Vacation rentals in Sunset Bay

Lake-View Cottage for 4 · Wine Tasting Included

Welcome to Fisherman’s Cottage; a cozy retreat with gorgeous lake views from the enclosed front porch and open-air back deck- perfect for catching a breathtaking sunset. Spend some time enjoying a complimentary wine tasting at nearby 21 Brix and return to comfortable furnishings, a fully equipped kitchen, and an efficient bath complete with a spa tub. Rent alone or pair with our newly renovated Mainstay cottage next door for extra space- ideal for families or groups seeking a peaceful getaway.

Location · Family · Amenities

Cozy Bay Getaway

Soak up the modern & vintage charm of this 1 bedroom independant apartment attached to our 160 yr old charming home by the bay. Queen sized temperpedic adjustable bed in the bedroom . Original modern an vintage artwork. 2 large screen TV's Wifi Fluffy bathtowels body soap. Full small but complete kitchen . Bottled water. pots & pans. Dishes cutlery glass ware. Walk to eaterys grocery pharmacy . 5 min drive to Sunset bay beach & beach club. Perfect getaway for a couple that needs to unwind

Value · Location · Comfort

Charming Cottage by the Lake

This quaint, well-maintained cottage is a perfect getaway to the beach. Located a short walk down a private drive to our community lake access, it has a fully fenced backyard and patio with grill, three bedrooms, well-appointed, updated eat-in kitchen, charming dining room, cozy living room with working fireplace, and a comfortable family room. You are five minutes from Evangola State Park, and close to Sunset Bay, SUNY Fredonia, Brooks Memorial Hospital, and Frank Lloyd Wright's Graycliff.

Value · Family · Check-in

Lake Lounge Lakefront property.

Welcome to the Lake Lounge. Vacation rental with 2 queen bedroom 2 bathrooms. Sleeper sofa in basement. Also air mattress. Enjoy the serene views of Lake Erie through the 15 Foot sliding glass doors. Start your day with an espresso on the deck or sitting cozy in front of the fireplace.Lake Erie beach park (less than two mins) City of Buffalo (23 miles) Bills Stadium (27 miles) Niagara Falls/casino (45 miles)Close to Evangola State Park and Sunset Bay. Restaurant/bars Stroh’s at the Lake

Family · Location · Outdoor spaces

Lotus Bay Cabin- all seasons oasis

*8-person stand alone hot tub open Dec.-April* *In-ground pool with spill over hot tub & pool house open May 1st, 2026* Winter, Spring is that you? A drink in the above ground hot tub (or pool & hot tub), meals in the fully stocked kitchen, movies on the spacious sectional, reading in the sunroom, bomb-fires under the dark sky & gorgeous sunsets, walks and seasonal swimming along Lake Erie…simply cannot go wrong! Wine country, beaches, ski resorts, Buffalo & Niagara Falls all nearby

Location · Value · View

Waterview Cottage

Welcome to our Waterfront Boutique Resort nestled on the picturesque shores of Lake Erie, where tranquility meets adventure. Our idyllic property is a haven for those seeking both luxurious relaxation and exhilarating outdoor experiences. With its own 400 feet of sandy beach Hideaway Bay Resort offers a unique blend of natural beauty, modern comforts, and endless opportunities for fun and relaxation. Indulge in the convince of an onsite restaurant and bar, creating the perfect getaway.

Family · Location · Indoor spaces

Blue Canoe/Upscale Lake Cottage/Chautauqua

Welcome to Blue Canoe Lake Cottage on Cassadaga Lakes! This small, 2 Queen Bedroom/1 Full Bath, newly renovated, open-concept, light-filled cottage offers 125 ft of private waterfront, a gated covered porch, & thoughtful details throughout. Enjoy 2 kayaks, 2 paddle boards, a pedal boat, 4 adult cruiser bikes, fire pit, & propane grill. Dog-friendly & perfect for up to 4 adults — luxury on the lake awaits! If booked, check out our sister property, Blue Oar (4BR/3BA, lakefront!

Value · Family · Layout

Peaceful waterfront paradise

Take it easy at this remodelled, well stocked, peaceful, family friendly, vacation spot. Fish, swim, kayak, golf, visit wineries or just watch nature. Located in Sunset Bay, a beautiful sandy beach on Lake Erie, 10 minute walk away. This is a beach community, during the summer it is very active, two beach bars in the bay. There are boat launches nearby. Trains pass nearby, which may disturb your sleep. This area is 40-50 min. drive to the Buffalo/Niagara Falls area.

Value · Family · Checkout

Island Cabin - The Paddle Inn

Abundant privacy is yours at this Island paradise on beautiful Cassadaga Lakes. Accessible by an arched bridge or boat, the cottage is brand new inside and out, is environmentally friendly, provides endless outdoor adventure and a charming interior. Fish from the back deck, swim in crystal clear lake water, relax on the covered porch, and enjoy boundless nature literally at your fingertips, in this very unique setting.

Location · Family · Access

The Little Cabin | Near Wineries & Beach | Hiking

Escape to The Little Cabin on Old Main Road, a cozy rustic retreat tucked away in the woods of Silver Creek, NY. Surrounded by trees and peaceful nature, it’s the perfect place to unplug, unwind, and slow down. Whether you're here to sip your way through local vineyards, reconnect with nature, or simply enjoy a quiet getaway, this cabin has everything you need for comfort, warmth, and relaxation.

Family · Location · Accuracy

Small Beach Bungalow

A small little bungalow/cottage that has all the basics you need for a beach vacation. Located within a 2 - 5 minute walk to the beach, bar/restaurants and Boat launch. Perfect for a couples get away or a family of 4. Kids welcomed. Our Place is a 4 night minimum from June 15- Sept 1 before or after that if an inquiry is sent for less days we will accept the offer if it's available.

Location · Hospitality · Access

Lake of the Woods Retreat

Escape to private acres at Lake of the Woods — with a full home, large deck, firepit, and trails nearby. Spot wildlife, sip coffee with sunrise views, and end your night under the stars. This 3BR/2BA retreat has everything you need: stocked kitchen, laundry, 65" TV, Wi-Fi, and space to relax. Close to Lake Erie beaches and local adventures, it’s your perfect basecamp.

Location · Family · Indoor spaces