Tilloo Cay vacation rentals

Book unique vacation rentals, houses, and more on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Tilloo Cay

Guests agree: these vacation rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Guest favorite

Condo in Marsh Harbour

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews

Condo on Bay Street at Regattas

Experience the ultimate island getaway in this stunning condo located on the island of Abaco! This is the perfect place to relax and unwind! The condo features modern decor, comfortable furnishings, and plenty of natural light. Guests will have access to a fully equipped kitchen and stylish living areas. Whether you're looking for a romantic retreat or a fun-filled family vacation, this condo has everything you need for an unforgettable stay. Book now and start planning your dream island escape!

Top guest favorite

Villa in Marsh Harbour

5 out of 5 average rating, 31 reviews

Brand NEW Oceanfront Villa with protected dockage

MERMAID COVE is a BRAND-NEW one bedroom open plan waterfront Villa directly on the Sea of Abaco. Includes a 50-foot private protected dock. Spectacular 400 sq ft outdoor lower deck with stairs that lead directly into the ocean and a huge upper covered patio and deck. Our luxurious villa with outdoor living is the ideal private getaway for a couple looking for a picture perfect location with all the amenities. Kayak, paddle board and snorkel without leaving the property (Equipment included).

Superhost

Villa in Treasure Cay

4.79 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews

Treasure Cay Beach Villa Oasis - Paradise Awaits

This villa located in the heart of Treasure Cay is a 2 minute walk from one of the top 10 beaches in the world! This two bedroom, two bath is the perfect place to enjoy deep sleep and enjoy your time in Paradise. Want to rent for a month? Book our monthly rental specials! We welcome extended getaways in Paradise. The Bahama Beach Club, a Cafe and grocery store are all located a short golf cart ride away. Dive deep into the water and enjoy your vacation in our home away from home!

Guest favorite

Villa in Treasure Cay

5 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

Surf Shack on the Beach Ocean Front Villa

Your own private beach! 1 of 7 Villa's in this community with private beach. Starlink high speed internet with out interruptions for workcations. Kid friendly rental games, toys, books, etc. Take it easy at this unique and tranquil getaway. Direct Ocean Front villa Newly renovated Granite countertops, air conditioning, king size master Beautiful bathrooms Tile throughout High speed Starlink Satellite Fully stocked kitchen including spices and acompaniments. Brand new......!

Superhost

Villa in AB-22134, Great Abaco Island

4.78 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

🌺VILLA SOFIA🌺 TreasureCayParadise🌴Fully Sanitized

Paradise is here! Turquoise water and white powdery sand make this amazing beach ranked top 10 beaches in the world by National Geographic. Take a break and unwind at this peaceful oasis. 2 bedrooms 2 baths ( 1 king and 1 queen bedroom ) few steps from the Treasure Cay Beach which was ranked top 10 beaches in the world. Completely renovated after hurricane Dorian Close to Bahamas Beach Club restaurant, excursions, gold cart rentals, clinic, grocery store, Florence cafe’, pool

Superhost

Apartment in Marsh Harbour

4.5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Tranquility Hideaway Villas (Villa Love)

Newly renovated one bedroom apartment centrally located. Amenities include everything to make you feel right at home. Spacious kitchen with full stove, microwave, refrigerator, coffee pot and toaster. Sit at the large granite countertop and enjoy conversation while your meal is being prepared. Large open living area with a cozy ambiance. Fully equipped with washer and dryer for your use. Additional bedding and towels are provided. Ask about our car rental options.

Superhost

Home in Green Turtle Cay

4.8 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Tropical Comfort: Lillian's Ground Level Oasis

Bright and Spacious Downstairs Unit with Ocean Views Wake up to breathtaking views of the Atlantic Ocean each morning! Step into a brightly colored family room that opens up to a fully-equipped kitchen, featuring a complete suite of LG stainless steel appliances—perfect for any chef. Sip your morning coffee on the deck, or gather with friends and family for al fresco dining as you enjoy the island breeze. Please note: This listing is for the Downstairs Unit ONLY.

