House vacation rentals in Fire Island Pines

Great little place to stay right by the bay.

My family and I had a beautiful stay and I couldn’t have asked for a better rental. The Airbnb was huge with more than enough room for everyone and the backyard was large and spacious enough to have everyone eat comfortably. If I ever need another large rental you can bet I’m gonna check here first.

Very clean and confortable place a few minutes from the center of the village. Both bedrooms have king beds which is always a plus! Large yard and deck

Six of us flew in from all over the world to have a friend reunion here since it was the most convenient location for us all to meet up. The house was great for this occasion in that it is cozy, and conveniently located. Our favorite spot in the house was the sunroom with the wood burning stove since the weather was mostly gray and on the chilly side. The kitchen was the next most popular spot and was well equipped, better than most places actually. David and Claire provided clear check in and checkout guidance and were proactive in their communication with us. Thank you!

What an amazing home! Me, My husband and our dog spent a week there with another couple and their dog and it was absolutely the perfect home stay! Lots of space, bathrooms, towels, amenities, and even the most thoughtful additions like a Christmas tree and garland for the holidays! Got to use the hot tub which was perfect in a chilly day! Tons of entertainment throughout the home and they kindly had two sets of dog bowls for the pups! Will definitely try and stay again!! Thank you so much!

I was in Dion’s place with my family we really enjoyed the time we spent there,everything was perfect the pool was something that my kids enjoyed a lot, and hopefully we will come back again, for sure I totally recommend his house if you want to go and have a couple days of fun and relax thank you again Dion.

I have stayed at Jean Francois home several times. I always feel comfortable there. His home is spotless, easy to travel to, close to town, lot’s a great shops and restaurant’s and in a beautiful area. Jean Francois is also very friendly and responsive when I communicate. It’s a lovely space and I can’t wait to return!

I cannot describe accurately how lovely and comfortable Jonathons house is It was more than perfect for us in every way! The fenced in yard was perfect for our little dog and we all enjoyed turkeys and deer hanging out. Walking the neighborhood and to the beach with leaves changing It couldn’t have been any better.

I would definitely recommend it, very good area, everything clean.

Our stay was absolutely fantastic! The home was spotless, cozy, and exactly as described. The location was perfect for everything we had planned, and it truly felt like a home away from home. We wouldn’t hesitate to stay here again or recommend it to others. Thank you for making our trip such a memorable one!

We had an untimely passing in the family and we needed someplace to accommodate my family last minute and Felix was very understanding and worked with us to make our family time stress free. The place was clean and spacious enough for is to gather as a family during a very difficult time. I would recommend staying here.

Absolutely fantastic place in a perfect location on Fire Island. Maryann is also an incredible host—by far the smoothest communications process of any vacation rental I’ve stayed in. Would love to return to this place and check out some fantastic other properties she has. One word to the wise though— if you come early in FI offseason, there is a lot of maintenance work being done around town—-the neighbors across street somehow had someone power washing their fence for two days straight and there is some car traffic on the island. Not a dealbreaker but worth being mindful of…

We really loved staying here. Fantastic location, big patios, comfortable beds. Right by the beach. Grill, spices, speaker system indoor and big portable outdoor speaker. Two bathrooms, skylights... Big dining room table. Awesome spot! Thanks so much for having us.

What an amazing host. Jenns communication is spot on. She is very accommodating and was understanding and went above and beyond for our family. In the unusual situation that we were in, not only that, but she provided us with additional garbage bags and toilet paper and other things that we needed in the home, most hosts do not do that. her home is very warm and Welcoming and inviting and made us feel right at home. If I could rate her three hundred stars, I would, she is truly and honestly, a superhost.

Frank was wonderful to communicate with! The place was beautiful and quiet. Beautiful kitchen area, comfortable bed, and close to places to eat. We had a wonderful stay there. I would stay here again!

Very respectable, responsive and courteous couple! Proactive in solving your issues. Felt like home

I really enjoyed my stay I was very comfortable and the host was extremely nice I would definitely stay again

We had a wonderful stay at Nir’s home. It was very clean and welcoming. The pool was just lovely and much needed on some very warm days. Especially after working hard all day! The kitchen was very well equipped with everything you would need to cook gourmet meals! Nice large subzero refrigerator as well. Very spacious home and well designed for private areas. Air conditioning was fabulous as was hot water in the many bathrooms. Lots of towels for bath and pool .Beds we’re comfortable which was amazing. Close to parkways, grocery and gym. We felt very much at hime. Nir is an outstanding kind host and communicates very well if there is an issue. We hope to stay again in the future! I highly recommend Nir’s home!!!

Christina’s place is a lovely cottage by the marina and walkable into town. The main loft bedroom and sitting area is spacious and comfortable. We stayed for the holiday with our adult daughter and we were all comfortable and cozy. She had her own bedroom on the main floor. We thoroughly enjoyed our stay while we visited our family over the holiday.

What a great house! This was such a beautiful, clean and large space to spend time with the family. We loved the pool and the large kitchen - which was well equipped. Location was fantastic - super close to town and the ferry. The living room with the large couch was our favorite - it was bright, airy and overall a great space for us all to hang out. Instructions were also very clear and easy to follow. Brian was a great host, he checked in to make sure our stay was going well and was super responsive. I would not hesitate to stay here again!

I definitely recommend Hugh's home. It was very clean, exactly as described, and so close to everything!

My group had a wonderful stay. We felt right at home. The property was private and the house was clean. The backyard is beautiful with a great pool. Erol was responsive throughout our stay. I would stay here again!

John and his wife are excellent hosts. Their home is pristine with an abundance of amenities. The sunset on the bay is spectacular. I highly recommend. Thank you. Keith and Donna W.

AIi’s a great host. The house was as described, very spacious and well kept. Check-in was super easy as Ali sent me all the info 2 days before. The house is in a great location and everything is within driving distance. There’s also a YMCA 1 minute away which we used for workouts. Ali was also very responsive throughout our stay and made sure we were comfortable.