Vacation rentals in Lake Sara

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Lake Sara

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favorite

A spacious two-story house is nestled beside a calm lake, with a large deck overlooking the water. A private dock with a red roof provides boat slips. Surrounding trees offer shade, enhancing the tranquil lakeside setting.

Home in Effingham

Haven on the Lake-Swim/Fishing Dock-8 Beds-2 Baths

Location, Location! Beautiful home with lake access for swimming, fishing, and boating on beautiful Lake Sara. Wonderful 2400sq ft house with dock & boat slips & water toys at awesome location for families/friends to relax & enjoy scenery & boating, have fun in the water, grill out, use the game room, or sit by the fire pit or the fireplace. 7 minutes from Interstates 70 & 57. 6 minutes to Walmart. 6-10 minutes to area restaurants. Golf Courses-1 minute to ForeWay & 2 minutes to Cardinal.

LocationFamilyTV

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 119 reviews

Guest favorite

A cozy sleeping area features a spacious bed with multiple pillows in neutral tones. Wall sconces provide gentle lighting on either side. A decorative sign with the word 'welcome' is displayed above the headboard, adding a personal touch to the inviting space.

Apartment in Teutopolis

The Shoe Inn, a modern apt in downtown Teutopolis

Welcome to The Shoe Inn! You'll be at the center of town within walking distance to all the places you need to be: banquet halls, five bars, restaurants, Wessel's grocery store, ice cream shop, church, hardware store, and community parks. Smart lock, contactless entry is available for a convenient & safe stay. Enjoy the full size washer & dryer (no detergent provided) , fireplace, kitchenette (no stove), free parking, Samsung 50" smart TV w/ 100's of cable channels, Alexa device, & free WiFi

FamilyLocationLong stay

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 676 reviews

Guest favorite

A view of the Lake Sara home from the water, showcasing a spacious deck with white railings and outdoor furniture. The surrounding trees display autumn foliage, providing a warm backdrop against the home. A boat lift is visible alongside the dock, featuring colorful kayaks.

Home in Effingham

Lake Sara Lake House

Come enjoy our Lake Sara home that is situated on Blue Gill Cove with inviting water from the swimming / fishing dock, electric boat lift for your use, beautiful views and a home with 5 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms and an open concept common area. Per the Effingham Water Authority short-term rental ordinance, maximum occupancy is 2 adults (aged 21 and older) per bedroom, with a maximum of 8 adults. This is a 5-bedroom home, so additional guests above 8 adults must be children under the age of 21.

FamilyLocationCheckout

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 66 reviews

Top guest favorite

Place to stay in Greenup

The Candy Kitchen

Take a step back in time as you enter this authentic 1930's Soda Fountain located in downtown Greenup Village of the Porches situated on the Historic National Road. The Loomis Family immigrated from Greece and operated the Soda Fountain and Confectionary until the 1960's. It has since been transformed into a spacious and comfortable living area with the original Soda Fountain still intact, beautiful tin ceiling, and also includes a large kitchen, a separate shower room & powder room.

FamilyLocationGetting around

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 279 reviews

Top guest favorite

Home in Shelbyville

Vintage Victorian | Lake Shelbyville Getaway

Nestled just 1 mile from Lake Shelbyville, this restored Vintage Victorian is the perfect retreat for families and friends. With three cozy bedrooms, a full kitchen, and a relaxing patio overlooking an old brick road, it is made for unwinding and making memories. Shelbyville’s history, parks, shops, and scenic trails offer endless exploring. Located 116 miles from St. Louis and 209 miles from Chicago, this charming home blends comfort, character, and small-town beauty for every guest.

FamilyLocationCheck-in

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Top guest favorite

A spacious lawn leads to a serene three-bedroom home, surrounded by trees and greenery. The property features a view of a pond in the distance, with the American flag gently waving near the entrance.

Cottage in Brownstown

Shagbark Landing

Forget your worries in this spacious and serene space. Drive down the lane to a secluded 3 bedroom home newly furnished. Enjoy yourself in an open concept floor plan where there is lots of room to spread out. Spend your evenings in the living room or the family room that has a fireplace. From the family room you can step out on a deck and enjoy the view of the pond. We are located 8.5 miles from Vandalia where there are historical landmarks, great restaurants, and quaint shops.