Top guest favorite

Cottage in Green Turtle Cay

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 76 reviews

Maranatha Cottage, Green Turtle Cay - Harbour View

Bright, breezy, coastal cottage located in the main village of New Plymouth. Originally built in the late 1860s but completely renovated and modern. Situated on the main shore road with a view of the beautiful harbour. Minutes away from restaurants, grocery stores and the beaches. Air conditioned throughout, main bed and bath downstairs, second bedroom (twin beds, air mattress or convertible to a King upon request.) with full shower and bathroom upstairs.

Guest favorite

Apartment in Casuarina Point

5 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Oceanfront Cottage on stunning Casuarina Point

This oceanfront cottage boasts breathtaking views right on the beautiful beach of Casuarina Point. "Sunset Cottage" is one of two units in this beachfront duplex. Fall asleep to the sound of waves and spend your days in the sun and sand. We can connect you with local guides for deep sea or bone fishing and we are happy to share of favorite restaurants and day trip ideas. Maximum occupancy: 2 adults and 1 child under 12.

Superhost

Home in Green turtle cay

5 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Lo key Villa

Lo key Villa -the name says it all.If you are looking for a relaxing , comfortable vacation rental home right on the beach, it doesn't get any better than this . We designed Lo Key Villa to showcase the natural beauty of Coco Bay , a pristine strip of sand that's perfect for swimming, snorkeling,and kayaking as a family. Multiple porches and sun decks overlook the white beach and sparkling turquoise waters.

Superhost

Villa in AB-22134, Great Abaco Island

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews

Sea Spray Ocean Villa 915

If your dates are showing booked message me I have 3 villas. We have several bookings with regular clients that book with me personally. Local restaurants open include Cafe La Florence, Bahama Beach Club Pool Bar, Bahama Beach Club Pavillon, Sunset Pizza. Get groceries at Maxwells in Marsh Harbour before traveling to Treasure Cay. This is the place to feel blessed, not stressed.

Superhost

Villa in Treasure Cay

4.76 out of 5 average rating, 41 reviews

“Ocean Pearl” Ocean Villa 923

Ocean Pearl is located in a beautiful, private resort in Treasure Cay at the Ocean Villas. Just a few steps from Treasure Cay beach which is ranked one of the Top 10 beaches in the World by The National Geographic. Relax, Breathe and Unwind with us in our newly renovated Villa.

0 of 0 items showing

What guests are saying

Canal Front Home in Treasure Cay w/Dock, Generator

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews4 months ago

This is an amazing place! Great lay out, plenty of room for our family of five. Well-equipped kitchen super easy to cook at home. The back balcony offers a wonderful view of the canal. Easy walking distance to incredible beaches. Enjoyed dinner at the Beach Club and breakfast at Florence's. We loved our stay in Treasure Cay!

Home in Treasure Cay

What guests are saying

Blue Wave Dreamin' Ocean Villas

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews2 weeks ago

Tommy’s place in Treasure Cay is ideal. The home is equipped with everything you need, and then some. The location is perfect, close to the pool and steps away from the beautiful beach. Tommy is the consummate host … very responsive every step of the way, helpful when we needed him. He greeted us when we arrived to welcome and orient us. He provided recommendations on delicious restaurants and fun day adventures. We will definitely be staying there on our next trip to Abaco.

Home in Treasure Cay

What guests are saying

Treasure Time

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews1 day ago

Our family had the best time staying here in Treasure Cay! The condo was adorable and very clean and stocked with everything we needed. The dock slip was perfect for our boat. We loved walking across the street to Bahama Beach Club and even played pickleball on the nearby courts. All of the neighbors were super friendly as well. We can’t wait to stay again on our next trip!

