Cottage vacation rentals in Guilford Lake

Charming stay!! Spotless! The only issues were the knives were very dull they just need sharpened and we thought for the cost, the jets on the hot tub were not strong at all. Otherwise it was very relaxing and much needed!!!!!

From the minute you walk in the door you smell the clean fresh air of a cottage that has been well taken care of and kept very clean. The one reason that we chose this cottage was the extra touches from the decor, to the mint by our bed and the bread and sweet rolls awaiting for us. This is not a cookie cutter place, but a place where someone cares about it and puts in those extra touches and love to make it a relaxing and enjoyable time for the guest who have the privilege of staying at Red Cottage Hideaway. We have stayed in two of the three Cottages and both have been extremely well cared for and very nice.. A huge thank you to those who take care of these beautiful Cottages. Your hard work and care does not go unnoticed.

The little cottage was perfect for a Christmas getaway. Quiet, relaxing, and peaceful. The fireplace adds so much to the space and really ties it together. We would happily book again.

Was a very nice little getaway. Nicely located only a few minutes from town was very convenient. So quiet and peaceful, was very relaxing. Would definitely stay here again.

Brian and Charlene truly went above and beyond as hosts! Their thoughtful recommendations for places to visit and dine made our stay extra special, and they were always quick to answer any questions we had. The cottage was absolutely charming—exactly as described and perfectly suited to our needs. We were greeted by the rambunctious and vocal resident geese, who added such a fun touch to the experience. The ambiance was pure tranquility, and the hot tub offered the most peaceful relaxation, free from any distractions. If you're dreaming of a secluded, rejuvenating getaway, this is the perfect spot for you! From the stunning scenic drive to the five-star hospitality, this trip will stay in your heart forever.

Nice cottage with lake views and awesome porch. Outside space made the vacation for us. Only one of the bathrooms usable for showering because of the low crinkling in basement but were able to work it out fine between the 5 of us. Would stay again

Sunny’s place was amazing, we came up to watch our son play college lacrosse over Easter break. She ensured that we had everything we needed to ensure a big Easter dinner was possible for a group of boys! Our pups loved watching the pond. Sunny’s place is outstanding and a must stay location, we felt very much at home, we will be back soon!

Stephens place was great! We had a nice, quiet, and peaceful weekend away. My husband and I enjoyed the hot tub, fire pit and just being able to have a break from real life. ❤️

A great, quiet little getaway from the daily grind to connect with nature. Semi-stocked fridge, fresh local eggs, fire pit, kayaks, board games, grill. All we needed to bring was our favorite snacks (s'mores ingredients were already there!). The bed was so comfortable and the shower was hot and strong.

We had a great time at Miriam's place. Everything was clean. The beds and couch were so comfortable! If I had a cozy blanket, I could have lounged all day! The countryside was nice and peaceful. The horses didn't wander up but the kids enjoyed the chickens. Miriam's communication was instant and very much appreciated.

Traveled with my wife recently to visit family in Ohio. This cottage was very comfortable and welcoming. Woke up on the second morning to the trees covered with a layer of snow. It was a beautiful winter wonderland, if only for a day. Tim and Melissa were gracious hosts, and check-in/check-out was easy and seamless. When the time came to travel back home...we did not want to leave.

We had a great time. Lots to do in Amish country. House was close to restaurants and Amish theater. Nice size table for playing card games.

We completely enjoyed our stay at Julie’s place! It was home away from home and very relaxing. Thank you for everything…

Really enjoyed the location of the cottage - both the walkability of the local town and proximity to other towns and attractions. The cottage had a good amount of space for us to relax and play games. We particularly liked sitting on the screened in porch.

This is nice little hide away from the world, felt right at home, lots of space and grass for me to play with my dog. Stacy was very helpful, responsive and great host giving instruction before hand and providing items for my pet. Will always stay again in the future.

Beautiful scenery, peaceful, spacious inside home, kids loved the foosball table, pet friendly, very house warming!!!

I can't say enough about this beautiful cottage. The town is adorable, and the decorations are charming. Extremely comfortable beds and relaxing atmosphere. The extra touches like snacks and beverages make this place exceptional. We will definitely be back!

Everything was exactly what was shown. The host was very prompt in response and the follow up was amazing!

We had the privilege of a few months stay. Absolutely everything is as described. Beautiful state of the art appliances down to the toaster. High speed internet that never went out. Many bathroom towels, washer and dryer, pots and pans, dishes flatware and GREAT neighbors. Local restaurants are fabulous to visit or have delivered and not overly priced. A great stay by ALL means. If you can book it I would recommend. ZERO complaints. Thank you Kelli!. Great rental.

Highly recommend this host and home! The location was convenient to all local attractions and views of the lake were nice. We were impressed by the beautiful decor, amount of space, and ALL the thoughtful amenities. This host seriously thought of EVERYTHING! We look forward to visiting again in the future. Thanks for sharing your beautiful home with us—you made a busy soccer weekend very relaxing and enjoyable!!

We are looking forward to spending time here again! Absolutely wonderful!

Another great stay at Greg’s place. Greg continues to be a great host! Would highly recommend for anyone looking for some quality time on lake Milton!

Plenty of seating inside outside for the 6 of us girls who stayed over the weekend. Decent fire pit, nice views, quiet, and private. Comfortable arrangements in the bedrooms with the beds and comfortable furniture in the living areas. Great kitchen for cooking and everything was clean.

Sparrows Nest is stylish, cozy, super clean and surrounded by spectacular views. You won’t want to go leave (just like the owner planned when it was designed and built). Treat yourself to a relaxing stay in the beautiful Ohio rolling hills.