Vacation rentals in Poygan Lake

The house itself was the best-equipped rental we’ve ever experienced. Starting with the kitchen: no cheap utensils, no flimsy dishes—they didn’t cut corners. Everything felt like it was stocked by someone who actually cooks. Every little tool or item you’d expect in your own home was there. As for cleanliness—impeccable. This may have been the cleanest short-term rental we've ever stayed in. Spotless, organized, and not a single hair out of place. The location was fantastic: walking distance to downtown Menasha with its charming restaurants and shops, yet peaceful and right on the water. The hot tub was actually the reason we booked, and it absolutely delivered. High-quality Adirondack chairs added a nice touch and made it feel like home. We’re already talking about coming back—especially to try out the pontoon boat next time. Everything about this rental exceeded our (very high) standards. We own beautiful homes ourselves and expect a lot when we travel. This place lived up!

By far my best experience in Green Bay and staying at an Airbnb. Nicole takes great care of the property and is super responsive. We had no issues at all during our stay - it was better than described and located within walking distance of shops and restaurants downtown. I will definitely try to stay here again if I make it back for a game.

Such a wonderful experience! The place is perfect for a getaway or even a longer stay. The surroundings are beautiful—we enjoyed breakfast on the terrace, did some grilling, and even tried a bit of fishing. Everything was super clean with a stylish, tasteful design. I would definitely come back for a summer experience!

The A Frame was a great Airbnb that I’d definitely recommend to anyone looking to stay in the area. It was just a short drive away from town, so getting last minute groceries was very easy, and not too far from a couple larger towns with more restaurants and things to do. The house itself had everything we needed and them some. It was also plenty warm for it being a fairly snowy weekend and all the windows made enjoying the peaceful surroundings (in the warmth) very lovely.

Beautiful and clean AirBnb! The backyard was the perfect place to relax next to the stream. Plenty of games and things to do. Would certainly book again!

We had a great time! We enjoyed the open concept kitchen/dinning and living room. The hot tub was nice to have. There was plenty of towels for the hot tubs as well as showering for our group. We did get to use the golf carts on Friday for a little bit since it was so nice out but Saturday the weather was crappy. All in all we had a really nice weekend away!

Our stay was wonderful. The house was clean, excellent floor plan, nicely decorated and beautiful view of the lake. Host was attentive and easy to work with. Highly recommend. Looking forward to staying during the summer.

Price was fair, house was spotless, host was very kind and helpful. The kitchen is kinda small but the appliances are amazing. Nicest grill setup ive seen at a rental. Spotless weber kettle with 2 bags of kingsford waiting in garage. We had a blast. Would definitely book again.

Good location with ample sleeping room. We pretty much hung out on the deck. Great communication from the host. Everything was exactly as described. They had bands playing music across the river so we even got free entertainment. We rented pontoons from the place across the river. The fishing was extremely tough. We definitely plan on going back and next time we're going to try and time it with the white bass run. We will be back. We had 13 guest and we all throughly enjoyed our stay. Most importantly it was great just getting together. Thanks Lana!