Some info has been automatically translated. Show original language

Lake houses in Lake Shafer

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

0 of 0 items showing
1 of 3 pages

Popular amenities for Lake Shafer vacation rentals

Lake Shafer fishing houses

A serene view of the house from Lake Freeman highlights its lush green lawn and surrounding trees. A wooden dock extends towards the water, with a gentle slope leading up to the home, which features multiple levels and an array of outdoor areas.
Home in Monticello
4.74 out of 5 average rating, 54 reviews

Panoramic view on Lake Freeman!

JesusRating, 5 stars9 months ago
This home had everything we needed! Check-in to check-out was easy and reasonable. Would definitely come back.
Superhost
The modern lake house is set on a sloped wooded lot, surrounded by vibrant green grass and trees. A wooden staircase leads from the water's edge up to the screened porch, emphasizing a seamless connection between the house and the lakefront.
Home in Monticello
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 31 reviews

Modern lake front house w/ HOT TUB for 10 people!

JanieRating, 5 stars18 months ago
Great place description is very accurate. Host is very helpful and responsive. Home is beautiful and comfortable. Loves staying here
Guest favorite
A well-maintained lawn is bordered by a white picket fence, leading to a view of the dock along the river. Surrounding greenery and trees provide a natural backdrop, while a pathway made of concrete guides the way towards the water.
Home in Monticello
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 35 reviews

3 Bedroom River Retreat with lake access

JonathanRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago
went their and stayed 3 weeks for work. it was perfect foe what I needed and being on the water was an added bonus! very enjoyable place to stay!
Superhost
An open kitchen space features white cabinetry and a wooden island with seating for three. Modern appliances are present, and a welcoming sign hangs on the wall. Natural light enters through a window above the sink, illuminating the countertop and decor.
Home in Rochester
4.86 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews

Ohana Lake Cottage

KimberlyRating, 5 stars5 months ago
Our stay at Pam’s was so very nice Comfortable bed. Having washer/dryer Ami’s a plus. The lake view is BEAUTIFUL! Pam made everything easy and communicated quickly and well. We will be back. Did I mention, the view was Great?!
Guest favorite
A spacious backyard is viewed from above, featuring a large deck extending over the water. The deck includes seating arrangements, surrounded by lush greenery. A house with light-colored siding is positioned near the water's edge, with a lawn and a fire pit visible in the background.
Home in Monticello
5 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

Mellow Yellow on Shafer

StevenRating, 5 stars9 months ago
We had a wonderful time at Mellow Yellow! The home was clean, spacious. The kitchen had everything that you could need, and the home was exactly how it was described! Marie was very flexible and easy to work with, as well as excellent in her communication. This was one of our favorite locations that we have stayed at through Airbnb. We will absolutely consider coming back again as we plan our next trip!
Guest favorite
A charming cottage exterior is highlighted by a welcoming front porch with two chairs. Wooden steps lead to the porch, which is surrounded by black railing. Lush greenery is visible nearby, complementing the light-colored siding and gray roof under a partly cloudy sky.
Home in Monticello
5 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Indiana Beach's best retreat

TommyRating, 5 stars1 week ago
Amazing place, great house. The only downfall was the amount of TVs with zero Wi-Fi.
Guest favorite
The spacious living area features large windows that fill the room with natural light and offer views of the lake and surrounding greenery. A dining table with chairs is positioned near a cozy sitting area, which includes a sofa and armchair, enhancing the inviting ambiance.
Home in Monticello
5 out of 5 average rating, 14 reviews

Lakeside Bliss: Wonderful Lake Views & Access

LindseyRating, 5 stars2 weeks ago
While we felt the price was steep for 2 bedrooms, the house was pristine and even better than the photos convey. We were extremely pleased with the house, location, cleanliness, easy access, pet and kid-friendliness, etc. We would definitely stay again but potentially with a couple more friends to split the cost. We had 4 adults, a child, and our dog. There’s plenty of space for an air mattress or the cot for additional folks. We will highly recommend this place to friends and plan to return!
Top guest favorite
A stone fire pit is surrounded by circular pavers, with several blue lounge chairs positioned nearby. A grassy yard expands around the area, while the home features multiple large windows and a covered patio for outdoor relaxation.
Home in Monticello
5 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

The Main Lake House

JeremyRating, 5 stars10 months ago
Great place on the lake. Brought our family of 5 and rotated a friend or two throughout the week. Brought our boat and 2 jet skis and the hosts were very helpful with ideas to keep them safely docked out on the water. Lots of space at the house for everyone to hang out together or in pockets. Plenty of room in the garage for all of our gear too. Hope to come back every year.

