House vacation rentals in Fire Island Pines

My family and I had a beautiful stay and I couldn’t have asked for a better rental. The Airbnb was huge with more than enough room for everyone and the backyard was large and spacious enough to have everyone eat comfortably. If I ever need another large rental you can bet I’m gonna check here first.

We were in town for a baseball tournament. The place was in a great location, convenient to restaurants and the fields. The house was very quiet and comfortable for a family of 4. The pool looked nice but we didn’t get to use it due to colder weather and our schedule. The host responded quickly to our messages. Overall would recommend.

We had a great time in David and Claires beautiful house in Bellport. Such a nice place and perfekt location for daily trips by the coast with stops on the way out to the Hamptons. Or a daytrip to the city, close enough. Nice and quiet location, the house is very cosy and a lot of space for a bigger family or perfect for family reunion. We loved the ping pong table and other activitites as the pool, jacuzzi and the outdoors. If the weather had been better we would have used the facilities outside more for sure. We would love to come back to the house again. David and Claire are excellent hosts, very helpful and quick at responding.

My husband, our dogs, and I just returned home after spending a month at Sarah's house on Long Island. we truly didn't want to leave, it was so relaxing! The lousy May weather notwithstanding, the property was absolutely perfect for us. Everything was as described and we felt right at home. Sarah was super proactive/responsive. While we were only able to use the pool a couple of times (weather), it was great and the spa was awesome, especially in the evening under the pretty lights in the backyard! There were great spaces to work (hubby didn't have the full month off like I did) and to just chill. The house is located near many conveniences (I'm looking at you, Walmart) to pick up necessities and while we didn't cook for ourselves quite a bit, we were thrilled that unlike at home, the food delivery services were fast, reliable, and everything arrived at the perfect temperature! we can't say enough good things about our stay and will definitely be returning!

My group had a wonderful stay. We felt right at home. The property was private and the house was clean. The backyard is beautiful with a great pool. Erol was responsive throughout our stay. I would stay here again!

Paul is a great host. This is our 2nd time staying at Paul's home and it was just as wonderful as the first time. Clean, beautiful and in a lovely town. Paul is easy to communicate with and was thoughtful throughout the whole stay. We look forward to staying at Paul's home again in the future. Thanks Paul, for helping us with a wonderful weekend out east

Despite the rainy weather, we had for most of our stay, we were still able to enjoy our time in and out of the house. This home did not disappoint, very clean, well stocked and spacious. Open floor plan allows for easy conversation with all. Nice quite neighborhood. Village is quaint and in walking distance. We were able to use the pool and lounge area for one of our days. Due to the quite neighborhood it was nice to relax outside. Bellport Holidays did not disappoint. We are planning another trip next year. Thank you for offering such a beautiful home.

Great and responsive host. Home was lovely and we felt welcome. Host responded quickly to questions and requests. The home was very peaceful and relaxing. We really enjoyed the outdoor patio and pool area. I would recommend for a peaceful time away from the city.

This space was in a great location to many restaurants, bars, and the beach! David was quick to respond to our needs and the house was fully accommodated with bedroom, bathroom & kitchen supplies. We would definitely come back!!

We have stayed in many Airbnb's and this was in my family's top 3 so far. Vivia thought of everything from snacks for us when we arrived, to food and activity recommendations, to instructions for everything in and around the house. The place smelled good, felt clean, and was stocked with anything you could need to cook with. The location is private, secure, and incredibly well decorated. The ferry to New London was about an hour away and La Guardia was an easy drive of about an hour as well. We would definitely stay here again and recommend the place to friends as well.

This home was clean and well-maintained. It is in a quiet neighborhood. We would recommend staying here!

The house was spotless and exactly as described. Damion was incredibly welcoming and made check-in easy. A comfortable and pleasant stay—highly recommend!

Our stay at the house was wonderful experience. Our host Michael whom fortunately we met personally is one of the nicest person you’ll encounter in life. The surrounding and the grounds were so beautiful that you will enjoy when you stay at that house. Many thanks to our host and his well managed house. The place is very close to all lovely restaurants, shopping areas, etc. We all highly appreciated and recommend to stay at this place for any occasion and vacation. Thank you again and hopefully will stay in the future. Your guest Janneta 😀❤️

Everything was beautiful. It was exceptionally enjoyable to visit during the off season. We had the whole island to ourselves.

Perfect place for a weekend of beach walks !

One of the best stocked places I've ever stayed. There was no kitchen amenity that wasn't conspicuously provided.

If I could give a higher rating than 5 I would. This place was amazing to say the least. Better than I could have imagined. Amazing location, clean, beautiful, amazing hosts. The list goes on and on.

I really enjoyed my stay I was very comfortable and the host was extremely nice I would definitely stay again

This house is perfect. Great layout for groups and one of the cleanest AirBnBs I've ever stayed in - not just on Fire Island, but anywhere. Kenneth and Fred were great to plan with and made checking in early happen even after a little confusion. The house is a stunner - especially the outdoor/pool/hot tub space. I've never seen anything like it in the Pines. We will be back!

the house was extremely comfortable...quiet yet close to town and a 5 minute easy walk to the beach. it's a little small, with 2 bedrooms and 1 bath, but well-appointed. the pool is gorgeous. shawn was extremely responsive to any questions we had .

A Perfect Long Island Getaway! I had an incredible stay at this beautiful Long Island home. The property is truly stunning—it is nestled on a large pond with its own private waterfront and dockage. The views and relaxing atmosphere can't be put into words. We sipped our coffee by the water in the morning and really enjoyed the sunset from the deck. It truly felt like a retreat! The house itself is immaculate and thoughtfully stocked with the important amenities. From a fully equipped kitchen to comfortable beds and stylish decor, it’s clear the owner put great care into making sure guests feel right at home. The location is amazing--secluded enough to enjoy nature and privacy, but still close to everything you might want to explore. Whether you're into boating, relaxing, or just soaking up beautiful surroundings, we were pleasantly surprised at all there was to offer. The host Joe was responsive and made the whole process seamless. We miss it already and can't wait to go back!

Joey’s Fire Island home was a great weekend getaway from the city! It’s really close to the ferry (~5-7 min walk) and even closer to the beach (right across the main road!). The house itself has a ton of natural light and patio space (which I can imagine will be *perfect* for summer) and the second bathroom was convenient for having multiple guests with us. As a host - Joey was super sweet to keep us updated on ferry times to ensure a smooth arrival, and is the #1 in-the-know person for all the best things going on. Future guests will adore him!

Roberto was such a great host! The house was so cute and perfect for six people. It’s right off the water taxi stop, which was so convenient for getting to and from cherry grove (abt a 30 min ride to cherry grove, abt $20 per person). It’s also very close to a great beach. We would definitely stay again! Thank you Roberto!

My husband and I are FI regulars, and had a lovely beach weekend in Villa Etoile, located in OBP. It has a charming, welcoming atmosphere with two large outdoor decks, a well-equipped kitchen (we had everything we needed to cook), plenty of cozy spots (including a little bed for our dog!) and excellent beach accessories (chairs, towels, etc). The house is very clean. It's also ideally located: a super quick walk to the beach and just a hop away from the ferry and local hot spots like Schooner's, Flynn's, On the Way Cafe and Pantry. Even though it's a short trip in any direction, having access to the house's wagon was really helpful for carting things around. Chris was easy to communicate with and had clear instructions for everything. We loved the spacious lofted bedroom and high ceilings in the living room, which has lots of natural light. Even though we had some rainy weather during our stay, we had the perfect spot to chill inside. Thanks, Chris! We hope to come back.