Vacation rentals in Pultneyville

Lakefront Midcentury Cottage

Looking for a relaxing place to finish your novel? Come watch the sunset over the lake, listen to the waves crash & enjoy the views of local wildlife. Nestled in a private cove right on the shores of Lake Ontario you'll be charmed by this midcentury cottage. Not far from local farm stands & markets for truly a farm to table dinner. Hike the Chimney Bluffs, check out the local cider/wine tastings, and treasure hunt at local antique shops. 30 mins to Rochester & Renaissance Fest. Come stay!

Bayside Getaway

Relax at the Getaway, overlooking Ontario's Great Sodus Bay. Perfect for golfing, fishing, beach-going, boating, apple-picking, hiking, or simply... getting away. Adjacent to Sodus Bay Heights Golf Club. Short drive to Sodus Bay Beach, Beechwood and Chimney Bluff state parks, and many public and private lake access points. (All access requires driving.) Weekly Saturday-to-Saturday bookings only in summer. Additional nearby accommodations are available for larger groups. Message us if interested

Loft on East Main

The Loft on East Main- this newly renovated luxury apartment, is located in downtown Palmyra NY. Known as the "Queen of Erie Canal towns", located in the finger lakes region of upstate NY, Palmyra is known for its lush history and architecture dating back to the 1800s. Whether you come to see the four churches (1/4ml), visit the Hill Cumorah Monument (<5 ml), take a wine tour, enjoy hiking/biking along the canal, or prefer to spend your afternoon antiquing, there is something for everyone!

The Lake Nest

If you’re looking for a lovely retreat to hang your hat, unwind and experience a comfortable and tranquil place to watch the sunsets and enjoy a big exhale-The Lake Nest is for you! Minutes from Rochester and close to shops, stores and restaurants -this country cottage is the perfect spot to enjoy beautiful Lake Ontario. Updated with all modern amenities and conveniences, the Lake Nest is the ideal location for boating, fishing, hiking, checking out wineries or visiting lovely parks.

1845 School House in the Heart of Pultneyville

Fully renovated in the spring of 2021. According to the Pultneyville Historical Society, the first school, a small crude building, was built on this site in 1808. It burned in 1816 and was replaced by a larger schoolhouse. The cobblestone building was built in 1845 and served as a school until 1943 when the Williamson School District centralized. It is now a private residence. Notice the cobbles set at an angle. A metal bar circles the building as reinforcement — a modern addition.

Lakeside Serenity Home

Spacious 3 bedroom and 2.5 bathroom home on Lake Ontario will be the perfect relaxing getaway. Admire the view and sunsets over the lake from the comfort of this home or out on the patio. Just outside of Rochester. Central location to explore Upstate NY including Niagara Falls, Watkins Glen, Lake Canandaigua and the Finger Lakes. Close to hiking, skiing, golfing, boating, fishing and other water activities. Perfect place to go apple picking in the fall or explore local wineries.

Lake Ontario Beauty! Sleeps 4!

Take in the sky and water on majestic Lake Ontario! This cozy, tranquil cottage offers comfort and relaxation. All you need to unwind is yours at this renovated waterfront property. Peaceful, beautiful and meditative. Relax on the deck and stare at the horizon while cooking your favorite menu on the grill! Play yard games in the huge front yard on the parking side of the cottage. One pet welcome if approved by host -- pet fee is $35/night.

The Legacy- Historic Farmhouse

This historic farm house has a lot to offer with 5 bedrooms and can hold up to 10 people. In the den/game room there is a pull out couch for an additional guest if needed. There is a large kitchen and dining room with seating up to 12. Come enjoy a long weekend with us. We are centrally located between Sodus Point and the City of Rochester. There is a lot to do locally as well with restaurants and attractions in Williamson.

1/1 Fully Furnished Modern Apartment

Brand new 1/1 furnished apartment with open floor-plan, granite counter tops, oversized kitchen island, stainless steel appliances, washer/dryer in unit. Behind TOPS plaza off of Furnace rd. One minute from 104 and 5 minutes from Webster.