Lake Shafer fishing vacation rentals

Guest favorite
A charming waterfront home features large glass windows allowing natural light to illuminate the interior. The exterior showcases a smooth stone pathway leading to the entrance, with a blend of rustic brick and dark siding complemented by surrounding greenery.
Cottage in Monticello
5 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Waterfront Lake House

AmiRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago
Had a couple snaffus outside of the host’s control (gusty winds and tornado watches) and the hosts were very responsive and helpful. The beds were remarkably comfortable and the patio was really as serene as the pictures. Thank you
Superhost
Aerial view of the resort property reveals a well-maintained landscape with lush greenery and multiple wooden decks. The shore features a private dock with boat slips, providing access to the tranquil waters of Honey Creek Bay.
Cottage in Monticello
4.83 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Deluxe Lakefront Cottage with Private Deck

AmyRating, 5 stars23 months ago
Great family run resort. Perfect size and very welcoming. It’s quaint and very much has a small town feel. It was perfect for our big group of 9! Nice deck/grill/view of the lake.
Superhost
A cabin with a combination of light blue and brick exterior stands near the water. A screened porch is visible on the side, and the lawn is surrounded by neatly trimmed grass and shrubs. The tranquil lake and outdoor seating area are seen in the background.
Cottage in Monticello
4.75 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews

Dly Wkly Mthly Rates Avail 01/01 to 04/30/25 2bd

MichaelRating, 5 stars1 month ago
Loved the location plus Frank communicated with me several times to check if there were any issues and to just check that we found the house and were able to get in. Will definitely check if his place is available if I need to work in the area again.
Top guest favorite
The spacious living area features high, wooden-beamed ceilings and large glass doors that open to a scenic lake view. Comfortable leather seating is arranged around a central area rug adorned with a starfish pattern. Additional seating includes woven chairs, creating a welcoming atmosphere.
Cottage in Monticello
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 55 reviews

The Sandbar Cottage on Lake Freeman

MaureenRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago
Shelli was a wonderful host! The house was well appointed for a fun-filled vacation at the lake!
Top guest favorite
The view from a wooden deck features a serene lake bordered by lush greenery. Tall trees provide shade, while a private dock extends into the water. Small boats can be seen cruising by in the distance, suggesting a peaceful and inviting outdoor setting.
Cottage in Monticello
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 65 reviews

Lake Shafer 3 bedroom 2 bath lakefront house

ChrisRating, 5 stars1 month ago
An awesome and charming little place in a perfect spot. Perfectly situated to enjoy sunrises over the lake!
Guest favorite
The expansive exterior of the chalet is highlighted by a wrap-around deck with two umbrellas, providing shaded seating areas. Large windows atop the entrance allow natural light to fill the space, while a grassy area and landscape stones complete the inviting outdoor setting.
Cabin in Monticello
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 51 reviews

3,800 Sq Ft., Rustic Luxury Estate On Lake Freeman

KimberlyRating, 5 stars6 months ago
This was the perfect place for a family Christmas. We felt like we were on the set of a Hallmark movie! The cabin is quite large and has plenty of seating for wherever people want to gather. The kitchen was very well stocked and clean, the beds were comfortable and Brian and Allison were more than accommodating and quick to respond. We only wish we would had another couple days to spend there!
Guest favorite
The rustic cabin exterior is surrounded by trees, featuring a stone foundation and black log walls. An American flag adds a touch of charm. Inside, an open floor plan showcases a cozy living area with a sofa, a stone fireplace, and a lofted space visible above.
Cabin in Monticello
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 63 reviews

Sunset Cabin

AnnieRating, 5 stars1 week ago
My friend and I had a great girls weekend away at Lois’s! Her cottage is adorable and cozy making you feel right at home. Lois thought of everything and was so helpful and responded right away when we communicated. We would definitely stay there again! Thank you Lois!! -Annie S
Guest favorite
The cabin exterior showcases a metal roof and a combination of wooden and stone elements. Two wooden chairs are placed on the porch, providing a welcoming spot. Large windows flank the entrance door, allowing natural light to enhance the outdoor view.
Cabin in Rensselaer
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 32 reviews

Brightstone Lake Cabin 3

CeeRating, 5 stars2 months ago
The cabin was even more cozy than it appears in photos. Very clean. The location is peaceful and scenic. Would definitely stay here again!

