Vacation rentals in San Carlos Island

Private Home and Heated Pool on Virginia Ave

Your Sandy Feet Retreat in Paradise This newly remodeled home offers modern elegance with 3 spacious bedrooms and 2.5 beautifully remodeled bathrooms. Enjoy the private heated pool, perfect for relaxing. Situated in the heart of Fort Myers Beach, this home is just a 5-minute stroll to the powdery, sugar-sand beach and only a 10-minute walk to margaritaville andTimes Square. With a variety of restaurants and bars featuring live music nearly every night, it’s the perfect location for enjoying th

Paradise Found

Located in Sun Retreats Fort Myers Beach (formerly Indian Creek), just 3 miles from Fort Myers Beach, Bunche, and Sanibel Island, and Margaritaville. The property offers amenities, including pools, pickleball, tennis, and numerous activities. It’s a great location, away from the main beach traffic but still close to shopping, and you can bike or walk to the beach. The trolley also stops right at the entrance. The bungalow features a fully equipped kitchen. Must be 35 to book, park rules.

Seabreeze Hideaway

Located in Sun Retreats Fort Myers Beach (formerly Indian Creek), just 3 miles from Fort Myers Beach, Bunche, and Sanibel Island, and Margaritaville. The property offers amenities, including pools, pickleball, tennis, and numerous activities. It’s a great location, away from the main beach traffic but still close to shopping. The trolley also stops right at the entrance. The bungalow features a fully equipped kitchen and allows one pet up to 20 pounds. An occupant must be 35 or older.

Charming suite w/ private deck Downtown FMB

Discover the perfect blend of modern and tropical charm at our 1BR/1BA loft apartment in Downtown Fort Myers Beach. Just a 2-minute walk to the white sands, this upscale retreat is walking distance to the beach, Times Square, restaurants, bars, and shops. Enjoy water sports, kayaking, parks, and more. Ideal for couples, snowbirds, or anyone seeking a tropical escape, The Loft FMB combines modern comforts with island relaxation truly designed to feel like your home away from home.

Ocean Jewels 1 - Overlooks Margaritaville

Right on Estero Blvd. in the heart of Fort Myers Beach sits this one bedroom loft! With two king beds in the sleeping area and a sleeper sofa in the living room, you can have up to 6 guests here. Enjoy the brand new bath with walk-in shower, living space with large picture window facing the Gulf, and an all new kitchen with everything you need to prepare a full meal or just a snack for the beach! Guests can expect modern and cozy decor with free WiFi and a TV in the living area.

Ready to Enjoy again! 2025: Everything is new!

This vacation rental unit has been totally rebuilt and is now ready to welcome guests again! Nearly everything is new (as of early 2025) and it is likely one of the nicest studio apartments now available on the entire island. Skip the dated condos and hotels and get ready to enjoy this newer, nicer option, located just 1 short block (800 feet) from the sand. As you’ll see from the reviews it had a great track record before the storm, and it’s been rebuilt even better! Enjoy!

Mango Villa - Steps away from beach / private pool

We're Back! Fully Renovated in 2023! Welcome to the Mango Villa located at 150 Mango Street, Fort Myers Beach. 2 bedroom and 1 full bathroom villa. Steps away from the beach where paradise is waiting for you. Centrally located at the North end of the island. Walk to Times Square to enjoy shopping and dining. Close to all Fort Myers Beach has to offer while also located on a quiet residential street, this home is perfect for those that demand both proximity and tranquility!

Your Home at the Beach!

Less than a mile from Time’s Square, the beach center, and the remains of the pier. Beach access is a 5 minute walk. Close to public transportation and located on a quiet street with a private backyard on a canal. If you’re lucky, catch a glimpse of a dolphin or manatee. Private entrance. Newly remodeled with full kitchen and shared laundry room. If this sounds like what you’ve been looking for, instant book right now or text me with any questions you might have.

Grace by The Sea · 2025 Build · Steps to Beach

This stylish coastal home offers a brand-new experience with a spacious lanai and backyard, all with just a 6-minute walk to the sugar sand beach. Start your morning with coffee on the covered front porch, enjoying Gulf breezes. Relax by the pool with a book throw something on the blackstone grill, play corn hole or enjoy cozy outdoor seating for lounging and dining. End the day with a sunset stroll or a short drive to nearby bars and restaurants.

Cap't Jack's Waterfront Cottage

Escape to Captain Jack’s Cottage, a newly renovated canal-front retreat perfect for up to 4 guests. Just a 10-15 minute walk to the sandy beach, this charming home offers a tranquil vibe with modern amenities, a private patio, and stunning water views. Walk to local restaurants or hop on the nearby beach trolley. Whether relaxing or seeking adventure, Captain Jack’s Cottage is ideal for a memorable coastal getaway. Book now and unwind in paradise!

Calm & Relaxing Beach Getaway!

Forget your worries in this spacious and serene space. Right before the Matanzas Pass Bridge. Excellent for anyone looking for a Beach Getaway. Great neighborhood, walking distance from Fort Myers Beach Times Square and Great Reastaurants. Enjoy the beautiful sunsets and walks on the Beach. Includes: -Beach Towels -Basic Cooking Utensils and Pans -1 Queen Bed 1 Queen Sofa Bed -2 Cars Maximum

"Queen Conch"

Snug apartment with a beachy vibe. It's compact but well-organized, with a cozy living area furnished with a comfortable sofa and a small dining table. The decor is simple and inviting, with touches of coastal charm like seashell accents and nautical artwork. Located just minutes walking from local bars and restaurants and less than a mile from Fort Myers Beach!