Vacation rentals in San Carlos Island

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in San Carlos Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Top guest favorite
A spacious living area features a large sectional sofa adorned with cozy pillows. Natural light fills the room from the adjoining dining area, which showcases a wooden table seating six. The modern kitchen with stainless steel appliances is visible in the background, creating an inviting social space.
Home in Fort Myers Beach
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 124 reviews

Sandy Feet Retreat on Virginia Ave

Your Sandy Feet Retreat in Paradise This newly remodeled home offers modern elegance with 3 spacious bedrooms and 2.5 beautifully remodeled bathrooms. Enjoy the private heated pool, perfect for relaxing. Situated in the heart of Fort Myers Beach, this home is just a 5-minute stroll to the powdery, sugar-sand beach and only a 10-minute walk to margaritaville andTimes Square. With a variety of restaurants and bars featuring live music nearly every night, it’s the perfect location for enjoying th

Top guest favorite
Home in Cape Coral
5 out of 5 average rating, 20 reviews

Villa510~3 En-Suites~Gulf Access, Heated spa~pool

Villa510 is a newly built waterfront retreat ideal for extended stays in Cape Coral. Enjoy peaceful salt canal water views and manatees from the lanai, then relax in your private heated pool and spa—perfect year-round. The outdoor kitchen and lanai create an easy, comfortable daily routine. Inside offers three private en-suite bedrooms, a den with optional airbed, open living space, and TVs in every room. Close to shopping, dining, and beaches—perfect for snowbirds seeking comfort and ease.

Top guest favorite
A sunlit pool area is framed by palm trees, with views of the canal and neighboring homes in the background. Comfortable loungers are positioned along the poolside, inviting relaxation amidst the tranquil waterfront setting.
Home in Fort Myers Beach
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Paradise on canal minutes to Ft Myers Beach/Gulf

Beautiful 3 Bedroom, 3 bath home on a canal with a dock! Bring your boat or jet skis! Enjoy a relaxing stay watching the dolphins and manatee right off the dock. This exquisitely updated home has everything you need for a fantastic vacation. Especially location! 5 minutes to Ft Meyers Beach. Enjoy the resort right in your own backyard. New pool with hot tub and sun shelf. Enjoy beautiful sunsets off the huge patio. Trolly to beach at neighborhood entrance or walk to in minutes.

Top guest favorite
An open living area features a spacious arrangement of light-colored furniture, including a large leather sectional and armchairs. A modern fireplace and flat-screen TV are positioned on a textured feature wall. Natural light floods the space through expansive glass doors that overlook the pool area.
Home in Cape Coral
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 61 reviews

Villa Sunset Serenade II

Komplett renoviert und neu eingerichtet! Erleben Sie die schönsten Wochen in der brandneu durch ein professionelles Designerteam komplett renovierten Villa Sunset Serenade II. Das mit einem tollen Lichtkonzept ausgestattete offene Wohnzimmer mit der nagelneuen großen modernen Küche der Ess- und Kochinsel sowie mit Kamin und Großfernseher. Die große italienische Ledercouch mit den großen elektrischen Sessel erlaubt einen tollen Blick auf den breiten Kanal und laden zum genießen ein.

Top guest favorite
The outdoor area features a spacious paved patio surrounding a private heated pool. Lounge chairs are positioned by the poolside, and a grill is visible nearby. The pink-hued villa and a screened lanai area can be seen in the background.
Cottage in Fort Myers Beach
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 145 reviews

Coral Reef Villa - Steps from beach / Private Pool

We're Back! Fully Renovated in 2023! Welcome to the Coral Reef Villa located at 213 Fairweather Lane, Fort Myers Beach. 2 bedroom and 1 full bathroom villa. Steps away from the beach where paradise is waiting for you. Centrally located at the North end of the island. Walk to Times Square to enjoy shopping and dining. Close to all Fort Myers Beach has to offer while also located on a quiet residential street, this home is perfect for those that demand both proximity and tranquility!

Guest favorite
Home in Fort Myers Beach
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 15 reviews

“Welcome to Relax and Unwind".