Apartment in Treasure Cay

What guests are saying

Top Deck Cottage-taxes included in rate

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews1 month ago

It's an unbeatable location. The view outside the slider door looks fake, but it is so perfect. It's a quiet area of the island but a 3-minute walk to the Abaco Inn for breakfast, dinner, or drinks. Be sure to reserve a golf cart ahead of time. There's lots to see on the gorgeous island. Jon's place has a full-size refrigerator and light cooking amenities, but getting to and from the market with water, etc., will require that golf cart. If you're a laid-back person or couple, this spot is ideal. You can lounge on the porch or stroll the beach, disconnect, and relax in paradise. The bed is comfortable, the place is clean. However, if you are a high-maintenance human that needs to be connected to reliable internet and perfect cooling temperatures, this is not the place for you.

Cottage in Elbow Cay

What guests are saying

"Little Shack Of Treasure". Beautiful Efficiency

4.78 out of 5 average rating, 18 reviews1 month ago

We loved our stay at Benjamin's. The villa is just what you need for a short low-key trip away. The only knock is the bed was soft and (not our personal preference) and the shower has a small water heater so you have to be quick. We absolutely loved our stay and will be back!

Vacation home in Treasure Cay

What guests are saying

Beach Villa Baby Steps

4.86 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews1 month ago

We loved Reagan’s place. It was perfect for our family of 4. It’s beautifully remodeled and decorated. The beds and pillows were super comfy, and the home is very clean. Treasure Cay is absolutely gorgeous! A candle was provided for when the power goes out which I understand is common on the island.

Home in Treasure Cay

What guests are saying

On famous Treasure Cay Beach !

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews2 months ago

Robert’s place was better than the pictures! It was a perfect set up for a small group (4 adults and 2 kids). Had all the amenities of home plus a beautiful ocean to wake up to every day, kayaks, life jackets, volleyball net, etc. the island itself is still rebuilding, but it was so peaceful and the restaurant at Bahama Beach Club had great food for a night out. Also was an easy drive to the ferry over to green turtle where the kids were ecstatic to swim with the turtles. Would highly recommend!!

Home in Treasure Cay

What guests are saying

Villa in Paradise-Limited Time New Owner Discount!

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 60 reviews4 months ago

We had an absolutely wonderful stay at Treasure Cay!!! The house was nice and clean, had a nicely stocked kitchen for cooking, and was a short walk from the (gorgeous!!!) beach. We were there toward the end of November and it was a quiet neighborhood which is what we prefer. We took some snorkel gear but appreciated having more sets there as well as life vests for four. Our host gave tips before we got there about the area attractions which was helpful. He was also quickly responsive to any questions we had. When we inadvertently left the lights on in our rental car and had a drained battery Brian was understanding and helpful and soon had someone show up with a charger. It's a laidback area with friendly people, we spent hours walking and sitting by the beautiful water. Check out Florence's Cafe, and take a ferry or boat to some of the nearby cays. We explored Green Turtle and Elbow Cay/Hopetown lighthouse. The long dock in Cherokee is also worth visiting. 10/10 recommend!!!

Villa in Treasure Cay

What guests are saying

Beach Attitudes - Relaxing 2 Bedroom Villa

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 42 reviews3 weeks ago

Amazing stay at Efains's villa. Very well appointed villa that it's very clean. We totally felt at home. The kitchen is well equipped with everything one needs - it even has basic spices, coffee, tea, etc. Villa is nicely outfitted and beautifully decorated. Location is great - steps to the beach. Efains is very responsive in case you need anything. Appliances are practically new and beds are comfortable. Will be back again for sure! Thank you Efains and Betty - great gob!

Vacation home in Treasure Cay

What guests are saying

Entire Home Near Marsh Harbour, South Abaco Island

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews1 month ago

A hard place to leave!! What a surreal experience. The beach alone was exceptionally beautiful, almost hard to find the words to capture its essence. 3 Palms was immaculate inside and cozy while offering the sought after beachy vacation vibes. Michele was beyond helpful in every way. From valuable and accurate information, to her response time and truly taking an interest in ensuring we arrived safely and enjoyed our stay. Cannot wait to book here again, next time will stay a little bit longer!

Home in Marsh Harbour

1 of 12 pages