Vacation rentals with a fire pit in Kelleys Island

This was a convenient and nice space for our family to stay on our Cedar Point trip. Clean, spacious, and well maintained. As other reviewers described, it sits between two well maintained motel units. Thanks for letting us stay!

The place is super nice and Joe is super helpful. He gave us some good tips and helped when we needed it. Overall the place is very nice.

Very nice, cozy and comfortable home for staying in Huron and fishing. Driveway accommodates a boat and tow vehicle. Central to fishing out of Port Clinton to Cleveland. Great location and close to Huron boat launch.

From the moment we arrived we just knew this was the perfect place for us to stay for the weekend. The location was perfect. Everything about Exchange of Pace was done with so much thought and love. We are definitely looking forward to coming back next year

Definitely worth the stay!host was helpful and responsive when communicating. The house was very spacious and nice. We enjoyed our stay and plan to come back again soon!

We met up with family to stay on the lake for several days, and it was just perfect. We had 8 adult sized folks, and we fit in just perfectly. The location is just amazing...right on the lake with access to swimming and kayaks. The place felt more roomy than the pictures...there is a really nice sitting room where most of us could sit, plus two screened in porches and plenty of seating outside. Kitchen is extremely well stocked. Central air was key for us and provided a nice respite from the heat. We drove 30 minutes to Cedar Point, and it was close enough that we came home for a few hours to take a break from the heat and went back for the evening. Hosts were just super on it, proactive, and very helpful. Highly recommend. Oh and the outdoor shower really was a highlight. Sounds silly, but we all loved it!

House was beautiful and came with 6 person golf cart. Great area of the island close to everything but yet house was in a quiet street only 1 neighbor down the road. We had the best weekend there!! House newly built all updated its the perfect place to stay. Definitely recommend and planning to go again!!

The house is RIGHT on the beach which was great for our family. The kitchen was even better in person and there was a dryer which we weren't sure of based on the listing. Overall it was a great long weekend for the family.

This was our first trip to Lake Erie and Dwight made us feel right at home abd gave us local tips to enjoy our time. We loved the lake access, the local shops and restaurants, and the spacious and comfy home with tons of extra toys to make the area enjoyable - bikes, games, and beach chairs.

Great place. Very convenient location. The boat launch at the State park is in walking distance and food was close by too.

Such a cool spot — you immediately feel transported to a different place. We found ourselves forgetting we were even in Ohio anymore! It’s also close to everything and there’s a bike path right at the end of the street. Highly recommend!

This is the second time we've stayed here, which says more than anything else. The place was great, just like last time. Noticed some nice updates this time to make the place even better. Literally the only reason not to stay here would be if someone in your party cannot climb stairs or would have difficulty with a bathtub type shower. Aside from that, book with complete confidence.

This property was great! Tricia was so quick to respond, from my booking request through the end of our stay. The home was clean and easy to access. I loved the charm of the house with the dark wood. It was perfectly located so we had easy access to Cedar Point Sports Center, shopping and eating. Would definitely recommend!

Dave and Patrick were awesome hosts! They have thought of everything! My almost 4 year old loved the candy machine and the basket of chips were a hit too. The space was really clean and big enough to accommodate 2 adults, a baby, and 2 kiddos. During our visit, the city lost power in some areas and it affected the rental. They messaged me immediately to let me know what was going on and the estimated time power would be back on. They checked on us several times. They were friendly, responsive, and very helpful. Would definitely recommend staying at their place.

Great simple place for our group. Boat ramps were close. Plenty of parking. No troubles and comfortable.

It was a comfortable, cozy place to stay! We enjoyed sitting around the fire pit on a cold night and walking to Massie Cliffside Preserve early in the morning with our coffee. Would recommend anyone stay here.

great spot on the island. you really get to be in the center of everything and feel entirely alone with full privacy.

What originally started out as a group of 8 fishermen turned into only 4 due to “life happens”. The house was perfect for the 4 of us with everyone getting a bedroom and 3 bathrooms was great!! I know the other 4 would’ve been fine with plenty of room for air mattresses or cots. (That’s what we normally do when we have a bigger group). The house was exactly as described, and all the antiques were cool to look at!! I would definitely recommend Mary Kate’s place!!

No complaints for the price. Very quiet. Easy access would be easier to find in the daylight but instructions are clear so not too difficult even at night. Will stay again if in the area.

I loved this air bnb!!! It’s the perfect location away from the downtown area. Very easy to get to downtown with the $3/person taxi service put in bay offers. The cabin was private and peaceful and slept everyone comfortably.

Clean, quaint, and enjoyable. Thank you!