“Welcome to Relax and Unwind, your perfect waterfront getaway in beautiful Fort Myers Beach. This charming 2-bedroom, 2-bath home at 70 Emily Lane offers everything you need for comfort and relaxation — a queen bed, twin beds, a cozy futon, and a fully equipped kitchen. Enjoy peaceful mornings by the water, take a kayak or bike ride. Just minutes from the beach and top attractions like Margaritaville Resort, the Key West Ferry, the vibrant marina, and local restaurants

Top guest favorite
An expansive open kitchen and dining area showcases sleek white cabinetry and a large kitchen island. Wooden barstools provide seating at the island, while contemporary lighting fixtures hang above. Large windows enhance the airy atmosphere, revealing a modern living space in the background.
Home in Fort Myers
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 103 reviews

Modern City Loft in Downtown River District

Welcome to Gun-Loft, a custom-designed modern sanctuary in the Downtown River District. This expansive 3500 square foot city loft is tailored for those seeking to embrace the cosmopolitan lifestyle, with the perfect blend of urban luxury and cultural richness. Whether it's a leisurely stroll to the Edison Ford Home, an exciting night out, or a culinary adventure in the restaurants nearby, Gun-Loft offers an unparalleled experience in the city's most coveted location.

Top guest favorite
The exterior of Captain Jack’s Cottage is displayed, featuring a light-colored wooden structure with a spacious patio. Colorful adirondack chairs are arranged around the outdoor area, with a calming sunset in the background. A staircase leads to the upper level, enhancing accessibility.
Home in Fort Myers Beach
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 32 reviews

Cap't Jack's Waterfront Cottage

Escape to Captain Jack’s Cottage, a newly renovated canal-front retreat perfect for up to 4 guests. Just a 10-15 minute walk to the sandy beach, this charming home offers a tranquil vibe with modern amenities, a private patio, and stunning water views. Walk to local restaurants or hop on the nearby beach trolley. Whether relaxing or seeking adventure, Captain Jack’s Cottage is ideal for a memorable coastal getaway. Book now and unwind in paradise!

Top guest favorite
Home in Fort Myers Beach
5 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Icon on the bay - Panoramic views/Rooftop hot tub

Waterfront fun meets luxury in this 3-story Fort Myers Beach home on San Carlos Island! Featuring 4 bedrooms, bay-view living room with balcony, and a full kitchen & dining on the 2nd floor. Enjoy an outdoor kitchen with grill and bar, plus pool table, ping pong & air hockey. Private dock with boat lift and a rooftop deck with turf, lounge chairs & a 6-person hot tub for sunset soaking. Perfect for families, boaters & group getaways.

Top guest favorite
Villa in Fort Myers Beach
5 out of 5 average rating, 29 reviews

Luxury Waterfront Home • Pool • Dock • Near Beach

Experience refined coastal living in Siesta Isles, Fort Myers Beach. This 4,000+ sq ft waterfront retreat offers a quick 5-minute drive to the beach and seamless, direct Gulf access by boat. Features include a private dock with lift, heated pool, open-concept design, multiple lounge areas, outdoor kitchen, and a separate TV suite with bar—perfect for families, groups and boaters seeking privacy, comfort, and location.

Superhost
Home in Fort Myers Beach
4.71 out of 5 average rating, 7 reviews

Ostego Charm | Fort Myers Beach Coastal Charm

Welcome to Ostego Charm! This beautiful 2 bed, 2 bath Fort Myers Beach home offers an open floor concept filled with natural light and coastal charm. Enjoy breezy evenings on the spacious covered porch or entertain in the bright, modern living space. Elevated for safety and style, and surrounded by lush tropical landscaping, Ostego Charm is just minutes from the beach—your perfect island getaway or vacation rental!

Top guest favorite
A modern entrance is framed by landscaped greenery, including palm trees and ornamental stones. The house displays a combination of textured materials, with large windows allowing ample natural light. A straight pathway leads from the driveway towards the entrance, set against a clear blue sky.
Home in Fort Myers Beach
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 52 reviews

Beach escape! Walk to the square! Steps to beach!

Modern 3BR/2BA home with an industrial-chic vibe, perfectly located just a short walk down the street from the beautiful Fort Myers Beach. Enjoy a fully equipped kitchen, open living space, and private outdoor area—ideal for relaxing after a day in the sun. Walk to the beach in minutes or explore nearby Times Square for dining and entertainment. Comfort, style, and unbeatable location all in one!

Popular amenities for San Carlos Island vacation rentals