Vacation rentals in McElhattan

Our stay at this Airbnb was absolutely perfect! The location was stunning—beautiful scenery all around, and it felt so peaceful and private, exactly what we were looking for. The house itself had absolutely everything we needed, making it feel like a home away from home. We also loved exploring the local wineries, which were just a short drive away. If you're looking for a relaxing getaway in a gorgeous setting, this is the place. We can’t wait to come back!

This cabin was awesome! Main reason is location. Many cabins are too close to highway for good nights rest. We have stayed in some with no rest that night. This was best nights of sleep in Tioga ever. Thank you. we will return!

Loved the deer roaming right in the yard and nearby field each morning and evening. Incredibly comfortable home and furnishings. Being able to use the hot tub was one of the reasons we chose this place. We can only say great things about this place and hope to stay in the future! Thank you for being a great host!!

What a pleasurable stay for our extended family. The house was meticulous and beautiful. This was not a cheap flip. This home was done with care for detail. The view was absolutely magnificent, and what a treat to see elk and deer come to the pasture for the children to see. Everyone in our family said how much they loved the stay. It was well worth the 2 1/2 hr drive!

Two senior brothers who appreciate the outdoors and God's nature selected Stacy and Tim's cabin for our annual spring fly fishing and photography trip destination. We hit a home run by selecting their cabin overlooking Beaver Lake and located adjacent to some of PA's finest state parks, streams and forests. The cabin's quality, comfort, cleanliness, unique architecture, and furnishings are exceptional in all regards that exceeded our expectations. Stacy's communications, support and responsive email replies were excellent. Very early morning coffee on the deck with fog on the lake highlighted by turkey gobbles was fantastic. Thanks Stacy and Tim for sharing your awesome retreat. Looking forward to being back, your place is truly the best.

An awesome find! We loved visiting and will visit again on another vacation. The place was clean and neat. The beds are very comfortable. The view was stunning and the privacy was exactly what we were looking for. We saw deer, plenty of fish and some turkeys and squirrels hanging around. The place was so peaceful and relaxing. Mandy was an excellent host and answered all of our questions in a timely manner. The cupboards were stocked with snacks and plenty of essentials. Pickleball in the driveway was a fun bonus that we had not considered. If you are looking for a relaxing vacation, this is the place to be. Looking forward to another visit.

Agree with other reviewers - better on the inside than outside. Clean, comfortable. Just down the street from the main site with multiple cabins, the office, and direct creek access. Will consider staying at one of those cabins next time.

We had a fantastic time at Jim and Nancy’s place. There were detailed labels and instructions for all of the lighting, switches, and amenities in the house which made it very easy to get comfortable and familiar as soon as we arrived. The kitchen, bathrooms, and bedrooms were well stocked with everything you could need to feel right at home. We enjoyed relaxing by the gas fireplace and being able to look out the back windows to wildlife enjoying the bird feeders. There were suggestions in the breakfast nook for things to do nearby. We ended up checking out Martin’s pantry which was absolutely delicious. Nancy was thoughtful and quick to respond, and helped make for an overall great relaxing weekend getaway

This place fit perfectly for us over a busy weekend attending the PIAA Championship. Great kitchen, great bedrooms, useful utilities and modern amenities. The hosts were proactive and helpful. Highly recommend!