Cottage vacation rentals in Sunset Bay

Our family really enjoyed Elena’s place. It was cozy, clean and exactly as described. The deck was wonderful and close access to the lake and beach were great features. Elena offered for us to leave later on our last day and this allowed us to really maximize our last day of vacation. Wonderful experience!

This was an amazing place to spend couple of days. Safe neighborhood, gorgeous place and very peaceful. Kirk was very responsive and good with communication.

Thanks John and Darlene for the amazing stay and going above and beyond for looking after us during the winter storm. I highly recommend this place

We just returned from a perfect spring break getaway in Derby, NY, just outside of Hamburg, and we’re already missing it! The neighborhood was peaceful and quiet, with partial views of the lake that made sunrises and sunsets feel extra special. The hot tub was definitely a highlight—so relaxing and totally worth it! We were also so grateful that our dog Frankie was welcomed. The fenced-in yard gave him the freedom to roam, sniff, and unwind right alongside us. Our daughters loved having their own bedrooms (and their own TVs!), and the streaming subscriptions included were a great touch for cozy evenings in. The home was beautifully maintained, thoughtfully stocked, and we felt so welcomed from the moment we arrived. Truly wonderful superhosts—thank you for sharing your space with us! We’d love to come back!

Alissa and Jeff were great hosts and their home was a reflection of that. It matched the description, photos, and location shown on the listing. Alissa was very responsive and went above and beyond to help me plan a surprise for my wife. Cannot overstate enough how helpful and responsive she was. The house was very clean and we felt right at home. The kitchen and amenities worked perfectly for all the use we gave them. Hot tub worked and was clean. Loved the short walk to the water and the view of the lake from the living room! Any negative comments were really just nitpicks at this point and not worth bringing up. 5/5, would definitely stay here again!

Not our first time booking with Lauren. We have stayed in a few locations within Sherkston Shores. This unit is absolutely top notch! High end amenities. Beautiful place! Highly recommend and Lauren is a great host!

Paul is a great host. Very knowledgeable & helpful. Walked us through house instructions clearly. The cottage is great, ambience is magnificent and everything is just a 5 to 10 mins walk away or even better, charge & take the golf cart! It’s a nice ride to the beach or to the soccer field where most of the evening events occur. Definitely coming back to this place.

Great place. Very comfortable would definitely recommend. Having the hot tub was such a nice addition to the place. Elisabeth was amazing for my entire experience

Megan was very easy to communicate and the place itself was amazing. It was quite peaceful and easy to find. As we entered the house it was spotless and clean. It was quite and as the sun set each evening you would have amazing views. We were also able to enjoy the morning sunrise views. The house and the amenities itself were as described and it was tastefully decorated. The sun room was an amazing place to lounge. There were plenty of linens and essentials and the kitchen was stocked with every possible amenity needed. There was plenty of drinking water and coffee for 2 adults. The bed was comfortable and the blackout shades helped as well. Megan was proactive and sent out the instructions in advance which definitely helped. Would surely go back to her place sometime again probably once in the peak of summer and once in the peak of the winter months enjoy the views. Thank you Megan.

This is an quaint older little place on a very large serene and beautiful easy-to-navigate property with so much character. The home itself was very clean, incredibly well-stocked, tastefully decorated and furnished, and felt like home. The owners or management were available by message if I needed anything but give you space to enjoy your stay which I greatly appreciated. The location was incredibly convenient and easy to find. My dogs loved being walked on such a huge parcel of land and I loved being able to walk out the door and have so much yard to enjoy with them! I hope to stay here again sometime!

Very clean and comfortable home. Holly provided everything needed. We have stayed in many places…this one had the best stocked kitchen!

We had an amazing stay and cannot wait to go back! My husband, I and our 2.5 year old fell in love with Anne-Marie's place and all of us were sad to leave. The place is clean, beautifully decorated, with all of the amenities you need. It is a very short walk to the beautiful white sand beach and to lots of restaurants, cafes, ice cream and little shops. We also loved that her place is dog-friendly so our old chocolate lab was also able to enjoy the vacation with us. We walked down to the beach each day (it's so awesome that beach passes are included as well), had so much fun playing in the sand and swimming in the warm, clear water that you can walk out far in. We also tried some of the local restaurants and enjoyed all of our meals. And of course, when in a beach town, you have to eat ice cream! We were there on a Thursday so also enjoyed the weekly food-truck festival with live music. Such a beautiful outdoor setting. We will be back next year!

Beautiful lake setting even for a rainy March weekend. Did get to enjoy fire on the 1 dry evening. Seating for meals was limited but outside table would help in warmer months. Also lower level bedrooms could be warmer. Loved the decor of old school local items.

Our stay was great! We were just passing through but it had everything we needed to be comfortable, plus more! The bed was incredibly comfortable and everything was very clean and easy to find. We would definitely stay again.

Ray and Patty were accessible even though we had no issues or need to contact them. The little treats and breakfast items were a nice touch. We would stay there again.

Cute house! We loved our stay. And it was very nice to be able to do laundry there too.

Great place for a family getaway, with a splendid tranquil environment. Not far away from basic amenities, with a public park within 5 min of walking distance having tennis, pickleball, volleyball and horse riding facilities. A bee farm is also walking distance, where one can get delicious organic honey. The house is quite spacious with numerous patios and sitting areas with spectacular views to suit individuals’ tastes. Restaurants and market place is 20 min drive, and Niagara falls a 30 min drive. The host Teri, was quite friendly and accommodating.

This is a wonderful place to stay with your family. It has a beautiful large lot and a bunkie in the back. We would definitely return.

This cottage was absolutely beautiful, clean, and had everything we needed. The host was very responsive and helpful. I highly recommend this place for a relaxing stay!

This cottage blew my expectations. I came here for a peaceful retreat and I got that and more. Check in, was very easy, the house was clean, the location was great and the views were mind blowing. This cottage backs on to Lake Erie and waking up every morning to the sound of waves and the beautiful view leaves you speechless. Tracey was a great host. She had clear instructions with ample information about the area and most importantly she was quick to answer any questions. I would definitely recommend this cottage to anyone who is looking for a peaceful get away. Thanks again Tracey for your lovely hospitality!

We love this house and location. This is our 3rd or 4th time here. There are lots of lovely personal touches that makes it a home away from home. Also Hai is a lovely host and always responsive. Thank you Hai! We will be back in 2025 😀

Our stay was absolutely fantastic. Our host was communicative and answered all of our questions immediately. A great time at the beach making memories that will last a lifetime!

We had a wonderful stay for our girls weekend!!! Tami was very helpful with questions we had! Can’t wait to come back! Thank you so much!

We absolutely loved our time at Anu’s lakeside cottage. We felt right at home. The lake was gorgeous and sounded like the ocean. The waves never stopped and the wind kept the bugs away. We enjoyed our evenings around the fire and bbq’d every night. The stars didn’t disappoint, there was very little light pollution! Oh and the sunsets were amazing. The cottage was homey, yet spacious and very comfortable. We slept so well, and it was great having a spare room for the two pack’n plays for our twins. It was our first getaway as a family of four and we hope to book there again next year!