Monthly Rentals in Handsome Hollow

A great place to stay that felt very cozy and offered nice privacy in a beautiful area.

Five stars all around. The place was great, exactly as advertised, and very cozy for a winter getaway. We love the fireplace and we really loved THE STOVE!! Plan on broiling something just to use the broiler. It's so cool. Thank you Nynene for being a responsive host. You made our Christmas vacation lovely.

Coming from the west coast this spot was exactly the epitome of eastern cabin comfort you envision when you think of staying in rural NY, right in the woods next to the crick, abundant wildlife and beautiful views- tucked away from city life. We enjoyed how quiet and serene it was, and how beautifully and thoughtfully decorated and curated the home was. The rules were not hard to follow and we LOVED our stay, will be back next year!

Judy's place was amazing. Me and my film crew stayed there during a 4 day shoot and enjoyed every minute of it. She had a bunch of games for us to use in the game room and had a amazing backyard with hiking trails. Here house is out there but all and all so worth the drive and the stay. You only have 1 road and its has maybe one car passing every 30 minutes. I would love to stay at her place again any day of the week. Thank you Judy for the time and amazing experience.