Cottage vacation rentals in Grand Island

We had such a lovely stay at Grace's home and cannot wait to come stay here again! Grace was responsive and so helpful, going out of her way to quickly resolve any understandable/minor issues that came up during our stay. The house is even more beautiful than the pictures captured---the master bathroom in particular is heavenly and spacious, with plants around the Jacuzzi and a lovely skylight. The only things I would note to future guests is to really be mindful with the amount of water you use---there is plenty for normal use, but any heavy use will run out the cistern. Also, the Internet can sometimes get a little slow if you use it a lot. The surrounding area is so beautiful and charming, with more wineries than you could possibly visit, and an adorable pier/waterfront area with cafes, ice cream shops, and antique shops. Grace made plenty of recommendations for places to visit and offered to help us with bookings, which is so appreciated. Can't wait to stay here again!

Our family really enjoyed Elena’s place. It was cozy, clean and exactly as described. The deck was wonderful and close access to the lake and beach were great features. Elena offered for us to leave later on our last day and this allowed us to really maximize our last day of vacation. Wonderful experience!

We just returned from a perfect spring break getaway in Derby, NY, just outside of Hamburg, and we’re already missing it! The neighborhood was peaceful and quiet, with partial views of the lake that made sunrises and sunsets feel extra special. The hot tub was definitely a highlight—so relaxing and totally worth it! We were also so grateful that our dog Frankie was welcomed. The fenced-in yard gave him the freedom to roam, sniff, and unwind right alongside us. Our daughters loved having their own bedrooms (and their own TVs!), and the streaming subscriptions included were a great touch for cozy evenings in. The home was beautifully maintained, thoughtfully stocked, and we felt so welcomed from the moment we arrived. Truly wonderful superhosts—thank you for sharing your space with us! We’d love to come back!

Not our first time booking with Lauren. We have stayed in a few locations within Sherkston Shores. This unit is absolutely top notch! High end amenities. Beautiful place! Highly recommend and Lauren is a great host!

Paul is a great host. Very knowledgeable & helpful. Walked us through house instructions clearly. The cottage is great, ambience is magnificent and everything is just a 5 to 10 mins walk away or even better, charge & take the golf cart! It’s a nice ride to the beach or to the soccer field where most of the evening events occur. Definitely coming back to this place.

Great place. Very comfortable would definitely recommend. Having the hot tub was such a nice addition to the place. Elisabeth was amazing for my entire experience

We had a fantastic stay here! This was our second time staying here. Hot tub was lovely, bed was comfortable and the place was very clean. Bbq was clean and worked well. Had everything you would need on vacation.

Michael’s place was excellent! It is in the perfect location. The house was perfect for a weekend getaway. It had ample room and was super relaxing for our group. The hot tub was a perfect place to unwind . Michael was an amazing host with timely communication. Thank you! We hope to be back in the future! Cheers

The Mafia House is exactly what you’d expect and want for the weekend. The location is perfect, walk out the door and there is the stadium (new and old). Plenty of tailgating fun around the house, everyone was super nice and welcoming. Shane was a great host, answered texts quickly and made sure we had what we needed. Highly recommend this place if the opportunity comes about, it just adds a little extra to a great Bills weekend. GO Bills!

Great place! Vicki was very friendly and communicative. The cottage was perfect for what we wanted - a family friendly Thanksgiving. The place has everything you need and we had an excellent experience. We barbecued and made s’mores at the fire pit. I suspect that during summer it’s even more fun given the warm weather amenities. We definitely would love to come back!

It was great staying at Thess’s place, she was responsive and friendly. It was very easy to get inside and we felt being home as a family. Patio was great and also sun room to hang out.

Very cute and cozy cottage right near the beach. The host was very responsive and helpful and the cottage was very clean, which we really appreciated. The location was great with the beach just a short walk up and across the road. We loved walking up and down the beach and went a few times a day — our golden retriever was in heaven. It was relaxing and peaceful and a lovely place to get away from the noise of the city for a few days.

Our stay was great! We were just passing through but it had everything we needed to be comfortable, plus more! The bed was incredibly comfortable and everything was very clean and easy to find. We would definitely stay again.

I recently stayed at the beach cottage and it was perfect for us. The check-in process was seamless, and Sarah provided clear instructions. Everything was clean, nicely decorated, and equipped with all the amenities we needed. Thanks again for your hospitality.

Very pleasant, albeit brief stay. Charming interior with great sunset views. And a note to all future renters, walk just 500 feet across the street to Avondale Dairy Bar for some of the best ice cream you'll ever eat.

Absolutely beautiful home!! This home worked great for our girls weekend. Lots of space and the backyard was so fun! Even with the rain this weekend we were so thankful for the inside space (specially that couch!). Probably one of the cleanest airbnbs I’ve ever been to. Thank you so much for letting us use your home, hoping we can come back next year!

The location for us was perfect, because it was pretty much between Niagara Falls and Niagara on the Lake. Depending on traffic, 15-20 minutes. The only downfall is it is right beside the 4 way stop in the resort, so you get a lot of traffic noise. Otherwise alll was great.

The location and house was perfect for our family. We had a great stay

Jasmine has a wonderful property in a beautiful park! Off season was so peaceful, but lots to do and see on weekends. The space is exactly as described, and is a great family friendly option for a getaway. Communication was always very prompt and friendly. We loved being able to take the golf cart around the park and having everything you need located inside the park is a huge plus. If I could leave 10 stars I would!

Great place! Very peaceful! Thanks again!!

New cottage in new section of Sherkston. Very private area with no rear neighbors. The cottage was very clean and well stocked. The golf cart was in great condition and fast. Would be happy to stay again in the future.

Paul is a fantastic host. He was very quick to respond for all my questions I had before we booked and leading up to our booking. We stayed with 16 adults in the house and there was plenty of beds and bathrooms for all of us. There was also plenty of parking available for us in the driveway. The house was very clean and well stocked. Instructions were very clear and easy to follow.

My family of four had a lovely time at Ann’s cottage. It’s a cozy little place conveniently located close to the beach, shops and restaurants. There’s a nice yard to relax in with a gazebo and fire table. Inside is comfortable even on hot days - the air conditioning and fans work well. We would love to visit again sometime!

Morgan and Nick’s place was beautiful and clean! It had all the amenities you’d need to feel comfortable and right at home. We were caught in a pretty bad snowstorm during our stay. The hosts were so gracious and let us check out late, whenever it was convenient for us!