Vacation rentals in Bimini Bay

Waterfront, Heated Pool, Elevator, Fire Pit, Dock

Escape to The Blue Ark, a 3-story home inspired by Noah’s Ark. Families will love this peaceful retreat, blending luxury and comfort. Discover the island's only natural lagoon, boasting stunning views, manatee and occasional dolphin sightings! Unwind by the heated pool, fish from the dock, or take an easy 4-5 minute walk to the beach. End the day with a drink by the fire pit on the top deck, watching the sunset. The Blue Ark has an elevator, 3 bedrooms + extra sleep space, 8 beds and 4.5 baths.

Limited Availably w/ Private Boat Dock & 30' Pool

✨ 4.95★ GUEST FAVORITE! Canal Front & 1/2 Block to Beach Experience the ultimate AMI getaway! This 4.95-star tropical oasis features a wide canal with a 30' boat/fishing dock, a massive 16'x30' private pool, and is just a 1/2 block to the beach. Walk to everything:• 3-min walk to Bay Beach, 15 to Bean Point• Steps to Pine Ave shopping & City Pier• Stroll to Waterfront Restaurant & Two Scoops. Bring your boat, lounge poolside, or hit the sand. Perfect island living with 200+ rave reviews!

Heated Pool, Hot Tub, Game Room, Steps to Beach!

Welcome to Island Dreams, the ultimate peaceful escape just 4 min walk from Anna Maria Island's stunning beaches. This fully renovated three-bedroom, three-bath beach house features a Zen-inspired backyard oasis, a private cocktail pool, and a game room! Walk to shops, restaurants, and the trolley stop! Island Dreams offers the perfect blend of relaxation, location, and indoor and outdoor fun! NOTE: Holmes Beach has a 7-day rental minimum. Check in / Check out days are on Saturdays.

Gulf Front! Sunset Deck! + Walk to Bridge St Pier!

🌊🏄Welcome to The Surof House - where panoramic views of the Gulf of Mexico welcome you from almost every corner! 🏖️Experience the ultimate beachfront retreat at this unique & stunning property nestled across from one of the top beaches in the world. A perfect blend of luxury, comfort, & unparalleled views awaites. With an upstairs loft featuring 3 single beds & 2 downstairs rooms with king beds, it's an ideal getaway for families, friends, or anyone seeking a slice of paradise.

Lux Spa Retreat•Pool•Hot Tub•Sauna•10 min to Beach

You asked, we delivered. Inspired by our Top 1% listing and consistent 5⭐ stays at “The Tiny Oasis”, Haus De Noir is a moody, boutique 3BR/3BA retreat with Plunge Pool, Hot Tub, Sauna, Outdoor Cinema and More! Slip into the Midnight Kafana, your own after-hours Hideaway Bar with Karaoke, Lights, and Late-Night energy. Fully stocked with everything you need and then some! Family-Owned and Managed! We don’t just host we LOVE what we do! Just 10 mins to Indian Rocks & Madeira Beach🏝️.

Modern 4BR Home *Heated Pool & Spa*

Discover elegance in this centrally located Sarasota gem, featuring four bedrooms and two bathrooms to accommodate up to eight guests. Enjoy a laid-back vibe while lounging at Sarasota's beaches or immersing yourself in local attractions. Siesta Beach and Lido Beach are within easy reach at 7.6 and 6.4 miles respectively. Rest easy knowing commitment to cleanliness aligns with your travel priorities. Your serene vacation awaits in this beautifully adorned home. VR24-00265

Ocean Air Oasis-New Centrally Located AMI Luxury

Immerse yourself in coastal luxury at this exceptional 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom custom home, where opulent high-end finishes and stunning pecky cypress floors adorn every nook. Revel in the impeccable features, including Sub-Zero and Wolf appliances, marble countertops, Shaw’s sinks, and exquisite custom woodworking, all bathed in abundant natural light. This delightful space offers panoramic views of the lavish backyard, complete with a heated pool and spa.

83rd St Villas East by Duncan Real Estate

Welcome to The 83rd St Villas East! A stunning ground-level vacation villa just a 6-minute walk from the beach! With two bedrooms and two bathrooms, this rental sleeps up to six guests. You and your guests can sit back, relax, watch movies, and connect over effortless conversations in the living area. Top of the range, fully equipped kitchen with Café appliances, ample counter space, cook top and oven, extra-large fridge/freezer making meal prep a breeze.

2BR | Oceanfront, Backyard Beach, Fully Equipped

Experience luxury coastal living at Indian Shores in this beautifully appointed beachfront retreat at Sunplace. Featuring 2 spacious bedrooms with a king and queen bed, plus a full-size roll-out bed and Pack ’n Play, this fully equipped condo is perfect for families and groups. Enjoy direct beach access, stunning Gulf surroundings, resort-style amenities, and easy access to local dining, shops, and nearby Clearwater Beach.

L'Oasis East w/Dip Pool

Completely remodeled, this beautifully 2-bedroom duplex, crafted to enhance your living experience. Every detail has been thoughtfully designed to create a serene and inviting atmosphere. New images showcase this stunning transformation, come visit us to see the beauty in person! Additionally, West and East are now available for rent together, featuring convenient adjoining doors through the utility room.

The Boathouse

Would you like to feel like you are sleeping in a tree house with all the luxuries and comfort of a high end hotel? Then welcome to our brand new guest house, which accommodates a maximum of two guests and is a completely private tropical oasis. Standing on the edge of Lake LaVista, surrounded by tropical palms where you have use of the private and beautiful pool which we heat during the winter months.

NEW! Meet Me At Sunset! 3 Homes from the Beach!

🌅 Meet Me at Sunset is a 4BR/4.5BA beach-boho villa just 3 homes from the Gulf 🌊. Enjoy a heated pool & spa, private balconies, ping pong 🏓, outdoor grill 🍽️, and dog-friendly stays 🐾. Walk to Pine Avenue shops & dining 🛍️, hop on the AMI trolley 🚎, or bike the island 🚲. Beach chairs & cart provided 🏖️. Perfect for families or friends seeking the ultimate Anna Maria Island getaway ☀️🍹.