Vacation rentals in Sproul State Forest

We had a great stay at Brenden’s, the place was very well maintained, and provided plenty of room for four of us (2 adults, 2 kids under 7). House is very cozy and well equipped, even though there are some neighbors around the area, you still get plenty of privacy and nice surroundings. Kids loved the fire pit, didn’t get a chance to use the grill this time but it was in good shape. Great communication from the hosts, look forward to staying again on trips up North.

My extended family and I had a wonderful stay at the Flying Squirrel Lodge! The property is meticulously maintained, with beautiful handcrafted furniture, high-end finishes, and thoughtful details. We appreciated the well-furnished kitchen, as we cooked most of our meals. And the kids loved the game room downstairs. The bathrooms are spacious and clean, and have everything one might need (obviously besides personal items), plus some unexpected extras, like a towel warmer. The pellet stove was a nice touch, and kept us toasty warm. Lastly, the jukebox provided great tunes.

This cabin was awesome! Main reason is location. Many cabins are too close to highway for good nights rest. We have stayed in some with no rest that night. This was best nights of sleep in Tioga ever. Thank you. we will return!

Incredibly awesome place! A must-- stay! My wife and I just got back from being here for our 25th anniversary. no unpleasant surprises when arriving here. Everything absolutely accurate based on the photos and all descriptions. A beautifully designed cabin, spacious, outdoor hot tub and fire pit, wrap around porch, lots of land to explore in the beautiful Pennsylvania mountains by the Susquehanna river. Even saw a large group of elk as we were pulling up! Secluded, peaceful, and an all-around quality property. All instructions were clear, simple, and fair. Several items are labeled for convenience, everything easy to use and operate. Also, Paul was a perfect host - very responsive, accommodating, helpful, and great customer service every time I contacted him. I couldn't have asked for a better stay for mine and my wife's special occasion. Great experience for a fair price, worth every dollar! Thanks again Paul.

Looking forward to another stay in the future.

What a pleasurable stay for our extended family. The house was meticulous and beautiful. This was not a cheap flip. This home was done with care for detail. The view was absolutely magnificent, and what a treat to see elk and deer come to the pasture for the children to see. Everyone in our family said how much they loved the stay. It was well worth the 2 1/2 hr drive!

Beautiful home, secluded. Great outdoor space, firepit. Beautiful view right on Penn’s creek. Landon was super friendly and proactive. Great guide for local places . Highly recommend. We stayed to do some fishing on Penn’s creek

We had a fantastic time at Jim and Nancy’s place. There were detailed labels and instructions for all of the lighting, switches, and amenities in the house which made it very easy to get comfortable and familiar as soon as we arrived. The kitchen, bathrooms, and bedrooms were well stocked with everything you could need to feel right at home. We enjoyed relaxing by the gas fireplace and being able to look out the back windows to wildlife enjoying the bird feeders. There were suggestions in the breakfast nook for things to do nearby. We ended up checking out Martin’s pantry which was absolutely delicious. Nancy was thoughtful and quick to respond, and helped make for an overall great relaxing weekend getaway

Our stay at Cozy Pine Cottage was peaceful, quiet, and the birds would chirp and sing a bit every now and then. Which was very nice. The neighbor nearby did start up the chain saw Saturday morning but, not till after 8 am. The cabin was very comfortable, and nice touches by Sarah with pretty throw blankets, chocolate left for us, and info about local things to see and do. I would recommend this cottage to any couple wanting to get away together for some much needed quality time together. The hot tub was wonderful for in the evening under the stars.