Vacation rentals in Apple Valley Lake

This place was just what we needed. We rented this place following a death in the family locally and we needed somewhere for family to gather and be together. This house and the property was everything we could ask for. Quiet. Peaceful. Spacious enough to allow for individual space when needed. The property is beautiful. The house has character and comfort. The hosts have stocked EVERYTHING a person could need. And it has an amazing vibe and history. It felt to all of us that there has been much love and laughter in this historic home which is just what we needed. Thank you for hosting us.

Great place to stay in Millersburg! Our large family had plenty of room, the house is beautiful and perfectly located. Andrea was very helpful, and everything was exactly as described in the listing.

Jody is the perfect host! He was quick to respond if we had a question, and was so kind and great to work with! The house itself is beautiful… Very clean and spacious! If you’re looking for a comfortable home away from home, this is it! Thank you so much, Jody! We really appreciate all that you did to accommodate us!

Super cute house! Great getaway, we all felt right at home! Two adults and six kids and we didn't try to kill each other once! That beanbag chair was absolutely the favorite!

We were so fortunate and grateful to stumble upon this beautiful and well maintained gem of a home in Mt. Vernon. This was the perfect halfway point for our family of 6 as we headed back to NY. We immediately felt right at home and were blown away by the generous hospitality that we were provided with from the coffee station, to the treats and beverages, and thoughtful note and information provided. The only regret we had was not being able to spend more time here to enjoy the comforts of this special home and to explore all that the charming town had to offer.

Our weekend getaway at the lakehouse with friends was nothing short of perfect. The house itself was cozy, well maintained, and had everything we needed the hot tub and the lake access were extremely enjoyable highlights of our time there. Additionally, Alan is simply the best host possible, he was extremely accommodating and went above and beyond to ensure our stay was enjoyable. It is our second time staying at Alan’s place and we can’t wait to stay there again!

What a great place to call home while exploring the Mohican State Park amenities and the surrounding towns. We were able to eat most of our meals in our rental, including the great Amish breakfast treats left by Richard. The fresh flowers were also a real treat as we were celebrating our 54th Wedding anniversary. Thanks for everything Richard!

We always love coming here for a little getaway. House is always beautiful and clean. Katie is always very responsive when I message her.