Places to stay in Palmyra

Love the cabins at Screwy Louie’s! My husband and I stayed here for some time years ago and decided to revisit for our anniversary recently. The cabins were better than we remembered, everything was clean and tidy. I am from the area so I’m aware of everything Fair Haven has to offer, but the location of the cabins makes things super walkable. We will be back!

Great place! Beautiful. New. Safe neighborhood. Easy access to Cornell and Ithaca. Highly recommend. Will stay here again!

This charming historic home exceeded all expectations! Every detail sparkled with character, from the immaculate interior to the supremely comfortable beds. The location couldn't be better for anyone's stay in Rochester. Lucking out with warmer Dec. weather, we strolled through streets lined with architecturally unique and beautifully holiday-decorated homes that looked straight out of a postcard. I only wish we could have stayed longer to soak in more of the magical atmosphere. A perfect 5-star experience from start to finish in my favorite part of the city.

A gorgeous, relaxing, calm retreat in the heart of Ithaca! We thoroughly enjoyed our stay and the best coffee; ice cream and restaurants were within short walking distance from this property. It was cozy yet spacio9us, the bed was incredibly comfortable after a day of exploring and catching up with our college son. We will be recommending this gem to others and plan to be back in the future.

A++++Cannot say enough about this rental. So clean- it was basically a hotel room but as a house in the countryside. Every amenity possible, welcome basket, even extra toothbrushes etc. checkin was a breeze- even early because we arrived sooner than expected. Hosts were lovely and proactive with everything and anything with the home. Will be staying here again and again.

I just wanted to thank you for everything you did for us!! Your home is lovely and I would definitely stay again! We had 3 feet of snow and he plowed everything everyday for us since we worked nights! Beautiful spot you can see the Bay!

Great place, beautiful views of the lake (and lake effect snow)! Top notch coffee grinder. Would stay here again, 100%.

We had a great few days at Anita's place. The location is perfect- walking distance to much of what Ithaca has to offer. The place itself was clean and comfortable. We could hear the people above us walking around, so make sure to bring earplugs if you are a light sleeper. Anita was a great host- very responsive and helpful.

Great location! Walked to beach everyday and swam in beautiful Lake Ontario....walking distance to several restaurants. Small place but cozy, clean, and comfortable. Amazing deck view...perfect for a couple. Went on a few hikes in the area and a zoo 30 minutes away. Internet was a bit spotty but worked 90% of time and Katie had solutions so all was well. Katie was responsive, easy check in and i highly recommend for a lazy beach getaway!