Cottage vacation rentals in Kelleys Island

Karen’s place is a beautiful location right on the lake! The space was pristine and Karen was so kind and accommodating!

My husband and I absolutely fell in love with this place! Came for our 10 year anniversary. Very responsive hosts. Karen is so friendly and helpful, will let you know all the events going on in the area. Many close wineries. Beautiful scenery. Can see the lake from the property. The hosts even kept the heated pool open for us since it was nice weather, the water temperature was perfect!! Lounged out there for most of the afternoon. And the hot tub is spacious, good working jets, and a nice view of the lake! The hosts are creating a scenic walking trail around a beautiful pond out back, we saw a pair of swans swimming in it and enjoyed lounging while watching them. So many nice touches like snacks, coffee, espresso bar (fully stocked), makeup/cleansing wipes, etc. Everything is new and pristine. Beautiful full kitchen and bar area seating. Hosts have three other similar units on property, this would make a good extended family getaway or girl's weekend. Can't wait to book again!

Loved the placed wish the weather wasn't so bad wouldve enjoyed the hot tube but ill be back to do that lol house was amazing really liked it made me feel at home

We had a great stay at the Love Shack. Perfect for our little family. Close to all local attractions. House was clean and as described. Beds were comfortable. Hosts were very friendly and responsive. We used several of Marty’s and John’s recommendations. Overall, we had a great weekend!

The home was absolutely beautiful, and we had a wonderful stay! Would 100% book this Airbnb again!

We arrived late and left early on our trip cross country, so didn't get to enjoy to beauty of being on this lake, but appreciated the location and the comfortable accomodations.

Karen was a wonderful host! We had a great time. The place was very nice and very clean. I would definitely go back!

Taylor was a very nice and responsive host. However the trash was full at curbside all week which Taylor eventually corrected. Additionally our dog kept finding dirty socks and other items from behind and under couch. The kitchen and bathroom was very cramped for two people and no way adequate for 5-7 people. Multiple junk cars and trucks on surrounding properties. Lakefront access consists of a 6’ area surrounded by boulders. Overall Taylor commented very well.

Melissa was wonderful. Will stay again.

Very peaceful and beautiful Airbnb we stayed at the past weekend. Hosts were quick with responses and very helpful. Would stay again!

What a wonderful host and place! Very cozy and very homey. Worked great for the five of us. Very nice big yard for the dog and kids to run. The place was easy to find and easy access to main roads. And ice cream barn only a mile away!

Joel's place is a charming little cottage. Everything is very simple but you'll find everything you need. Joel went over and above for us, and left beautiful ripe tomatoes from his own garden in the kitchen for us. I was doing some family research on the Island, and Joel himself had some stories about people who had known my family. The volunteers at the Historical Society were super helpful and friendly, too. I had a great weekend on Kelleys Island.

We had a wonderful stay Everything was so clean and the beds were super comfy. The cottage had absolutely everything we needed as far as an equipped kitchen. The fire pit made for a great night of marshmallow roasting. The deck gave great views of the lake and both sunrise and sunsets were beautiful. We would definitely love to come back , in fact we didn’t want to leave!!

I’ve stayed in many VRBO’s throughout the US and this has to be my absolute best experience. David has gone over and above to make you feel right at home. I loved the “coffee bar”. I’m a tea drinker and he had me covered. I usually have to bring my own portable tea kettle and forgot it this time. He totally had me covered from a variety of teas and coffees. I will be back again next year and know exactly where I’ll be staying. What a great little place. Next time I won’t have to pack as much! As a host, David nailed it! Thank you David for the Ohio hospitality! We had such a great time!

This is the perfect location for a family (or 2) that want to spend time near Lake Erie. The house is directly across from the nicest playground I’ve been to! There is also beach access at the park. You’re located a few min from the Jet Express and about 20 min from Millers Ferry if you want to hop over to an island for the day. The house is very cute and charming, we enjoyed coffee on the porch and the kids loved the large upstairs loft!

Host was very helpful and communicated well. They definitely go out of Theile way to make your stay great!

Excellent place to stay for baseball tournament and Cedar Point. Everything in the description is accurate.

The house was very nice and well supplied. The fire pit and red chairs were beautiful. Andrea was very responsive and helpful!

Was a perfect fit for our weekend getaway. Excellent and prompt communication. I captured some amazing scenery photos! Thank you!

I had a fantastic stay at this Airbnb in Marblehead, Ohio! The place was spotless, cozy, and exactly as described. It had all the little touches that made it feel like home—from comfortable beds to a well-stocked kitchen. The location was perfect. Amber went above and beyond to make sure this place was right for me, and her attention to detail truly made the experience special. She was incredibly friendly and responsive, making check-in a breeze and offering great local tips. I’d definitely recommend this spot to anyone visiting the area and would love to stay here again!

Our family really enjoyed our stay in this beautiful home. Janet has thought of everything you might need and we appreciated having both a pack and play and high chair available for the little ones. There were lots of games and activities to keep the kids busy. The house is well equipped and the design is lovely. We will definitely stay here again when we are in the area.

Great stay at Bongo House, gorgeous sunset views, cozy , comfortable cottage with everything you need Anne was quick to respond Would love to return snd would highly recommend

We had two families that stayed at Karen & Jeff’s for our annual trip to Marblehead. It is a gorgeous home, perfect for kids to run and scooter the neighborhood, swim in the pool and play at the beach. Cannot wait to go back!