Vacation rentals in Sandy Hook Bay

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Sandy Hook Bay

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Top guest favorite

The living room features a neutral color palette with a comfortable sofa and day bed, complemented by decorative cushions. A coffee table sits in the center on a woven rug. Natural light filters in through windows adorned with green curtains, while a television is mounted on the wall.

Home in Atlantic Highlands

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 139 reviews

Sea-renity in Navesink Home Away From Home

Join us for a relaxing stay at Sea-renity in Navesink, an oasis, your home away from home. Nestled in the historic district of Navesink Village, this tranquil renovated historic farmhouse built in the 1840’s, rests on over an acre of lush land with mature hardwood trees. Envision yourself experiencing the sounds and sights of nature, the nearby ocean surf, cultural aspects of the area: music, plays, theater, art, vast variety of cuisines, walks, a day at the beach, fishing, crabbing, and biking.

Guest favorite

A bright dining area is furnished with a large wooden table surrounded by six upholstered chairs in a rich blue color. Two potted plants are positioned near the windows, which provide ample natural light, while a modern chandelier hangs above the table, complemented by a wall-mounted television displaying scenic imagery.

Home in Keansburg

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 13 reviews

Luxury Beach Villa 5 Min from the Ocean

BRAND NEW BEACH HOUSE | 3BR, 2.5BA | 1 BLOCK TO THE BEACH | BIKES, BABY GEAR & MORE Welcome to your perfect Jersey Shore getaway! This newly constructed 2025 modern beach home is ideally located just 1 block from Keansburg Beach and a short walk to the amusement park and waterpark—fun for all ages! 📍 Prime Location: 🌊 5-minute walk to the beach 🏖 Quick drive to Sandy Hook ⛴ Scenic 45-min boat ride to Manhattan 🌆 Stunning views of the NYC skyline ✈️ Only 35 minutes from Newark (EWR) Airport

Guest favorite

A two-story building with a yellow exterior is presented, featuring a covered porch with steps leading to the entrance. American flags are displayed on either side of the porch. The surrounding area includes a grassy lawn and a few trees, typical of a quiet neighborhood.

Home in Middletown Township

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 67 reviews

Newly Renovated Sergeants Quarter, Sandy Hook NJ

Newly renovated 2BR; 1 bath; uniquely located in Sandy Hook Nat'l Park with ocean views and an abundance of outdoor activities to keep everyone entertained. Sleeps 4-6. 1st Fl: full kitchen; LR with pullout couch 2nd fl: BR with queen bed; BR twin bunk beds +air mattress; BSMT W/D and pool table; Walking distance to the beach , Bay, Bike Riding/Hiking Paths; Historic sites ie Lighthouse/History House. Outside space has beautiful porch to watch sunsets and BBQ/picnic tables for outdoor dining.

Guest favorite

The main living area features a spacious bed adorned with a light green throw blanket, complemented by a colorful artwork above. A kitchenette is situated against the wall, equipped with a coffee maker and minimalist wooden cabinetry. Natural light enhances the warm wood flooring.

Guest suite in Sayreville

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

Contemporary Private Guest Studio close to NYC

Welcome to The Urban Guest Studio, a refined and modern retreat in vibrant Sayreville, NJ. Ideally located just off the Garden State Parkway and Routes 9 & 35, it’s a 40-minute drive to NYC and 30 minutes to Newark Airport. Enjoy quick access to the South Amboy Ferry, upscale shopping, top hospitals, Rutgers University, and New Brunswick’s cultural hub. Only 7 minutes from the iconic Starland Ballroom and 20 minutes to the PNC Bank Arts. Experience comfort, style, and effortless convenience.

Guest favorite

Home in Sea Bright

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 44 reviews

Wake up w/ Ocean Views in SeaBright!

This modern & luxurious property is located in the heart of Sea Bright just 3 houses from the beach with direct ocean views!! We are walking distance to the most popular restaurants and bars leaving you with no reason to drive a car! Each bedroom has its own private on suite bath and there's an additional half bath off the living room. Our reverse living setup has bedrooms on the first 2 floors with the living room and kitchen on the top floor. Book your stay for a truly relaxing time!

Guest favorite

A two-story cottage is visible, featuring a light exterior with a peaked roof. Lush green bushes line the front yard, and a concrete pathway leads to the entrance. Surrounding trees offer a natural backdrop, contributing to a serene neighborhood ambiance.

Cottage in Middletown

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 156 reviews

Cozy Cottage Retreat on North Jersey Shore

Come and relax in our shore retreat cottage with private driveway and backyard a block from the sea. We are a retreat away from the hurly-burly of connected life, but we do have WiFi Internet. We are located in a safe quiet neighborhood 5-10 minutes walk from Leonardo state marina and beach, 2 miles from Atlantic Highlands with it's bustling main street and delightful harbor where you can take the Seastreak ferry to Manhattan; 15 minutes drive to Sandy Hook and the Atlantic Shore Beaches.