ValueLocationBeach

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 213 reviews

Guest favorite

A charming lake house is set among lush trees, featuring a large shaded area with a fabric canopy. Red shutters adorn the windows, while a gravel path leads to the entrance. Colorful floats are arranged in front of the house, enhancing the outdoor space.

Cottage in Effingham

Lakefront Cottage • Dock, Kayaks, Fire Pit & Beach

Welcome! Imagine waking up ten steps from the water, kayak paddles already calling your name. The Lake House on Lake Sara puts you right at the edge of the lake — with four kayaks, a crackling fire pit, and a sunlit enclosed porch to come home to. The Lake House is located just a short walk to the Beach, Pinky’s , The Rusty Reel Bar (below Pinky’s) and The Marina. The beach offers a beautiful playground, pavilions, exercise equipment, pickleball courts and a frisbee golf course!

LocationFamilyDecor

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 321 reviews

Top guest favorite

An open interior showcases a spiral staircase leading to a loft area. A wooden table with seating for four is located in the foreground, complemented by a small kitchen featuring appliances and exposed brick. Natural light enters through the windows, enhancing the warm tones of the space.

Home in Teutopolis

Wooden Shoe Factory, Historic, w/ Bar & Breakfast

Historic 1880 Wooden Shoe Factory by Wooden Shoe Maker Gerhard Deymann. A great getaway Tiny House from the past with a Bar & Books. Please take some & leave some :-) Fully furnished. Tons of charm. It has a loft, luggage lift, exposed brick/beams, fireplace, bikes, antiques, front sitting area, swing, grill, back patio, yard, private parking, appliances, vaulted ceilings. 6 minutes to I57, I70, Effingham, & dozens of restaurants. 1 block to 7 Teutopolis Bars, & diners.

LocationValueNearby

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 255 reviews

Guest favorite

A large tree with a sign reading '9330 The Cabin' is visible in the foreground. A gravel driveway leads to the cabin, framed by lush, green trees that create a serene natural environment.

Cabin in Ashmore

Sweet Dreams Cabin. Peaceful & Relaxing

Get some quality family time at this newly remodeled cabin near the beautiful Embarrass river. You are surrounded by beautiful woods and a small creek. Lush wildlife is all around you so you can be one with nature. The cabin has all the luxury's to allow for a long term stay as well. Beautiful Lake Charleston is not far away. The large circle drive offers plenty of parking for your boat and guest. The large deck on the rear gives a beautiful view to be enjoyed by all.

LocationFamilyView

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 313 reviews

Top guest favorite

Home in Effingham

The Lake House @ Lake Sara Effingham IL

Forget your worries in this spacious and serene space. This home has been filled with cozy vibes, warm corners, and a strict no-stress policy. Consider this your official "relaxation HQ". The Theatre room features a 98" TV and a pit couch for champions. The entire home has been newly renovated with all new furnishings. Outside, you'll enjoy the in-ground pool (seasonally, April-November) and the boat dock with a sundeck on beautiful Lake Sara.

LocationFamilyCondition

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Top guest favorite

The exterior of Paradise Cottage features vibrant red wood paneling, with a stone path leading to a welcoming front door. Large windows allow natural light and views of the surrounding trees, enhancing the cottage's connection to its lakeside environment.

Cabin in Mattoon

Cottage on Lake Paradise

Welcome to Paradise Cottage nestled on Lake Paradise! Cozy and warm with wood finishes throughout. Includes three-tiered deck/patio, with the lowest level sitting over the water. Perfect for fishing (this lake hosts an annual fishing tournament), canoeing/kayaking, or just relaxing. Great for bird watching, with great blue herons, egrets, ducks, bald eagles, plovers, cormorants, woodpeckers and other species seen daily.

LocationValueWifi

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 195 reviews

Top guest favorite

A single-story home is set on a well-maintained lawn, featuring a paved driveway leading to an attached garage. The exterior showcases a mix of light-colored siding and stone accents, framed by mature trees and shrubs, with large windows allowing natural light into the interior.

Home in Vandalia

Modern family friendly home in Historic Vandalia

Beautiful completely updated home with all new items. 2 blocks from the park and swimming pool, stroller in garage if needed. Across the road from the hospital, 2 blocks from public schools, 1 mile from walmart, close to many restaurants and coffee shop. Deck with outdoor seating and fenced in back yard and a corn hole game perfect for this beautiful back yard. And a charcoal grill ready to use.

LocationFamilyIndoor spaces

5.0 out of 5 average rating, 177 reviews