Vacation rentals with lake access in Otisco Lake

Absolutely incredible views. We had an incredibly memorable two nights here, and Erin was always willing to provide pointers and help when needed (even at late nights). We appreciate the host and the location greatly and would definitely recommend this place to family and friends.

Shaun’s inviting Home provided a wonderful place for our family to be together and share the week of my Father-in-laws Funeral services. Being on Oneida Lake with the incredible homestead and views provided endless opportunities for Birding, solace and joyful times together. Everything we needed was there and/or was easily accessible. Our family has extensive food allergies and the fully equipped Kitchen made creating gourmet meals simple. This was my initial Airbnb experience and truly was stellar, we will be returning and staying here for each NY visit in the future. I strongly recommend this peaceful escape, just minutes to shopping and adventure.

Very nice accommodations. Beautiful lake. Enjoyed kayaking and rowing in the lake. Spacious rooms. Had lots of fun.

Great stay on the lake. Tom was a very flexible and responsive host.

My family and I had a great stay over the holidays. The place was as described, with three good sized bedrooms, nice bathrooms, and plenty of common space. Very dog friendly and games available to keep everyone occupied. It’s nicely set back from the road to feel more private and allow the dogs to roam in the yard without worry. We did leash the dogs by the lake because it was partly frozen but not totally. We enjoyed spending time by the fire and watching the snow fall, beautiful spot!

Had a lovely stay here, the natural beauty is truly to die for. Host was so accommodating and responsive. Will definitely return.

Great place for our group consisting of 4 adults and 4 kids. Parking adequate for our 2 cars. Appreciated the location and all the amenities.

A lovely, impeccably appointed, and yet affordable cottage right on Lake Cayuga and minutes from the center of Ithaca and Cornell. . Robert provides prompt and personal service to his guests. Highly recommended.

fantastic location..very walkable to food and gorgeous setting.. Sven and family were friendly and accommodating... easy to reach and gave great local recommendations!!

Jason's place was very clean and comfortable, and we really enjoyed our stay. The bed was comfortable, and the bedroom and bathroom linens were particularly nice. It was a cool weekend, and we appreciated the extra blanket and space heater when we were relaxing during the day. The building is older, so there are some quirky things about it. The corridor and stairway are quite steep and narrow, so it would be challenging for someone with mobility issues. We had a little bit of trouble finding the house at night and finding nearby parking, but the area feels safe. Jason's communication was excellent. Thank you for a great stay!

Excellent rental and great communications with Stephanie. We loved the back yard, docks, kayaks and fantastic views. Easy walk to some of the restaurants and beach area. Would certainly rent again and hope to return to Sylvan Beach during the summer months when more is open. Thank you :)

Loved staying at the cottage! Very peaceful, perfect for one person or a couple visiting Geneva. Quick drive to town but in a quiet area. Would absolutely stay here again!

Durga and Joop were great hosts and I’d highly recommend staying at their place if you’re planning on visiting the finger lakes. Accommodation was clean, tidy, comfortable and stocked with everything we needed. Location was close enough to town to make it easy to access but far enough out to be nicely private. Located right on the Taughannock Falls rim hike so perfect for some outdoors time. Hosts extremely friendly, helpful and great to chat to.

Our Sister provided this wonderful place to stay in for our Nephews Wedding. Even the visit was short it was a wonderful place to stay Geneva has a wonderful feeling super nice people and unbelievable food. We are planning a trip back to this area ❤️

We had the most wonderful stay at Amanda’s place! The space was exactly as described and perfect for our family while visiting our daughter at Colgate. We loved the location on the lake and views out the front windows. The house is about 3 miles from the Colgate athletic fields or a ten minute drive - 12 minutes if you’re going up the hill. Amanda was such a gracious and accommodating host with excellent communication. We will definitely be back!

I can’t say enough about how wonderful Peggy’s boat house is. This is my second time staying here and I have never stayed at the same ABB twice. This time I brought the kids because I wanted to share the beauty of this place and Ithaca and I knew they would love it. Sitting on the dock fishing and enjoying the views on Cayuga lake is so peaceful and relaxing. Peggy is a very welcoming host and keeps the place very tidy. There are so many things to do. Ithaca Falls is a very short drive away. Buttermilk Falls is a bit further away (not much) and is a beautiful hike. Great restaurants are nearby. I love the area and would love to come back someday.

We loved our stay at the Megan house! it's obviously an older property but it's well taken care of and well loved. the location was exactly what we were looking for, right on the lake with excellent views, and close enough for adventures in the Ithaca area. the beds were comfy and Roy and Molly have excellent communication and are very clear in their recommendations and requests. we would definitely stay here again.

Beautiful lakefront home that was very clean and accessible to the town of Hamilton. Perfect for a group.

Our stay in Lodi was amazing. Beautiful view of the lake while watching tv, cooking or just playing a game. Very Peaceful. Easy to walk our dog. Love how the bedrooms are on each side of the house as well as bathrooms as to not disturb one another... beautiful.. many wineries and breweries for tastings, & most are Dog friendly too! So easy to sit back and relax! My daughter & boyfriend loved hiking and also did some golf! This was a Beautiful getaway and the host was so great and attentive. So clean and so comfy.

We loved our stay at the lake! The views were beautiful, the cabin was peaceful, and everything felt right at home. Wish we could have stayed longer!

Such a sweet little cottage tucked away above the Lake. Beautiful views from the deck, bedroom and living room! Quiet and serene yet close to all of the places we wanted to visit! Made a great landing spot for a relaxing and fun weekend! Thank you!!

Very peaceful setting! Was just the perfect place to get away for a few days. Wish I had more time to stay. The home was great with beautiful views and perfect dock for fishing. The host was also very kind and very responsive.

Such a cute cottage right in the Lake. Had everything you could possibly need and Kevin was very responsive in answering my questions. Had such a great time sitting on the deck watching the sunrise. We will be back!

This was the 3rd year that Dina and her family graciously shared their property with us. My friends and I enjoy the coziness and family friendly atmosphere that is depicted in the photos. This is definitely a place where you can loose yourself in the vastness of the trees, the lake, and lastly the quiet. Makes for true retreat for the soul.