Other great vacation rentals in Lake Shafer

Guest favorite
A whimsical illustration captures a black and white horse galloping through a stylized landscape. Surrounding trees and various woodland creatures are depicted, creating a magical atmosphere. The words 'Farm to Folklore' are prominently displayed in earthy tones, enhancing the enchanting theme.
Farm stay in Delphi
4.82 out of 5 average rating, 197 reviews

A Fairytale Farmhouse at Farm to Folklore

MichaelRating, 5 stars1 month ago
Our farmstay was so wonderful. Emma has done a magnificent job with the design of this beautiful farmhouse - every room is magical; full of books and incredible views from the large windows. From the front porch swing, to the cabinet under the stairs in the Harry Potter-inspired bedroom, to the welcoming lounge spaces throughout is a joy. The pictures can't possibly capture the magic of this space. The highlight of our week was time with the horses - Angie spent considerable time with our two children (12 & 10), from teaching them to groom the horse to preparing the saddle, and then learning to ride in the pasture. Her gentleness with the animals was easily translated to the kids when they seemed nervous - we couldn't have asked for a better experience for them. Overall, a truly remarkable space with two truly talented people. We'll certainly return for more adventures as soon as we're able!
Guest favorite
A charming log cabin is set amidst lush greenery, featuring a spacious covered porch with multiple rocking chairs. Decorative planters hang from the porch, and the American flag is visible, contributing to the welcoming aesthetic of this woodland retreat.
Cabin in Delphi
4.86 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Enjoy the serenity of Cabin Life

TerriRating, 5 stars5 days ago
Mary Ann was an excellent host! She answered all my questions and made us feel welcome! This cabin was amazing! Anything you can think of they had it covered! Fire pit set up so we could easily light it , coffee bar and had fresh cookies ! My husband is in wheelchair and we brought ramps to get inside. Her and her husband met us there to make sure it would work for us ! Would highly recommend !
A view of the bright green lawn is framed by lush trees, with a winding creek visible in the background. A pot of colorful flowers sits on a weathered table, enhancing the natural setting. A small stack of firewood is positioned on the grass.
Cabin in Monticello
4.67 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews

Cozy Cabin

MattRating, 5 stars1 month ago
Heidy gave us a wonderful stay. It was worth every penny. If I was in the area I would stay again and again.
Guest favorite
An outdoor area is seen with a fire pit surrounded by stones and seating. A wooden bench is placed nearby, among tall trees and lush greenery, creating a serene environment. The ground is covered in dark mulch, offering a natural and rustic feel.
Cabin in Rossville
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 94 reviews

Enjoy the peace and quiet

AnnetteRating, 5 stars1 week ago
What a wonderful place! We loved our stay at the cabin. It's clean and cozy, and is in a beautiful location. Kevin was friendly and responsive. We would love to return on a future trip to Lafayette.
A person sits in a green Adirondack chair on a wooden dock, facing the calm waters of Lake Shafer. Lush greenery can be seen across the lake, with a boat anchored nearby. The sky is partly cloudy, adding to the serene lakeside atmosphere.
Home in Monticello
4.58 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

#4 Dock swim, float, 2 min walk to Indiana beach!

EduardoRating, 5 stars3 months ago
The place is really nice with a beautiful sorrounding and nice view facing the lake. Michael was really responsive , nice communication. Thanks Michael!
Top guest favorite
A view of the lake from the outdoor seating area showcases a spacious deck with chairs facing the water. A path leads down stone steps surrounded by greenery, and a small flower pot adds a touch of natural decor to the scene.
Cottage in Monticello
5 out of 5 average rating, 11 reviews

Tranquil Lake Cottage

LaurenRating, 5 stars10 months ago
Amy is a fantastic host and her home is amazing and VERY CLEAN! She’s thought of every detail. All of the outdoor spaces are beautiful with plenty of seating. We loved having multiple decks to hangout on. Most of the beds were very comfortable (the bunk beds are good for kids but not great for adults). The pullout in the living room was surprisingly comfortable! The layout of the house is lovely, inviting, and the kitchen is huge with a large island. Definitely recommend booking if you’re looking for a relaxing stay.
A modern kitchen is highlighted by a central island with a marble countertop, complementing white cabinetry and stainless-steel appliances. Four barstools are arranged along one side of the island. Warm wood beams accentuate the vaulted ceiling, enhancing the spacious atmosphere.
Cottage in Monticello
4.62 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Cheerful 3 - Bedroom Lakehouse With Canal Access

DavidRating, 5 stars10 months ago
Very nice place. Close to restaurants and lake. We had a great time
Guest favorite
A swing is positioned on lush green grass, facing a serene waterfront scene. Boats can be seen docked along a wooden pier under a bright blue sky filled with fluffy clouds. A large tree provides shade nearby, creating a peaceful outdoor space.
Cottage in Monticello
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 38 reviews

Charlesworth Cottage

MagdaleneRating, 5 stars2 months ago
Great little weekend stay!! Wish I could’ve visited in the summer! Would have had an even better time!

Destinations to explore

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Indiana
  4. White County
  5. Lake Shafer