Waterfront vacation rentals in Otisco Lake

The location is great—right by the lake with stunning views. The apartment was clean, cozy, and well-equipped with everything we needed. The host was responsive and made sure our stay was comfortable. Highly recommend this spot for a peaceful getaway

Incredible host! Very responsive and helpful would definitely stay here in the future and recommend this place to my friends!

Cute and exceptionally clean apartment. Great location, walkable to attractions and restaurants. Very peaceful. Eileen was a wonderful host. We would definitely stay here again.

Chance was very nice and hospitable. The place was very peaceful and quiet. Pool and hot tub area is very nice, weather wasn’t good so we didn’t get to enjoy it as much as we wanted. I would definitely stay here again.

Robyn is wonderful! She is very helpful and incredibly kind. This place is paradise. A very peaceful and relaxing, home away from home. The amenities are wonderful, we were able to kayak and listen to some beautiful records, it was absolutely amazing! You will not regret staying here. Put it on your bucket list:)

We had the most wonderful stay at Amanda’s place! The space was exactly as described and perfect for our family while visiting our daughter at Colgate. We loved the location on the lake and views out the front windows. The house is about 3 miles from the Colgate athletic fields or a ten minute drive - 12 minutes if you’re going up the hill. Amanda was such a gracious and accommodating host with excellent communication. We will definitely be back!

I can’t say enough about how wonderful Peggy’s boat house is. This is my second time staying here and I have never stayed at the same ABB twice. This time I brought the kids because I wanted to share the beauty of this place and Ithaca and I knew they would love it. Sitting on the dock fishing and enjoying the views on Cayuga lake is so peaceful and relaxing. Peggy is a very welcoming host and keeps the place very tidy. There are so many things to do. Ithaca Falls is a very short drive away. Buttermilk Falls is a bit further away (not much) and is a beautiful hike. Great restaurants are nearby. I love the area and would love to come back someday.

Stephanie is a great host who was always very responsive as well as friendly. The place was very clean, the backyard was a real gem for us right on the water and the place had everything you’d need. I’d definitely recommend this place (and imagine in the summer it’s really beautiful!!).

The entire area is absolutely beautiful. The patio and living room areas were amazing for board games and cards. We were always happy to come back to the place at the end of our festivities.

Tolus house was perfectly lovely as is Tolus. Everything was spotless clean and a lot of thought went into all the extra amenities. We felt very much at home. Tulus house has a great vibe to it. It's bright, cheerfull and comfy. Tolus is a tremendous host, responds immediately and is thoughtfully concerned that her guests e joy their stay....couldn't ask for a better host.

Beautiful home on Sodus Bay. Amazing views, great location, very clean. We would definitely consider renting here again!

My husband and I were just looking for a nice place to get away for a couple of days, and while this place was way more house then we needed, it was still comfortable and the amenities were great. Everything was as described, our bed was very comfortable and we really enjoyed the use of the home theater, jacuzzi and pool table. There were cute touches like the coffee bar, and fire s’mores kit with marshmallows, graham crackers, chocolate bars and peanut butter cups. We would definitely recommend this for both a quiet, private getaway, as well as a large gathering of family or friends.

Loved the cottage, which easily accommodated 2-10 family members during the week! Beautiful, private location w/an excellent lake front and boating options. As stated in previous reviews, you can hear each other in the space. It helped that we are family. Wonderful jacuzzi tub in first floor suite and good water pressure in first floor shower. We loved the big farm table for meals and games. Seats 10. The incline to the lake takes some care w/older guests but overall was accessible. The views from the cottage are spectacular and Geneva is only 10 minutes away. We would definitely return to this cottage!

spacious and comfortable cabin on the lake, with an amazing view of the sunset on Seneca lake. exactly as described

Beautiful home in a lovely setting. Truly a home away from home!

Had a lovely stay here, the natural beauty is truly to die for. Host was so accommodating and responsive. Will definitely return.

We love the space it's our second time staying there. you cannot beat The View

The condo is beautiful and perfect location! We liked having the beach right in the backyard and seeing the beautiful sunsets! Quick walk to everything in town. Plenty of bath and beach towels provided. My kids had a blast with the arcade game! Host is quick to respond. We would def book again at this house!

We had a great stay at Troy ’s Airbnd . It is a beautiful place, immaculately clean and a brilliant location. I would book again. Troy was great at communicating with us and checked we were OK during our stay. I will definitely book again .Highly recommended!

We have stayed in one of Troy's properties in the past and it was a great experience. This location did not disappoint. Beautiful view, easy beach access, spotless accommodations and hot tubs. The area in the off-season is very quiet but a few walkable restaurants were open and the Dollar General, which had everything you can think of. The property was generously stocked with everything we needed for the long weekend. I would highly recommend scooping this place up between Labor Day and Columbus Day if you can!

Lori was amazing at communicating with us about some issues we had leading up to our visit. We had a wonderful time and enjoyed every minute of our stay!