fire Pit & Park Lights

Step into your perfect lakeside getaway — a cozy 2-bedroom waterfront cottage where relaxation and fun go hand-in-hand. Spend your mornings fishing off the private dock or enjoying the gentle breeze by the shoreline, and wind down your evenings roasting s’mores under the stars. Set right on the shores of Lake Shafer, this hidden gem offers unobstructed views of Indiana Beach, where the lights of the amusement park and the hum of the roller coasters create a truly unforgettable backdrop.

Guest favorite

A wooden dock extends towards a lush, green yard framed by tall trees. In the background, a two-story house nestled among the trees is partially visible, emphasizing a serene lakeside setting.

Home in Monticello

5 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Lakeside Haven: 4 bed/2 bath/sleeps 9 on the water

Lakeside Haven: Your Dream Walk-Out Ranch Getaway in Monticello, Indiana Welcome to your serene escape on the shores of Lake Shafer—where peaceful mornings, adventure-filled afternoons, and golden hour sunsets create the perfect backdrop for memories that last a lifetime. Tucked away on a private, wooded lot in beautiful Monticello, Indiana, this stunning 4-bedroom, 2-bathroom walk-out ranch is your invitation to unwind, recharge, and reconnect with the ones who matter most.

Guest favorite

A spacious home is set along the water's edge, showcasing a welcoming yellow exterior. A broad deck extends toward the lake, accompanied by a subtle landscape featuring well-maintained gardens. The serene surface of the water reflects the house and the surrounding greenery.

Home in Monticello

5 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Mellow Yellow on Shafer

Bring the family to this beautiful, spacious home on Shafer Lake. 4.5 miles to Indiana Beach 3.3 miles to Tippecanoe Country Club 1.5 miles to Hollow Acres Gold Course 2.5 miles to Battle Ground Golf Club 9.4 miles to Altherr Nature Park 4.4 miles to Lake Shafer Boat Rentals 1.1 miles to The Boat House 9.8 miles to Whyte Horse Winery 4.5 miles to Whisky & Wine Saloon 10 miles to Sportsmann Inn 10 miles to Kopacetic Brewery 12 miles to Fruitshine Wine

Guest favorite

The cottage features a spacious deck, surrounded by greenery and shaded by trees. Outdoor furniture is arranged for relaxation, with an umbrella providing shade. A decorative pot can be seen at the edge of the deck, adding a welcoming touch to the area.

Home in Monticello

5 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Cozy Cove Cottage

Lake life is truly the best life—and after a stay at Cozy Cove Cottage, you’ll understand why. Wake up to the gentle sounds of water lapping against the shore as you sip your morning coffee on the spacious deck with beautiful lake views. Whether you’re out on the water or simply relaxing in the peaceful embrace of nature, time seems to slow down here, inviting you to breathe deeper, laugh louder, and soak in every unforgettable moment.

Guest favorite

A spacious deck extends over the calm water, featuring several outdoor chairs and a dining table. Lush trees frame the view, with a few houses visible across the lake. The wooden railing adds a natural touch to the tranquil setting.

Home in Monticello

5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Adorable House on Lake Shafer!

2023 20' Pontoon available at an extra charge! Full of amenities this 3 Bedroom, 3 Bath home with two separate living areas has plenty of room for up to 10 guests if using our QUEEN size sofa bed and available cot. Smart TVs in every bedroom with fast WiFi. Comfy bedding with fresh linens, bath towels and beach towels are provided. Washer and dryer available including Tide Pods, Bounce and Bleach.

A view from the water showcases the cozy bungalow set against a lush green lawn. A fountain is depicted in the foreground, adding movement to the scene. The boat dock is visible, featuring a lift and ample space for watercraft. An American flag flutters gently nearby.

Home in Monticello

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

Bailey Bungalow Lake house

Come stay at this cozy bungalow on the Big Monon just off beautiful Lake Shafer and minutes from Indiana Beach Amusement Park. This 3 bed 2 bath private home is located in one of the best fishing spots comes with a boat lift and piers. Watch the sunset from the deck or soaking in the lake. Rental includes all modern amenities. Also available is the rental of a golf cart for additional charge.