Top guest favorite

An open living space features a comfortable sofa and armchair, set on a patterned area rug. A modern kitchen island with bar stools provides seating, while stainless-steel appliances complement the light cabinetry. Natural light fills the room through two windows.

Vacation home in Highlands

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 116 reviews

2BR Oceanview Shore House, walk to beach/nightlife

** Beautiful newly renovated 2 bedroom that is walking distance from the NYC ferry, numerous bars and restaurants with live music, and steps away from the beach. Come explore the Highlands, where small town charm meets the Jersey shore. Everything is walking distance in this 1 square mile town. Enjoy waterfront restaurants , night life, tiki bars, fishing, kayaking, biking on the Henry Hudson Trail, hiking in Hartshorne Woods Park, and of course Sandy Hook Beaches.

Guest favorite

A spacious backyard features a stone patio with comfortable seating, accented by vibrant outdoor furniture. Cafe string lights hang overhead, providing a cozy ambiance. An umbrella-shaded dining area awaits, surrounded by well-maintained grass and lush greenery.

Home in Highlands

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 80 reviews

Stylish Home w King Beds, Walk to Beach & Downtown

Just a short walk from the beach, dining & nightlife, biking, boating, and the high-speed ferry to NYC, our centrally-located home offers the perfect blend of luxe style and functionality. Featuring a bright & open floor plan, 4 spacious bedrooms, 2.5 baths, a big fenced-in backyard, and 2 WFH workspaces, it's ideal for family vacations and digital nomads alike. Experience the best of beachside living in this modern and well-appointed home in historic Highlands, NJ!

Top guest favorite

An inviting outdoor pool area is framed by the main house, which features multiple levels and balcony access. Two striped umbrellas provide shade over lounge chairs, while warm evening light casts a welcoming glow on the surrounding greenery.

Apartment in Highlands

5 out of 5 average rating, 65 reviews

Highlands Hillside Hideaway w/Pool. beach, ferry

The guest apartment is located on the lower level of the main house on a beautiful, quaint hillside street. The 600 sq. ft. apartment is remodeled to provide a relaxed, beach getaway ambiance so you could enjoy a care free getaway. After waking from a restful slumber in the king-size bed, enjoy a beautiful oceanside morning walk to get your coffee at the local bakery or the local coffee shop. After you’ve grabbed your coffee, explore all that highlands has to offer.

Guest favorite

The cabin exterior is framed by lush greenery and tall trees, bathed in warm sunlight. A front yard with manicured grass and shrubs leads to large windows that offer glimpses of the interior. The rustic shingle siding complements the natural surroundings.

Guesthouse in Atlantic Highlands

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 331 reviews

Cabin in the woods

Private wood cabin on 2 acres of woods and landscaped gardens at the Shore. One bedroom, private patio with outdoor fire pit. Indoor wood burning stove, bathroom w/ shower, Internet, TV, sound system, & air conditioning. Close to local hot spots in Sea Bright, Red Bank, Pier Village, & Asbury Park. Activities near by: Mountain biking on Henry Hudson Trail, Sandy Hook, Hiking at Hartshorne Woods, Canoeing, kayaking, surfing, crabbing & and fishing. A fun space!

Superhost

A cozy living area features a light-colored sofa adorned with vibrant throw pillows. A ceiling fan with wooden blades provides a cool breeze. A small table sits near a window, while a warm floor lamp adds soft illumination to the inviting space.

Home in Keansburg

4.89 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Sandpiper Place 24: 4 min walk to beach, waterpark

Stay in this newly renovated home at the heart of the all the fun. Take a short walk down the long pier, or step around the corner to the waterpark and speedway. With the free beach just a stone's throw from your door, fun in the sun is at your finger tips. Relax watching one of the two smart TV's. Delight your tastebuds at one of the various restaurants all just minutes away. Finish you evening with a drink on the shaded patio. Permit: 383

Guest favorite

A charming carriage house features a combination of wooden shingles and large windows, surrounded by lush greenery. Bougainvillea climbs the exterior, adding vibrant color against the earth-toned siding. Sunlight casts a warm glow on the inviting facade, enhancing its tranquil countryside setting.

Guesthouse in Rumson

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

Navesink River Carriage House with water views.

Navesink - Sandy Hook Beach - Hartshorne Woods. Beautiful 1bed/1bath carriage house apartment amongst tree tops in the countryside, offers serene water views and direct access to kayaking and hiking trails. Just 10min to Seastreak ferry, cafes and restaurants. Well-equipped kitchen and temperature control (air/heat) makes this a comfortable year round escape or bonus accommodation for relatives. 1 king bed and 1 queen sleeper sofa.