Vacation rentals with a kayak in Goodyear Lake

This Airbnb is completely amazing. It is beautiful. It is spacious. It is great for a group. It comes fully stocked with most of the basic things you need like a fully functional kitchen with things like syrup and jam and all of that in there. The host was completely responsive. If you are planning to go to ski, it is close to the mountain. I completely enjoyed our stay.

We had a wonderful time at Alicia and Jamie’s home in Livingston Manor. The home itself was spacious, tastefully decorated, and comfortable. And the property was fantastic- beautiful and very private yet close to town. Speaking of the town, Livingston Manor is charming and definitely worth exploring, as is nearby Roscoe. Overall a great time. We look forward to returning.

Very nice home tucked away, was perfect for a private weekend for our group. We will absolutely come back if we are in the area again!

Our family vacation at this Airbnb was a truly tranquil getaway! Upon arrival, we were impressed by how spotlessly clean the house was. It was perfectly set up for our group, providing everything we needed. The kitchen was well-equipped, allowing us to cook large family meals effortlessly, and we loved bonding over fun board games and the pool table downstairs. Every morning was made special by waking up to brew fresh coffee while gazing out over the serene lake. The house featured cozy mood lighting throughout, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The beds were extremely comfortable, ensuring we felt rested each day. With multiple fireplaces, ample seating, and blankets available everywhere, it felt like a true home away from home. This stay was exactly what we needed for a perfect family vacation. Highly recommend! ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

We had a lovely stay at Isaac’s place. The house is super cute and cosy with everything you need, great TV and sound system. Issac was very helpful and friendly and the house was easy to find and get into. Peaceful area close to ski slopes and Margaretville. We had the best evening at Ark bowl & bbq.

Another wonderfully relaxing time in this beautiful spot! Weekend highlights included hiking, snowshoeing, lunch at Phoenicia Diner, watching the farm animals and lots of naps! 😃

The house was really well kept, designed and fitted with tons of fun activities. it sits on a gorgeous lake with incredible views! a few bugs of course as you’re so close to nature. marlaina was super responsive even when we had questions early in the morning. we loved staying here and hope we can again!

I travel a lot and I have a particular passion for the Catskills and this location was top of the list of all places I have visited in this Area. We tried our best to be great guests and we cleaned up after ourselves as best we could, so that we may be allowed to visit again in the summer and hopefully many future visits… Thanks again Susanna for sharing your wonderful and amazing lake house…

I was looking for a very autumnal place to rest with my family for my husband’s birthday I invited my friends to accompany us all they loved the location the landscape the super clean cosy spacious house

Wesley was a phenomenal host, beautiful home, extremely clean and comfortable! He checked in with us, making sure all was well during a snowfall, and offering a generator if the power were to go out! The kitchen was well equipped, the beds were comfortable and there were many other little extras like games, snacks, some drinks and all the cleaning supplies you might need. If we ever visit Cooperstown again, I would definitely stay at Wesley’s house a second time! Thank you for making our stay great!

Matthew’s home was amazing! For a relaxing time on the water and enjoying time away from city traffic, this is the place to be! Matthew was communicative, flexible and very friendly. The house was clean, neat, and cozy. Will be back soon! Thank you!

Beautiful location with lakeside view. Such a peaceful and cozy home. We had everything we could have needed - canoe, kayaks, bikes etc. 20 minutes from Cooperstown Dreams Park. Absolutely gorgeous. One of my most memorable vacation spots. Highly recommend.

What a wonderful place—cozy, warm, and incredibly inviting. Our hosts went above and beyond to make us feel welcome, even texting us weather updates when it started snowing to make sure we were safe. Their thoughtfulness really stood out. We truly enjoyed our stay and are already thinking of coming back in the summer to experience the beautiful countryside in a different season. A solid 10/10—highly, highly recommend!

A group of friends and family visited for a weekend ski trip, and both the adults and children had an incredible time. The property was absolutely perfect for a family getaway, offering everything we needed for a comfortable stay. While the downstairs shower was a bit misty and soft, both upstairs shower booths were compact but provided strong water pressure. Overall, we thoroughly enjoyed our stay and will definitely consider staying here again in the future.

Debra and Mike were great hosts and have created a very warm, inviting and comfortable place for those seeking to explore the Catskills. It's a home away from home! There's a grill available which we made great use of, a fire pit to enjoy nature and star gazing, and their two dogs Luna and Roxy are extremely friendly. Highly recommend their place!

We had a lovely stay at Sandy’s cabin! It was spacious, bright, peaceful, relaxing, and well equipped. We were able to enjoy sunrise over the water while drinking coffee each morning before venturing out to wineries and Cooperstown. It was a perfect balance! Sandy was a good communicator and was always available for questions and recommendations. She asked our permission to have someone stop over to repair the fireplace during our stay- she was receptive when we declined for him to come in the morning and helped coordinate the repairs for while we were out for the day. We were surprised to find the cabin located quite close to neighboring cabins, but all the neighbors were friendly and quiet so it made no difference to us. We enjoyed our weekend thoroughly!

We enjoyed the peace and quiet while staying. It was wonderful for star gazing and the fireplace was lovely.

I recently had the pleasure of staying at Dino’s Black Bear Cabin. The cabin is private and peaceful, such a nice getaway from the city. The furniture is comfortable, linens soft and kitchen fully stocked with spices and basic ingredients. Loved the unique basement speakeasy and jacuzzi. The cabin had everything we needed. The views of the lake and surrounding woods were breathtaking, providing a peaceful atmosphere to unwind. The host was exceptional—thoughtful, responsive, and always willing to help with any questions we had. Their attention to detail truly made a difference in our stay. Overall, the stay was an amazing stay. We hope to stay again and again. I would buy this place if it was for sale!! 10 out of 10 would recommend!

This is a great stay! Meghan has been a such amazing host. Her place is clean and well maintained. All appliances are top quality. The yard is the cherry on the top! It also connected to a state forest if you would love to have a little hiking experience. Will definitely check out during summer time again.

Had a great time at the cozy cabin. It's a cabin but still has some nice amenities. Location is somewhat close to road, you can hear occasional cars go by. Still, back by the pond it feels like being away from it all. I had a blast hiking local trails and enjoying the foliage.

Ivan's place emulated a YouTube cozy winter jazz 12 hour video. It had everything you ever needed to feel relaxed and at peace. There were antique fire places inside the home, the house was made out of wood, it was clean and stylish. The location was great , facing the lake and mountains. It was a great place to disconnect and get away from all the noise. The town was 10 min away where you can get anything from wine to coffee to produce. Really grateful to the host for creating such a nourishing space and sharing it with the world. Thank you Ivan!

Everything is perfect and has a nice view. The owner is very kind and all the services provided by the house are excellent. We loved it. We will be back in July for my birthday.

This was my second time staying here, I love it and the location. I was happy to bring my wife with me this trip and she loved it too. We’re already planning the next time we go.

My husband and I spent Thanksgiving at the cabin and it was perfect . We unexpectedly got snowed in with 8+ inches and it was magical. I highly recommend a winter visit. We managed ok on the road without at AWD vehicle, but if I'd known we'd have winter conditions I would have rented one. The cabin has a well-appointed kitchen and the pellet stove keeps everything very cozy. We spent our days walking nearby trails and evenings streaming old movies on the the projector. My dog was over the moon. Heather is so kind and very responsive to any questions throughout the visit. Thanks so much for a wonderful stay.